Atheism requires as much faith as rel...

Atheism requires as much faith as religion?

There are 258469 comments on the Webbunny tumblelog story from Jul 18, 2009, titled Atheism requires as much faith as religion?. In it, Webbunny tumblelog reports that:

Atheism requires as much faith as religion? bearvspuma : The only problem with this rationalization is that ita s assuming all athiests are so because theya re intelligent in the ways of science and reasoning and all people that believe in a form of god are unintelligent.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at Webbunny tumblelog.

Since: May 10

Location hidden

#158528 Mar 4, 2013
Aura Mytha wrote:
<quoted text>
Natural selection leads to speciation , and that IS evolution.
This has also been observed, so your scientist that denies evolution is willfully ignorant.
I mentioned nobody denying evolution.

I also agreed that natural selection is a component of evolution.

The claim was that natural selection IS evolution.

It is not.

Do you have a disagreement that is not wildly ignorant?

Since: May 10

Location hidden

#158529 Mar 4, 2013
River Tam wrote:
<quoted text>
Or, in your case, genetic mutation was not necessarily from natural selection.
It's an anomaly.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v =CkOfeSNsWpMXX
Spoken like the little punk you are.

“ad victoriam”

Since: Dec 10

arte et marte

#158530 Mar 4, 2013
Buck Crick wrote:
<quoted text>
You and Aura are wrong. Again.
If you go back and read my comment, you will see that it refers to the theory of evolution "as stated".
I accept evolution, and so do the scientists I referred to. I believe it occurred and continues to occur.
Maybe you need to read it 3 times.
Do you and Aura have some criticism to offer that is not wildly ignorant?
I'll let you in on something - it is not only possible to dissent from portions of a popular theory, while not rejecting it entirely, but it is also healthy.
I do, however, apologize to exposing you and Aura to the painful and alien concept of free thought.
Mea culpa.
http://www.topix.com/forum/topstories/TUGI0DV...

“What?”

Since: Oct 10

Location hidden

#158531 Mar 4, 2013
Buck Crick wrote:
<quoted text>
Spoken like the little punk you are.
Yep

:-)

Since: Mar 11

Scottsburg, IN

#158532 Mar 4, 2013
Well you could play the blob with zero special effects needed.
Buck Crick wrote:
<quoted text>
Spoken like the little punk you are.

“A sentient umbrella speaks”

Since: Mar 11

Some stable somewhere

#158533 Mar 5, 2013
Buck Crick wrote:
<quoted text>
There are also atheists and agnostics in science who do not accept the theory of evolution as stated, nor abiogenesis. They object on scientific and logical grounds.
Yeah. What, 4? 10?

I've read the links you've posted to the ID stuff, gone through the court transcripts - none of their statements were compelling. Few of them seemed to understand what natural selection was and how it worked - very similar to how you incorrectly describe it, actually.

To be honest, Buck, there's a lot of scientists in my field who don't actually get how evolution works. So I'm not surprised that some scientists might object to it - it's a matter of not comprehending it, not being satisfied with how the theory is incorrectly and illogically implemented sometimes.

I was at an evolutionary anth seminar and one women's presentation, I just wanted to stand up and say "clearly you don't know what you're talking about and the rest of us are embarrassed for you. Could you stop?"

“A sentient umbrella speaks”

Since: Mar 11

Some stable somewhere

#158534 Mar 5, 2013
Buck Crick wrote:
<quoted text>
You added another component to natural selection to get what you claim is evolution. That's my point - natural selection is not evolution.
I agree natural selection is the proposed mechanism of evolution.
But it is not evolution.
Passing the trait that allowed survival is in no way a different process than if the trait had not aided survival. That is simple reproduction.
Nothing in the example offered yet is evolution.
Natural selection is not evolution. If it were, we would have no use for the term "evolution". We would simply say the process of natural selection gives us our biologic diversity.
If you divorce science from logic, it ends up being mush - which is what attempts to describe evolution has become.
I'm not sure why you're not understanding my words. I never wrote that natural selection was THE mechanism of evolution. I wrote:

natural selection is a mechanism of evolution. It is the mechanism which produces adaptation.

I'm assuming you're confused b/c some other poster is telling you that natural selection IS evolution. It's not. It's just one mechanism of many. I would never write that it is the only mechanism.

