Thinking

Yeovil, UK

#2484 Feb 11, 2013
Me neither. I just wonder if Archimedes accepted that.
polymath257 wrote:
<quoted text>
Given the pi is transcendental, and probably a normal number (digits essentially random), I'm not convinced a more definite method is possible. I also doubt the continued fraction expansion is 'regular' in any reasonable way.

“Think&Care”

Since: Oct 07

Location hidden

#2485 Feb 11, 2013
Thinking wrote:
Me neither. I just wonder if Archimedes accepted that.
<quoted text>
Well, Archimedes would not have known about the irrationality of pi, let alone the fact that it is transcendental (or have even understood what it means to be transcendental). The irrationality of pi wasn't known until the middle of the 18th century AD and the transcendence of pi not until 1882.
Thinking

Yeovil, UK

#2486 Feb 11, 2013
Agree with the points about 1761 and 1882. He may have suspected something was up though, whatever the reason. Archimedes knew for example that root 3 was proving to be a problem to represent as a fraction.
polymath257 wrote:
<quoted text>
Well, Archimedes would not have known about the irrationality of pi, let alone the fact that it is transcendental (or have even understood what it means to be transcendental). The irrationality of pi wasn't known until the middle of the 18th century AD and the transcendence of pi not until 1882.

“It's just a box of rain...”

Since: May 07

Knoxville, TN

#2487 Feb 11, 2013
polymath257 wrote:
<quoted text>
Egyptian fractions were unwieldy and were not used in other places. The Biblical results were probably obtained from the Babylonians.
I don't think there was any calculation involved. They were describing the pool, not analyzing it. As such, they wouldn't have taken one measurement and then calculated the other, but would have measured them both. The inaccuracy simply shows how crude those measurements were.

I've never taken a very close look at the history of math--maybe it's time to do that. Somehow, I doubt that the early Hebrews will play much of a role in it, though.
Thinking

Yeovil, UK

#2488 Feb 11, 2013
Maybe that's why their walls kept falling down...
NightSerf wrote:
<quoted text>
I don't think there was any calculation involved. They were describing the pool, not analyzing it. As such, they wouldn't have taken one measurement and then calculated the other, but would have measured them both. The inaccuracy simply shows how crude those measurements were.
I've never taken a very close look at the history of math--maybe it's time to do that. Somehow, I doubt that the early Hebrews will play much of a role in it, though.

Since: Apr 12

Location hidden

#2489 Feb 11, 2013
polymath257 wrote:
<quoted text>Why would you think that is the problem in the Bible? The number pi was not singled out as a number of independent interest for a few hundred years; the goal was to find the circumference given the diameter. Given that as the problem, if the 10 is a rounded value, then the rounded value of the circumference could be anywhere from 30 to 33.
In today's math yes. If you don't have fractions or decimal points and use elbow to finger tip as a ruler then 30 cubits would be accurate because Pi could and would only be "3".

Since: Mar 11

Lexington, KY

#2490 Feb 11, 2013
Archimedes was an interesting dude light years ahead of his time. Facinating genius.
polymath257 wrote:
<quoted text>
Well, Archimedes would not have known about the irrationality of pi, let alone the fact that it is transcendental (or have even understood what it means to be transcendental). The irrationality of pi wasn't known until the middle of the 18th century AD and the transcendence of pi not until 1882.

Since: Mar 11

Lexington, KY

#2491 Feb 11, 2013
The ancient Egyptians were an interesting lot. Check out Dr. Kara Cooney a cutie MD on the subject of ancient Egyptians.



Smart and cute!
NightSerf wrote:
<quoted text>
I don't think there was any calculation involved. They were describing the pool, not analyzing it. As such, they wouldn't have taken one measurement and then calculated the other, but would have measured them both. The inaccuracy simply shows how crude those measurements were.
I've never taken a very close look at the history of math--maybe it's time to do that. Somehow, I doubt that the early Hebrews will play much of a role in it, though.

Since: Apr 12

Location hidden

#2492 Feb 11, 2013
Givemeliberty wrote:
<quoted text> http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Egyptian_fract...

