Local: Los Angeles, CA  (change)

 | 

Join the Topix community today: 

Sign Up

 | 

Sign In

Advertisment
Religion

Oct 31, 2007

Sikhs demand justice in 1984 anti-Sikh riots

“Earlier, on the orders of the Congress, people used to boycott us, but now the situation is gradually improving as people reciprocate our good deeds and good behaviour”

Sikhs on Wednesday took out protest rallies in different parts of the country, demanding justice in the 1984 anti Sikh riots. via AndhraNews

Read All 372 Comments

Comments

Showing posts 1 - 20 of 372
« prev | next »
Go to last post | Jump to page:
thewaywewere
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1
Nov 1, 2007
 
there is evidence that it was state sponsored terror..can be considered "genocide"..is there comparison to Jews and Germany during 2nd world war
Kaur
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#2
Nov 1, 2007
 

Judged:

1

thewaywewere wrote:
there is evidence that it was state sponsored terror..can be considered "genocide"..is there comparison to Jews and Germany during 2nd world war
Yea, it can be described as genocide, but the problem is that their is no factual evidence of the 1984 riots. I mean it obviously occurred, but in other words there are no historical recordings of the 1984 riots and there are no books that describe the 1984 riots. I think the evidence was burned or something. At least people today are recognizing the event. There was actually a movie created about it this year.....I think it was called Amu. I saw it and it sucked, it really didnt really describe the 1984 riots properly, I felt like it left some stuff out, but then again the director was a Bengali guy and he really doesn't seem like he knows enough about Sikhs and Sikhism. Im just happy that people today are able top recognize this event and see how terrible it was.
thewaywewere
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#3
Nov 2, 2007
 
Kaur wrote:
<quoted text>
Yea, it can be described as genocide, but the problem is that their is no factual evidence of the 1984 riots. I mean it obviously occurred, but in other words there are no historical recordings of the 1984 riots and there are no books that describe the 1984 riots. I think the evidence was burned or something. At least people today are recognizing the event. There was actually a movie created about it this year.....I think it was called Amu. I saw it and it sucked, it really didnt really describe the 1984 riots properly, I felt like it left some stuff out, but then again the director was a Bengali guy and he really doesn't seem like he knows enough about Sikhs and Sikhism. Im just happy that people today are able top recognize this event and see how terrible it was.
i guess there was no jounals..look at times and us news there is record.....were international media barred from delhi

Joined: Aug 5, 2007
Comments: 1906
mumbai........india
ISP Location: Bombay, India
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#4
Nov 3, 2007
 

Judged:

1

the sikhs shud get justice
True indian
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#5
Nov 3, 2007
 
Why u support khalistan if u didnt support it than nothing would be happened in 1984.......

Same thing to gujarat 2002 if muslims didnt do that godhra kand with hindus than nothing would be happend...

Dont think only about urself first think why this is happened in our country than think about justice and other things.....

Joined: Aug 5, 2007
Comments: 1906
mumbai........india
ISP Location: Bombay, India
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#6
Nov 3, 2007
 
abe madarchod bhenchod randi ke bache kutte haarami gaay mata ka moot pine wale insan , teri maa ko sab sikhs milkar rape kar diye hai shayed , abe muje ek baat bata indira randi ko jin sikhs ne mara , unko saza do na , yeh kaunse kitaab main likha hai ki , indira ko sikh ne mara to sab sikho ko maaro , ab jyada bhoonk mat randi ke bache bahut ho gaya , chal fuuut

Joined: Aug 5, 2007
Comments: 1906
mumbai........india
ISP Location: Bombay, India
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#7
Nov 3, 2007
 
mahatama gandhi ko bi ek hindu marathi ne mara tha , to fir tum kutte hindu sab marathi hindus ko kyu nahi maar dete , ek banda ki galti se poore religion ke logo ko marega , abe jaa apni randi gaay mata ka moot pi bhenchod
True indian
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#8
Nov 3, 2007
 

Judged:

1

Read my comments in india forum...fool khalistani...Mahatma gandhi ko jisne mara tha vo marathi nahi tha vo hindustani tha...he dont want to divide india...samja...sale khalistani..

Marathis are better than sikhs..they are part of united india...they r hindus...they dont want to divide india and make other country maharashtra like u to make khalistan from india...

How dare u to compare hindus with foolish khalistani sikhs...
Mr Naga
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#9
Nov 3, 2007
 
proud sikh munda wrote:
abe madarchod bhenchod randi ke bache kutte haarami gaay mata ka moot pine wale insan , teri maa ko sab sikhs milkar rape kar diye hai shayed , abe muje ek baat bata indira randi ko jin sikhs ne mara , unko saza do na , yeh kaunse kitaab main likha hai ki , indira ko sikh ne mara to sab sikho ko maaro , ab jyada bhoonk mat randi ke bache bahut ho gaya , chal fuuut
lol. The real proud sikh munda has had enuff!
mard singh
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#10
Nov 3, 2007
 

Judged:

