Off Topix: Hawkins clerk of courts su...

Off Topix: Hawkins clerk of courts sues anonymous blogger

There are 118 comments on the Kingsport Times story from Jan 9, 2013, titled Off Topix: Hawkins clerk of courts sues anonymous blogger. In it, Kingsport Times reports that:

One Hawkins County official who was a victim of malicious false allegations of infidelity on a popular Rogersville online forum last year wants cyber bullies to know there is no such thing as total anonymity on the Internet.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at Kingsport Times.

First Prev
of 6
Next Last

Morristown, TN

#105 Jan 16, 2013
Freedom of Speech. Just hope it keeps the truth going. There is a lot of shit that is true would not be brought up if someone had to use their name. There are plenty of things that need to be brought up and no one should have to use their name. The Big shit heads that dont want people to know what is going on is the ones that an end to topix. People stand up for the Truth and let people expose things that needs exposing.

Jefferson City, TN

#106 Jan 16, 2013
Thats my thing, she won the election, is still married( which if a topix thread ended your marriage... Well, it might have been doing a person a favor).... What was she out? What suffering had it cost her, from a legal standpoint?

Not sure anything can be proven harmful. It was gossip but what happens when the "named" person says "I heard it from blah blah"... Does it keep going down the chain of hearsay?
Like someone else posted, how they going to prove who posted... If from work computer or family computer then there would be multiple suspects. Consider wireless routers, I pick up my neighbors...

Like I have stated... I don't think I could support her next election. Not because what the thread said, i knew more than likely it was bullshat because it was on topix...but how she has reacted to the thread. Just my humble opinion.
voice of reason

Cookeville, TN

#107 Jan 16, 2013
My father once told me: "You can never underestimate the (American) public."

One minute reading Topix posts proves him right.

You go, Sarah. I support you all the way!

Charlotte, NC

#108 Jan 16, 2013
This topix keeps going and going. Just like a toy... the engerizer bunny toy... remove the battery and this topix would be dead.

Gate City, VA

#109 Jan 17, 2013
If this lawsuit is sussessful I can just picture the headlines...."BARACK OBAMA HIRES NOTED ROGERSVILLE ATTORNEY"
"Lawsuit being prepared against internet posters who falsely claimed Obama is a Muslim and born in Kenya".

Chuckles !!
Yo Mama Obama

United States

#110 Jan 17, 2013
Overtaxed wrote:
If this lawsuit is sussessful I can just picture the headlines...."BARACK OBAMA HIRES NOTED ROGERSVILLE ATTORNEY"
"Lawsuit being prepared against internet posters who falsely claimed Obama is a Muslim and born in Kenya".
Chuckles !!
Lies and more lies I once read on here that I would try to introduce more controls on guns and some even said I would try to take guns away from citizens. Of course there is no truth to that.
But I do want stronger background checks on gun purchasers.( of course I don't like background checks on Presidential candidates )

Praise Allah (who? me I ain't no Muslim.Would I lie about it?)

“You know they all....pretend”

Since: Nov 08

Flush 'em out, TN

#111 Jan 18, 2013
Hey Nonny!
Ya reckon ol' Bill would represent you and I, since these mean ol' people have trashed us so bad over the years?
chuckles and snickers

Morristown, TN

#112 Jan 18, 2013
If she wins or dont win i never vote for her again. If Ol Bill gets a lot of the bull shit said about him too which is embarrasing and he wants it stoped for his sake and use miss prissy as a decoy. His wife was a Davis someone said they were kin to the Ol Bill. hummmm it makes sense.

Kingsport, TN

#113 Jan 19, 2013
Way to go Ms. Davis glad you are standing up for what is right. As we all know, you cannot do wrong and get by with it. The mean, jealous bloggers WILL always be payed back in some form. In my opinion, posting lies on someone is alot more than gossiping. Good people stand up and be heard!!!

Johnson City, TN

#114 Jan 19, 2013
thts just it.. was what was posted all lies about her or could it be she got caught and need's someone to take a knife wound for her reputation ???? for so little tht was posted and tagged to her name she has really acted like a spoiled immature brat.. I would not want to be employee for her if she is this whinny... standing up for herself .ha more like needing attention to settle her on dust

“Pond's warmin' up!!!”