Indeed you are correct! No need for people of that time to round up or down or only use while numbers. The ancient Egyptians amongst other cultures were using fractions long before the genesis myth was written.
Givemeliberty wrote:

I am especially proud of my volunteer work and donations to the humanist cause. Every year I go to the Philippines and spend thousands on food,water, clothing and medicine for the needy there. After a horrific typhoon and flooding there I was there amongst others 14 hours a day handing out supplies, giving life saving injections and treatments to those who lost their home. I stood and watched as homeless children lined up easily 3 miles deep for a package of crackers sandwich fruit and bottle of water. Unwanted children who were born because the Christian ran theocracy light government makes it nearly impossible for a woman to obtain birth control. My wife is in pre-med classes and wants to practice medicine there free to help those poor children. Here in the states I collect donations for running in marathons with the money going to children's charities and cancer or HIV awareness programs.
I have seen first hand time and time again the damage and heart breaking situations brought on by theists. The same theists who come crawling to us to help fix their mess! Oh but while we are fixing it are we thanked? Nope. We barely get the figurative broom in hand and they are shrieking at us for not believing in their imaginary friend.
Honor? I guess it is a relative term. The dozen of urban low income students I assist for free with their biology and pharmaceutical homework at two different colleges locally would probably say good ole KJ is an alright dude.
Now if coming on topix and giving the theists a little taste of backbone, the theists who try to intimidate and silence non believers because they think we should all be meek and humble and tolerate their abuse and repeated logical fallacies makes me vile, Without reason, Disrespectful, In someone's opinion? So be it, hmmm I will chuckle about how vile And disrespectful I am Friday at U of L for the 6 hours I am assisting the students there as a volunteer. Or perhaps this summer as I am passing out thousands of dollars worth of free medicine and other essentials trying to save some more homeless from dying. Yes I was walking by a group of people there and they were huddled together praying loudly and crying. I looked in and a young girl was on the ground dying of dehydration. Instead of getting her water and rushing her to the hospital they stood there holding hands and praying! I grabbed my cell phone and called for an ambulance and started trying to get her to drink. Slowly she sipped the water as the praying continued. The ambulance came after almost an hour and reluctantly took her to the hospital, the paramedic said she was good as dead and best leave it in the hands of Jesus same thing the crowd thought. She died 18 hours later. They didn't even know her name and couldn't figure it out.
I guess I'll somehow deal with being called disrespectful.
<quoted text>

"I semi-retired except for collecting and inspecting my rental properties. I live comfortably off my stock dividends, porn sites I own, early retirement from work and rental properties here in the states and in the Philippines. "

OMG. It's getting better all the time!!!

You're retired except for Porn and your wife is still in school!

You give Christians thousands of dollars of your own money!!!!

Baaaaahaaaaaahaaaaa
Please stop!!!!

Lol BAAAAAHAAAAHAAAAA !!!!

Liberty wrote:
I am a 32 year old multi-racial man with a Johnson bigger than anyone in your family.

Since: Apr 12

Location hidden

#2493 Feb 11, 2013
Thinking wrote:
<quoted text>Civilisations were using fractional approximations to pi long before your POS bible was invented.

Your bible was already out of date when the goatfuckers wrote it.
Blood presser check time!

LOL

Since: Mar 11

Lexington, KY

#2494 Feb 11, 2013
Blood what? Presser? Keep scampering into stupidity.
Langoliers wrote:
<quoted text>
Blood presser check time!
LOL
Thinking

Yeovil, UK

#2495 Feb 11, 2013
Oh dear. You're a sandwich short of a full picnic, aren't you, poppet?
Langoliers wrote:
<quoted text>
Blood presser check time!
LOL

Since: Apr 12

Location hidden

#2496 Feb 11, 2013
Thinking wrote:
<quoted text>Oh dear. You're a sandwich short of a full picnic, aren't you, poppet?
LOL!

Too many ants!

Since: Dec 12

Location hidden

#2497 Feb 11, 2013
Thinking wrote:
If you went trick or treat you're part of the occult? No.
<quoted text>
If a person participates in holidays that derived from the worship of ancient gods then yes they in one

haloween comes from the worship of the dead.or all souls day
the celts worshipped the dead but when the so called christians came in,instead of telling the people they couldn't worship theirs god they just names all saints day or halloween.

the celebrations of these holidays remain the same as what they derive from.

when you celebrate your birthday,that has its roots of ancient worship, the egyptians believed their rulers were gods and they would celebrate their birth.
also romans and greeks believed that everyone had a protective spirit or daemon around them when they were born so in order to protect them they would gather there family members and shower them with gifts and giving them well wishes, they also made a lot noise to ward off the bad spirits.

Remember each society was conquerd by another an they took on their gods and traditions.

Don't take my word for it look it up for yourself.
New world encylepedia or go to the library an look for the book ancient gods.

if you participate in this you are just carrying on the tradition.its pegan or cult or whatever you choose to call it.

Since: Mar 11

Lexington, KY

#2498 Feb 12, 2013
Yes and the entire Jesus myth in the bible was stolen from the same pagan gods. The entire thing. Saying amen at the end of a prayer is a praise to the Egyptian god Amen Ra.

