Your Call: Should Canadiens sign or t...

Your Call: Should Canadiens sign or trade Subban?

There are 16 comments on the TSN.ca story from Jan 24, 2013, titled Your Call: Should Canadiens sign or trade Subban?. In it, TSN.ca reports that:

The Montreal Canadiens and restricted free agent defenceman P.K. Subban appear no closer to agreeing on a new contract, and as the club continues to play games without one of their top blueliners, the possibility of the club trading Subban if they can't sign him is becoming a point of conversation.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at TSN.ca.

mike

Trois-rivières, Canada

#1 Jan 24, 2013
Trade him....He has become a distraction on the club.

“HEISENBERG”

Since: Apr 09

MONTREAL

#2 Jan 25, 2013
My call...WAIT

he's LOADED with talent ~

Not unless we get a Tier 1 Defensman for him at the very least...

also I just wouldn;t do it, it;s thr wrong move after 3 games

They claimed they're TOP priority was signing him...BULLSH!T !!!

thjey've been rail roading the guy since he got here and holding him back as well !

Rrade him now it will 100% Bit Us Back On The Ass !!!

Wait !

Make another better offer,

wait some more,

That's the move here.

and if even 1 guy, say Markov goes down, and they don't have him there...they're fucked !!!

and right now I'd rather have PK than Markov, Markov has proven 1 thing in 12 years, he can now string two halfway decent games together, and that's it...

P.K> is a Beast of consistency, he is constantly fast, and constantly tough !!!

we need these things !!!

“HEISENBERG”

Since: Apr 09

MONTREAL

#3 Jan 25, 2013
also,

The Habs Haven't played anyone yet !!!

The Leafs, Panthers and Caps are all shit this year !!!

seriously people...wake up !!!
Ryan W

Toronto, Canada

#4 Jan 25, 2013
Honestly , if what i have been reading is true , i say make him sit the year . See if a good offer comes in . He does not deserve a long huge contract yet . He does still have a lot to prove . I have no doubt he will prove it , but its too early ( he is only 23) to lock him up for a 8 year deal for big money .

This is what i would like to see and believe it would be the fairest deal . It would show some give from the habs and some bend on subban . A 3 year contract . Pay him 2.5 million for this season( since it is short and he ahs already missed time ). Next year , pay him 3.5 million and for the 3rd year pay him 4-4.5 million . If at the end of that deal he pans out to be the stud d-man we all think he is , he will be 26 , just hitting his prime and then we sign him for a 6-8 year deal . 5-6 million a season . This is the best deal i see and if he really wants to stay in montreal as he says , then he will bend a bit for a home town discount .
Jeff

Canada

#5 Jan 25, 2013
Im a habs fan for life, but pk has hade one good playoff. He doesn't deserve 5 plus million. I would like to see a 3 year deal at 10.5 million. If he does well give him a 6 year deal at 32.5 ( like what Vancouver did for edler) . If we trade him I really don't see us getting full value.

“HEISENBERG”

Since: Apr 09

MONTREAL

#6 Jan 26, 2013
by that logic tough neither does Price

Look folks the bottom one is this

IN 50 YEARS THERE HASN'T BEEN BUT ONE OTHER ROOKIE DEFENSEMAN COME INTO THE LEAGUE AND MAKE AS BIG A SPLASH INSTANTLY AS PK DID AND THAT'S BOBBY ORR...PERIOD !!!!

all i am saying is if you deal this guy you need to do it for something worthy of what we are giving away,

and CLEARLY what we are giving away here is a future Superstar !!!

You CANNOT argue he has done nothing, he has DONE TEN FUCKING TIMES , NO, TEN THOUSAND TIMES MORE IN ONE FUCKING YEAR THAN CAREY PRICE HAS DONE IN 6 !!!
mike

Trois-rivières, Canada

#7 Jan 26, 2013
Subban has had run ins with Hall gill,martin,the assistant coach,the last coach....has come late to meetings,practice. lets just say that he needs to develop between the ears as much as he needs to develop on the ice. Last year his penalties hurt the team alot. Hes got flash...flash does not guarantee superstar.I see him (in light of what i read between the lines) right now as a liability. He will grow out of this but at what cost to the team.
Labatts

Havelock, Canada

#8 Jan 26, 2013
Yeah..I wouldnt Sh8t the bed yet....Bergevin is just playing it smart and sending a message....
If Montreal keeps winning then the rush to sign him wont be so crucial... Bring up some more youth and see what they got..