If we might get a bit more advanced in this conversation? What we call "mechanisms of evolution" aren't really as separate as the categories that we constructed here - those "mechanisms" are merely for our benefit, so that we can parse nature into recognizable and therefore understandable pieces. But nature is messy; it's not so neatly organized.

“A sentient umbrella speaks”

Since: Mar 11

Some stable somewhere

#158535 Mar 5, 2013
Buck Crick wrote:
<quoted text>
You will take whatever you're told.
David Berlinski:
'Darwin,' Richard Dawkins has remarked with evident gratitude,'made it possible to be an intellectually fulfilled atheist.' This is an exaggeration, of course, but one containing a portion of the truth. That Darwin's theory of evolution and biblical accounts of creation play similar roles in the human economy of belief is an irony appreciated by altogether too few biologists."
The same can easily be said about what Berlinski believes - which isn't actually capable of being tested scientifically.

Since: Sep 08

Westcliffe, CO

#158536 Mar 5, 2013
The mind and body can go separate ways. Dreams, NDEs, hypnosis, and exercising of will need to be explained better to support the belief that mind is all of the physical body.

Those last two are mental disciplines done on an individual basis. Hypnosis and going into trances overrides the body. People have been known to cut their own arms and legs off to survive, as have some animals. This is pretty high order thought for just the mind being a slave of the body.

How can such mental discipline be passed down in genes?

Richardfs

“Formerly "Richard"”

Since: Mar 12

In the beginning e=mc^2

#158537 Mar 5, 2013
Dave Nelson wrote:
The mind and body can go separate ways. Dreams, NDEs, hypnosis, and exercising of will need to be explained better to support the belief that mind is all of the physical body.
Those last two are mental disciplines done on an individual basis. Hypnosis and going into trances overrides the body. People have been known to cut their own arms and legs off to survive, as have some animals. This is pretty high order thought for just the mind being a slave of the body.
How can such mental discipline be passed down in genes?
Your mind and body separated years ago but never rejoined.

“What?”

Since: Oct 10

Location hidden

#158538 Mar 5, 2013
Dave Nelson wrote:
The mind and body can go separate ways. Dreams, NDEs, hypnosis, and exercising of will need to be explained better to support the belief that mind is all of the physical body.
Those last two are mental disciplines done on an individual basis. Hypnosis and going into trances overrides the body. People have been known to cut their own arms and legs off to survive, as have some animals. This is pretty high order thought for just the mind being a slave of the body.
How can such mental discipline be passed down in genes?
People have been know to put a bullet in their head too. High order thought? Fight or flight is a good bedtime story. There is also another choice. Not everybody cares about life, Dave. It is what it is until it isn't. Not a big deal.

Since: Sep 08

Westcliffe, CO

#158539 Mar 5, 2013
To demonstrate how sharp the Topix atheist mind is.

I have posted my NDE at least 3 or 4 times over the last couple of years. Wasn't exactly one that you could call a religiously inspired one. Not that such stopped Topix atheists from ranting about how I'm such a godbot and fundamentalist,yada, yada, yada.

Not a one of them took note of the fact I didn't cry out to a higher power to come get me.

Topix atheists have mental issues with obsession. paranoia, and projection.

Since: Sep 08

Westcliffe, CO

#158540 Mar 5, 2013
River Tam wrote:
<quoted text>
People have been know to put a bullet in their head too. High order thought? Fight or flight is a good bedtime story. There is also another choice. Not everybody cares about life, Dave. It is what it is until it isn't. Not a big deal.
You are wandering off track, there.

I still have guns I bought from the widow of a guy that left his brains all over his office walls that she had to clean up. That was because he couldn't see any escape from the debts and life he had created in his head. But he had the will to do it.

It is not all fight or flight. This exercise of will is done all the time. Conquering the body as in heavy exercise to political ambition.

“I see quantum effects”

Since: Jan 11

In the macro world.

#158541 Mar 5, 2013
Dizzy wrote:
I'm not sure why everyone care so much about religion... Who cares what someone else believes in? So atheist don't believe in deity's it's not that big of a deal! And so Christians and other religions have God(s)... People care to much. If everyone would stop judging others for what they do/believe the world would be a much nicer place... If you believe that's fine! If you don't that's fine too!!


And we could easily agree with that if religion didn't try to dictate science in public schools or create laws based on biblical falsehoods.

Believe what you want. But many of us are tired of religion interfering in our daily lives.