1

True indian wrote:
Read my comments in india forum...fool khalistani...Mahatma gandhi ko jisne mara tha vo marathi nahi tha vo hindustani tha...he dont want to divide india...samja...sale khalistani..
Marathis are better than sikhs..they are part of united india...they r hindus...they dont want to divide india and make other country maharashtra like u to make khalistan from india...
How dare u to compare hindus with foolish khalistani sikhs...
-You are an idiot and shit hole. Sikhs are also part of the united India.Hindus of N Modi in Gujrat and fascists of Mombai are the scum of the earth. Khalistan, was a nut, chauvinist Hindus used a sledge hammer to crack.Problems of Gujrat are created by Hindus and not by Moslems( I hate Islam). The train which was set on fire, in which some Hindus died was actually set on fire by Hindus themselves so they could kill Moslems. And you call yourself true Indian. I. Gandhi was killed by 2 Sikhs, what crime did the innocent Sikhs, who were killed by the Hindu scum, commit.Before you try to post any reply, think of all the contributions Sikhs have made and are still making for the united India.
BY THE WAY I AM AGAINST KHALISTAN .
True indian
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#11
Nov 3, 2007
 

Judged:

1

I am agreeing with u sikhs even muslims are also part of india....why u take me wrong....i m against sikhs who r khalistanis muslims who r pakistanis..

Who told u train was burned by hindus....are they fool they will burn themselves.....u r sick like lalu yadav so told like this....

Everybody in gujarat knows that muslims did that ..i was in gujarat at tht time so dont tell me wht is right...and please read my reply in india forum..

Jab tere ghar me koi marega minorities ke through tab muje batana samja sale bina dimag ke.....
thewaywewere
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#12
Nov 3, 2007
 
True indian wrote:
Why u support khalistan if u didnt support it than nothing would be happened in 1984.......
Same thing to gujarat 2002 if muslims didnt do that godhra kand with hindus than nothing would be happend...
Dont think only about urself first think why this is happened in our country than think about justice and other things.....
your reasoning is bull shit..what you are saying is german nazi had the right to kill all the jews.grow up..or you will go to jail..political process does not mean genocide..and delhi riot had nothing to do with khalistan..you are a bigot show should be tried in haig for war crimes..you wrre there in delhi's carnage..sonds like it..do not dare travel to USA
thewaywewere
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#13
Nov 3, 2007
 
TRUE INDIAN..DO YOU KNOW THE MEANING OF WAR CRIMES....IT IS A VERY PAINFUL PROCESS...REMEMBER YOU HINDU
Kaur
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#14
Nov 3, 2007
 
thewaywewere wrote:
<quoted text>
i guess there was no jounals..look at times and us news there is record.....were international media barred from delhi
Yea, sure, there is a record, but every time the Indian government is questioned they just pretend like it never happened.
True indian
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#15
Nov 3, 2007
 
thewaywewere wrote:
TRUE INDIAN..DO YOU KNOW THE MEANING OF WAR CRIMES....IT IS A VERY PAINFUL PROCESS...REMEMBER YOU HINDU
I dont know very much about punjab riots in 1984 but i know gujarat riots becoz i was there in gujarat at that time....muslims killed 60 hindus they burned them in train..........this is fact whtever lalu prasad said was election stunt tht train was burned by themselves are they fool tht thy burned themselves..so it was just election stunt from lalu yadav.....train was burnt by muslims and without support of local muslim of godhra this would not be happend

So at that time in 2002 the anti islam atmosphere was created and whtever hapenned was totally wrong...i really dont like this..but u dont know abut the atmosphere at tht time......it was really very dangerous for muslims.....and whtever happend was wrong.....but u cant say it was only hindus falut whteever was happend becoz of that godhra incident..

So i just want to tell minorities that we r 85 crores in india(80% of total population) are yar thodi izzat karo hamari i mean hindus ki tum log usike desh usko zinda jalaoge to reaction to ayega......u understand wht i mean to say....koi tumhare ghar me ake tumhe marega to kesa lagega u can imagine same thing happend to gujarat hindus....and 2002 was reaction of that...

So my conclusion is that muslims and hindus are equally responsible for that whtever happend in gujarat becoz without the help of local muslims this wouldnt be happend and this was started by muslims this is also true.....u cant deny that....

After this also if u cant understand wht i want to say than i thinkk u r from congress..who can only think about minorities for them majority 85 crores are nothing....thats all.
thewaywewere
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#16
Nov 3, 2007
 
