you missed my point as always, why do you think that the hadiths are still opened for categorization ?? its not a coincidence..!! for instance Al Albani raised up so many hadiths from Weak to Sahih and took down some Sahih Hadiths to weak, science of Hadith depends on what we get on narrators , thus some Hadiths remained Sahih (sound) for decades and others remained Weak or Hasan until a Hadith scientist gets new information that wasn't known to others and so on, Different Hadiths and different actions adds flexibility to Islam.<quoted text>
There are many scholars who converted to and from Islam - no big deal. Had Mohammad perfected the religion of Islam, there would be no need for hadiths & sunnahs. How do you know that a sunnah or a hadith is not fabricated? What means of varification do you have other than reading books written by people 250 years after the fact? You can't even prove that the Koran we have today is verbatim the same Koran dictated by Mohammad. Only your allah would know how much of the Koran actually comes from Mohammad. Even Ishaq's sira was written 150 years after Mohammad's demise and that too was edited by his student Ibn Hisham. BTW, this "bismillah rehman & rahim" bares resemblence to the Zoroastrian invocation of God.
This rumour that people memorized the Koran during Mohammad's lifetime is only a claim done in order to mask the dubious circumstances under which Koran came into existence.
Al Jarh Wa Al Tadil isnt a game, its has a very accurate method and depend on several factors.
the Quran was memorized by Mohammed companions and was written down on different materials and were kept away, But Mohammed ordered his companions not to write down his sayings (Hadiths) to make sure that the Quran won't be mixed with his sayings.
And where exactly did you get from That Hadiths were only written down after 250 years of the death of Mohammed ??!!
many Companions wrote Mohammed sayings during his life, it turned out that Mohammed gave permission to specific companions to write Hadiths and forbade some, During caliph Abu Bakr Time Muslims were busy with (Al Redda Wars) and after the death of Abu bakr , Umar decided not to gather Mohammed sayings (Hadiths) because he was afraid that Hadiths will be mixed up with Quranic verses until Caliph Umar bin Abd Al Aziz (99 Hijri) ordered to gather Hadiths , So hadiths were basically collected after 88 years of Mohammed's death because Mohammed died in 11 Hijri .
Umar bin Abd Al Aziz gathered what was already written by people in The Medina.