I bet your cult magazine the watchtower left that info out didn't it?

Speaking of pagan go look at the grave of Taze Russell the founder of the JW cult. It doesn't look very Christian does it? More like a Horus worshipper.
Yellowknightmare wrote:
<quoted text>
If a person participates in holidays that derived from the worship of ancient gods then yes they in one
haloween comes from the worship of the dead.or all souls day
the celts worshipped the dead but when the so called christians came in,instead of telling the people they couldn't worship theirs god they just names all saints day or halloween.
the celebrations of these holidays remain the same as what they derive from.
when you celebrate your birthday,that has its roots of ancient worship, the egyptians believed their rulers were gods and they would celebrate their birth.
also romans and greeks believed that everyone had a protective spirit or daemon around them when they were born so in order to protect them they would gather there family members and shower them with gifts and giving them well wishes, they also made a lot noise to ward off the bad spirits.
Remember each society was conquerd by another an they took on their gods and traditions.
Don't take my word for it look it up for yourself.
New world encylepedia or go to the library an look for the book ancient gods.
if you participate in this you are just carrying on the tradition.its pegan or cult or whatever you choose to call it.

“My hand is over my crotch.”

Since: Jan 10

It's time to put it to use

#2499 Feb 12, 2013
Givemeliberty wrote:
Yes and the entire Jesus myth in the bible was stolen from the same pagan gods. The entire thing. Saying amen at the end of a prayer is a praise to the Egyptian god Amen Ra.
I bet your cult magazine the watchtower left that info out didn't it?
Speaking of pagan go look at the grave of Taze Russell the founder of the JW cult. It doesn't look very Christian does it? More like a Horus worshipper.
<quoted text>
Don't forget Christmas, another pagan holiday stolen by Christatrds.

Since: Jun 07

Location hidden

#2500 Feb 12, 2013
Langoliers wrote:
<quoted text>
In today's math yes. If you don't have fractions or decimal points and use elbow to finger tip as a ruler then 30 cubits would be accurate because Pi could and would only be "3".
Pi never has and never will be 3. You're a f*cking idiot, just the same as the idiots who thought Pi was 3. Other parts of the world figured it out thousands of years before you idiots wrote that rubbish down.
Thinking

Yeovil, UK

#2501 Feb 12, 2013
Spell check?
Yellowknightmare wrote:
<quoted text>
If a person participates in holidays that derived from the worship of ancient gods then yes they in one
haloween comes from the worship of the dead.or all souls day
the celts worshipped the dead but when the so called christians came in,instead of telling the people they couldn't worship theirs god they just names all saints day or halloween.
the celebrations of these holidays remain the same as what they derive from.
when you celebrate your birthday,that has its roots of ancient worship, the egyptians believed their rulers were gods and they would celebrate their birth.
also romans and greeks believed that everyone had a protective spirit or daemon around them when they were born so in order to protect them they would gather there family members and shower them with gifts and giving them well wishes, they also made a lot noise to ward off the bad spirits.
Remember each society was conquerd by another an they took on their gods and traditions.
Don't take my word for it look it up for yourself.
New world encylepedia or go to the library an look for the book ancient gods.
if you participate in this you are just carrying on the tradition.its pegan or cult or whatever you choose to call it.

Since: Mar 11

Lexington, KY

#2502 Feb 12, 2013
Oh the Christholes steal everything they can even if it's nailed down like their Jewsus.
emperorjohn wrote:
<quoted text>
Don't forget Christmas, another pagan holiday stolen by Christatrds.

Since: Apr 08

London, UK

#2503 Feb 12, 2013
polymath257 wrote:
<quoted text>
Granted. The first *theoretical* calculation of pi was by Archimedes around 200BC. He obtained 3+10/71 <pi<3+1/7. The latter is the oft-used 22/7 for the approximation.
How sloppy of the supreme being of our universe - his magnum opus contains a less accurate ratio for Pi than that worked out by Archimedes.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Atheism Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Atheism to Defeat Religion by 2038 (Apr '12) 21 min Dak-Original 22,991
Atheism requires as much faith as religion? (Jul '09) 52 min Adam 230,011
Islam for peace, or violence? 2 hr JIN 36
Does Being 'Spiritual But Not Religious' Really... 3 hr Thinking 2
Our world came from nothing? 4 hr Thinking 1,037
Adam Atheoi - the god of 'humanity' Mon Thinking 90
Man center of the universe. Mon Thinking 87

Atheism People Search

Addresses and phone numbers for FREE