True indian wrote:
<quoted text>
I dont know very much about punjab riots in 1984 but i know gujarat riots becoz i was there in gujarat at that time....muslims killed 60 hindus they burned them in train..........this is fact whtever lalu prasad said was election stunt tht train was burned by themselves are they fool tht thy burned themselves..so it was just election stunt from lalu yadav.....train was burnt by muslims and without support of local muslim of godhra this would not be happend
So at that time in 2002 the anti islam atmosphere was created and whtever hapenned was totally wrong...i really dont like this..but u dont know abut the atmosphere at tht time......it was really very dangerous for muslims.....and whtever happend was wrong.....but u cant say it was only hindus falut whteever was happend becoz of that godhra incident..
So i just want to tell minorities that we r 85 crores in india(80% of total population) are yar thodi izzat karo hamari i mean hindus ki tum log usike desh usko zinda jalaoge to reaction to ayega......u understand wht i mean to say....koi tumhare ghar me ake tumhe marega to kesa lagega u can imagine same thing happend to gujarat hindus....and 2002 was reaction of that...
So my conclusion is that muslims and hindus are equally responsible for that whtever happend in gujarat becoz without the help of local muslims this wouldnt be happend and this was started by muslims this is also true.....u cant deny that....
After this also if u cant understand wht i want to say than i thinkk u r from congress..who can only think about minorities for them majority 85 crores are nothing....thats all.
english please...or translate...anyone who is willing to take this topic lightly as some has....go look up war crimes, genocide, state sponsored terrorism...if you do not know..keep quite on this topic and just go read about it before mouths are open..including Joy bangla
thewaywewere
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#17
Nov 3, 2007
 

Judged:

1

True indian wrote:
Read my comments in india forum...fool khalistani...Mahatma gandhi ko jisne mara tha vo marathi nahi tha vo hindustani tha...he dont want to divide india...samja...sale khalistani..
Marathis are better than sikhs..they are part of united india...they r hindus...they dont want to divide india and make other country maharashtra like u to make khalistan from india...
How dare u to compare hindus with foolish khalistani sikhs...
your racism is oozing out...control it and it is apparent that you feel inferior to sikhs..when out of taken in context of being out of south asia..per capita sikhs are most succesfull..it is the fact...1.8% of india, the rest are mulims and hindus.......grow up or shut up

Joined: Aug 5, 2007
Comments: 1906
mumbai........india
ISP Location: Bombay, India
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#18
Nov 4, 2007
 
there were no riots in punjab , true indian dog , sikhs were only butchered in delhi , if you are so proud of being an indian and think only hindus dominate in india , go to punjab and say that to a sikh , face to face , tab tuje pata chalega ki hindu ki indian punjab main kitna power hai ,

Joined: Aug 5, 2007
Comments: 1906
mumbai........india
ISP Location: Bombay, India
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#19
Nov 4, 2007
 
True indian wrote:
<quoted text>
I dont know very much about punjab riots in 1984 but i know gujarat riots becoz i was there in gujarat at that time....muslims killed 60 hindus they burned them in train..........this is fact whtever lalu prasad said was election stunt tht train was burned by themselves are they fool tht thy burned themselves..so it was just election stunt from lalu yadav.....train was burnt by muslims and without support of local muslim of godhra this would not be happend
So at that time in 2002 the anti islam atmosphere was created and whtever hapenned was totally wrong...i really dont like this..but u dont know abut the atmosphere at tht time......it was really very dangerous for muslims.....and whtever happend was wrong.....but u cant say it was only hindus falut whteever was happend becoz of that godhra incident..
So i just want to tell minorities that we r 85 crores in india(80% of total population) are yar thodi izzat karo hamari i mean hindus ki tum log usike desh usko zinda jalaoge to reaction to ayega......u understand wht i mean to say....koi tumhare ghar me ake tumhe marega to kesa lagega u can imagine same thing happend to gujarat hindus....and 2002 was reaction of that...
So my conclusion is that muslims and hindus are equally responsible for that whtever happend in gujarat becoz without the help of local muslims this wouldnt be happend and this was started by muslims this is also true.....u cant deny that....
After this also if u cant understand wht i want to say than i thinkk u r from congress..who can only think about minorities for them majority 85 crores are nothing....thats all.
true indian u have proved that u r deservingly the biggest idiot here , since u call the anti-sikh riots as punjab riots , the riots happened in delhi where the sikhs form just a mere 4 % population , so stupid of u to tink dat punkin narrow minded hindus can enter punjab and kill the sikhs there , dream on

Joined: Aug 5, 2007
Comments: 1906
mumbai........india
ISP Location: Bombay, India
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#20
Nov 4, 2007
 
and sob , indira gandhi was killed cuz wid her orders our golden temple was partially destroyed , indira gandhi was killed by her indian bodyguards who were sikhs , and not khalistanis , wat crap justification are you giving for the eruption of the riots ,
Showing posts 1 - 20 of 372
« prev | next »
Go to last post | Jump to page:
Type in your comments to post to the forum
Name
(appears on your post)
Comments
Type the numbers you see in the image on the right:

Please note by clicking on "Post Comment" you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Other Recent Religion Discussions
Topic Updated Last By Comments
Roman Catholic church only true church, says Va... (from Jul '07) 6 min disciple 48841
Catholic Church Waging War on Women and Gays (from Oct '07) 8 min Michael 40268
Church of Scientology wants Gizmo building 8 min Agent 41
Brooklyn pastor Jim Cymbala featured speaker at... (from Apr '07) 8 min Hi Carmen 436
La Herencia: Griegos were early Spanish pioneers 9 min Zarusthra 30
Who Is Allah? 10 min Sound Doctrine 2526
Pope warns of futility of money, careerism in t... 11 min Cathoholic 12
Related Topix Forums: World News, India, Sikh