Since: Sep 12


#115 Jan 19, 2013
moparedtn wrote:
Hey Nonny!
Ya reckon ol' Bill would represent you and I, since these mean ol' people have trashed us so bad over the years?
Brilliant....But...your'all just frogsinapond ya know!!!!*snicker* right back atcha!

Dandridge, TN

#116 Jan 23, 2013
A Nonny Mouse wrote:
Two aspects of the case appear a bit sensationalistic.

I totally don't believe the lawyers claim that his posts were auto-deleted one minute after posting. Sounds like a typical lawyer tactic to infer that he and his client are "being picked on" once again, this time by the owner of a big bad website.

The other thing I don't believe is the assertion on her part that comments posted on here can be marriage-ending, and how lucky she is that her husband was "understanding". I don't know about you, but if comments were posted on this site about me having sex, my spouse would just get a good laugh, not sue for divorce. As would the majority of others.

As a public official, she has a higher burden of proof for libel. She has to prove specific intent to do damage rather than simply go after someone who brain-farted a slanderous comment all over their keyboard.

Sounds to me she isn't trying to win, but rather uncloak the poster for her personal knowledge and send a "chill" through the forum here. And there is plenty wrong with any public figure who thinks its their job to intimidate the public into biting their tongue.
sandy is that u?

Charlotte, NC

#117 Jan 23, 2013
Has the poster's name been released?
Queen Victoria

Columbia, SC

#118 Jan 25, 2013
I think that the lady doth protest too much.

Bristol, TN

#119 Jun 19, 2013
I never knew his lady, never heard of her, never heard of this cry baby. To be honest this is what Politics is all about, if she cant take the shit talking then you dont need to be in politics. All this does is make her look weak and definatley not the type of person that can go everyday and ignore the gossip, when in that position you have to be able to ignore all the gossip and keep your head up and go on with your life, thats a good politician, yet most of the lie so i dont know what good that is but alteast they are following the correct morale that is expected of a politician. you didnt hear Bill clinton whine and cry about the lewinsky ordeal, he just sucked it up and eventually admitted to it. oh well, and people still like him. I personally would not ever vote for someone who makes these kind of lawsuits, It shows no back bone.

Bristol, TN

#120 Jun 19, 2013
Clarksville man wrote:
<quoted text>
I live in Clarksville, Tx and the ones you are talking about did haul them into court. Awarded a 13 million dollar judgement and it was overturned by another judge. So the Plaintiffs got nothing but huge legal bills. They already knew who was doing it but did get the ip's identified through court order.
Those people gave up their home/ranch, a million dollars and counting all just to sue people on topix and LOSE the lawsuit. This is very crazy, they were rich, they were millionaires who didnt have to worry about anything yet they got on topix and got mad over rumors and threw it all away. I hope that lesson hits the hearts of all the rich folk with too much money and too much time on their hands.

Sevierville, TN

#121 Nov 9, 2013
ANY one know.
How it Ended

Johnson City, TN

#122 Nov 9, 2013
Her lawyer told her she had a great case, and then proceeded to bill her for every hour, every phone call, every letter, all which she had to pay for.

Topix, receiving a warrant, turned over the ip address of the poster.

Since most ISPs in the area use dynamic address allocation, this ip address likely led to a dead end.

Even if it could have been tied to a specific household at the time, many people use wifi in their houses and don't set a password, thus anyone in their neighborhood could have posted it.

It's almost impossible to tie these things to a specific person unless one is very fortunate, such as the person posted from work, they don't have wifi there, and they said specific enough things to identify themselves.

Without these factors, launching such a law suit just gets you a bunch of legal bills.

But what about the lawyer saying there is a case? That is what lawyers say. They say you have a case, and then they bill you for every minute they work, rounding UP to the next quarter hour for each 2 minute phone call.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 6
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Topix Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Bisexual 51 min Flashg199 17
A-Z of "ANY WORD" that comes to mind! (Sep '12) 56 min Princess Hey 394
I SEND NUDES FOR FUN KIKME@ hazeliciouzzz 13 hr hazeliciouzzz 1
Myth or not White Male Privilege 14 hr PolySci Guy 10
1st Time Filipino Girl goes To USA & This Happe... 16 hr KuntyVag 1
Why do black women hate white women? (Nov '14) 18 hr qwerty 16
Fun chat 23 hr Keyanna 2
More from around the web