I agree he's good, and let him loose to play...but he needs to keep the pesty mouth shut..Hes a target out there...hes not that good of a fighter...so he needs to just concentrate playing and playing tough but shut the F8ck up....I hate pesty big mouth players who cant back it up...hes one of them...
hawk

Boucherville, Canada

#9 Jan 26, 2013
Spartacus1962 wrote:
also,
The Habs Haven't played anyone yet !!!
The Leafs, Panthers and Caps are all shit this year !!!
seriously people...wake up !!!
U got it right man; funny how crazy & so quick to forget, THE GUY WORED LIKE A BEAST LAST YEAR FOR A LOSER TEAM1 Mtl fans are I tell u are something else LOL; All excited after beating some low level teams and thinking markhov has the capability to perform as he did all year long!! MTL FANS SUCKS, IF I WAS HOCKEY PLAYER U COULD NOT PAY ME TO PLAY FOR MTL..

“HEISENBERG”

Since: Apr 09

MONTREAL

#10 Jan 26, 2013
all respectable opinions you guys !!!

labatt's one thing you said resonates, if they keep winning, it'll be moot !!!
labatts

Kinmount, Canada

#11 Jan 27, 2013
hawk wrote:
<quoted text>
U got it right man; funny how crazy & so quick to forget, THE GUY WORED LIKE A BEAST LAST YEAR FOR A LOSER TEAM1 Mtl fans are I tell u are something else LOL; All excited after beating some low level teams and thinking markhov has the capability to perform as he did all year long!! MTL FANS SUCKS, IF I WAS HOCKEY PLAYER U COULD NOT PAY ME TO PLAY FOR MTL..
I dont think its the fans that suck....more like the owner and his decisions. Years of bad drafting, coaching and G.Ms has put this team where it is today!!

Now Molson didnt own this team through all of the tail spin...but he needs and has begun to make changes....he just needs to step out of the 70's and into the new millium and set new traditions and make new HISTORY....

The only fault of the fans is they pay for all of the above...
If I was able to play hockey at that level...I would die to play for the habs....if your a true hab fan HAWK you would play to...

If you want to make millions and millions of dollars you need to play hard everynight and perform.....maybe thats why so many players choose not to come to the greatest city with the greatest sports team in the world..To much is expected....

“HEISENBERG”

Since: Apr 09

MONTREAL

#12 Jan 28, 2013
very well said imho
:-)
dmc

Monkland, Canada

#13 Jan 28, 2013
Trade him to a team in the Western Conference.

With the schedueling this year, the Habs would not see him until next year.
mike albrecht

United States

#14 Jun 21, 2013
Keep him. Norris trophy winner. No one can do what he can do. Molholvich type player. Need more.
mike albrecht

United States

#15 Jun 21, 2013
He's a keeper you nuts. He's a norris. Winner. Need more like him. Our d is to slow and small. More big gritty players. 2 way with speed brains. ringo. Tombstone az. Ps draft smart. For need

“HEISENBERG”

Since: Apr 09

MONTREAL

#16 Jun 21, 2013
THANKS MIKE
IMHO HE AND GALLAGHER ARE THE ONLY 2 ON THE ROSTER RIGHT NOW WORTH KEEPING AT ALL !!!
:-)

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

NHL Hockey Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News What's left for Chicago Blackhawks? Forward thi... Feb 16 TimePhartse 2
you should have seen the bald middle age guy tr... Feb 11 blackhawks 1
News Inquiries continue into highway fatalities in S... (Mar '13) Feb 8 Salmon Phart 4
wild penguins.. sorry. funny. haha! Jan 26 smile 1
News NHL Rumors: Latest Buzz on Players Potentially ... (Jun '14) Jan '18 WhenPhartss 3
News Sens' Bobby Ryan out with another hand injury, ... Jan '18 Hand phartx 2
mid season NHL predictions Jan '18 My Pearls Of Wisd... 1
More from around the web