It's only with the advent of the internet that the atheist voice is starting to be heard. Before that, we were pretty much muzzled by religious hatred. I still can't talk to most of my family about my atheism without creating major rifts.

I love them for who they are, religion and all, but I can practically guarantee that if I spoke my thoughts on religion, I would be irrevocably cast out.

Why is that?

“What?”

Since: Oct 10

Location hidden

#158542 Mar 5, 2013
Dave Nelson wrote:
To demonstrate how sharp the Topix atheist mind is.
I have posted my NDE at least 3 or 4 times over the last couple of years. Wasn't exactly one that you could call a religiously inspired one. Not that such stopped Topix atheists from ranting about how I'm such a godbot and fundamentalist,yada, yada, yada.
Not a one of them took note of the fact I didn't cry out to a higher power to come get me.
Topix atheists have mental issues with obsession. paranoia, and projection.
You live with people. You die alone.

It's a personal experience Dave.

I was hit by a large metal object too, Dave. I lost my leg and neither of us died. When we do, look me up. I'll be the Asian girl with one leg.

“What?”

Since: Oct 10

Location hidden

#158543 Mar 5, 2013
Dave Nelson wrote:
<quoted text>
You are wandering off track, there.
I still have guns I bought from the widow of a guy that left his brains all over his office walls that she had to clean up. That was because he couldn't see any escape from the debts and life he had created in his head. But he had the will to do it.
It is not all fight or flight. This exercise of will is done all the time. Conquering the body as in heavy exercise to political ambition.
It only matters if you care. Do you care?

If you do, stop talking about your NDE or OBE and start getting on with your life.

Or not.
Imhotep

Miami, FL

#158544 Mar 5, 2013
Aerobatty wrote:
<quoted text>
And we could easily agree with that if religion didn't try to dictate science in public schools or create laws based on biblical falsehoods.
Believe what you want. But many of us are tired of religion interfering in our daily lives.
It's only with the advent of the internet that the atheist voice is starting to be heard. Before that, we were pretty much muzzled by religious hatred. I still can't talk to most of my family about my atheism without creating major rifts.
I love them for who they are, religion and all, but I can practically guarantee that if I spoke my thoughts on religion, I would be irrevocably cast out.
Why is that?
Easy as 1-2-3

1. Keep your religion out of our lives..
2. Keep religious dogma out of government.
3. Cease attempting to force your beliefs on others.

You will never never hear about atheism again.

Since: Sep 08

Westcliffe, CO

#158545 Mar 5, 2013
River Tam wrote:
<quoted text>
You live with people. You die alone.
It's a personal experience Dave.
I was hit by a large metal object too, Dave. I lost my leg and neither of us died. When we do, look me up. I'll be the Asian girl with one leg.
A very mature statement you made there in the first sentence. You had good influences in your younger years to shape your high intelligence. You have some bitterness, but it will pass as you mature even more.

You can bet I will be looking you up when that time comes, but I won't be looking for an Asian girl with one leg.

I lost a life, little one, but got another one. More to it than you know.

Since: Sep 08

Westcliffe, CO

#158546 Mar 5, 2013
River Tam wrote:
<quoted text>
It only matters if you care. Do you care?
If you do, stop talking about your NDE or OBE and start getting on with your life.
Or not.
I bring it up only as an example of the mind having a link to some place else besides the body. I got over it a long time ago.

You prefer I let these idiots rant on about mind and spirit being strictly a material thing? Why would I do that?

Explain how humans have such an ability to override the material if we are strictly a product of it.

Since: Sep 08

Westcliffe, CO

#158547 Mar 5, 2013
http://www.santafenewmexican.com/Local%20News...

Sounds like something Topix atheists under stress will gravitate to.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Atheism Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News "Science vs. Religion: What Scientists Really T... (Jan '12) 16 min Aura Mytha 69,957
News Atheism, for Good Reason, Fears Questions (Jun '09) 5 hr 15th Dalai Lama 30,111
News Tampa Teacher @LoraJane Hates Christians, Promo... 6 hr orlando 434
News Atheism and cowardice (Nov '11) 10 hr Roy 12,673
News Nonsense of a high order: The confused world of... 11 hr yehoshooah adam 3,779
Evidence for God! (Oct '14) 18 hr superwilly 579
News The rise of militant atheism (Sep '09) May 21 online reality bu... 9,236
More from around the web