Sorry I'm not here much and often miss replies to my posts,
Actually it is not 'an atheist thread on the RC Forum'. What happens is that the same thread is listed on many forums. In this case the tread is on the RC and Atheist forums and maybe others.
Actually Ed , this IS an atheist thread on a Roman Catholic Church forum, regardless of whether your posts appear elsewhere this thread is unique by virtue of its ongoing dialogue. That is what makes it a thread you silly billy.