I'm not talking about the Big Bang theory as I have stated many times.
I am discussing what was there when there was "no" Time, Space, Matter & Energy. In other words what existed when there was no Big Bang or Big Bang after math. And please no "north of the North Pole statements". Shlts getting old.[/QUOTE]
Only because you continue to ignore the point.
No.Does a 2 dimensional plane really exist?