The Sexual Fetish of Gay Marriage Opp...

The Sexual Fetish of Gay Marriage Opponents

There are 263 comments on the www.slate.com story from Mar 22, 2013, titled The Sexual Fetish of Gay Marriage Opponents. In it, www.slate.com reports that:

As the Supreme Court prepares to hear Hollingsworth v. Perry and United States v. Windsor, opponents of same-sex marriage have scrambled to answer the central question: What is the government’s rational interest in preventing gays from marrying? The standard argument from moral disapproval was revoked by Romer v. Evans and Lawrence v. Texas. The argument that gay marriages undermine the family has been debunked by a decade of same-sex marriage in several countries. So, as Proposition 8 and DOMA wound their way through the courts, gay marriage opponents lit upon a more durable argument, seemingly grounded in science rather than animus or religion. Their case, presented most comprehensively by Princeton professor Robert P. George, is that only sex acts with a “dynamism toward reproduction” — that is, penile to vaginal intercourse — create true marriages and lead to legitimate child-rearing. Same-sex marriages, by this theory, are not “real” marriages, because they do not involve “organic bodily union.”

Editor's note: so I guess all infertile heterosexuals are also denied legal marriage then?

Join the discussion below, or Read more at www.slate.com.

“unstoppable”

Since: Jul 11

Hell

#269 Mar 27, 2013
Polly wrote:
<quoted text>
Is that how you started out? Or was you a closet queer like most are. Sounds like you know from experience, otherwise you couldn't possible know whether or not they have sex with men. That's why they are called, closet queers, they hide that fact.
You sure have a fascination:
Polly wrote:
<quoted text>
Hey big boy, will you suc:k my d!ck for a pizza?
Quest

Drakes Branch, VA

#271 Mar 27, 2013
The Worlds Biggest Lie wrote:
<quoted text>
One might ask Lides his opinion if it's appropriate for 40 something year old men to have 'affairs' with high school sophomore girls.
Why ask such an off topic question? Gay folks aren't responsible for the inapproriate behavior of straight men.

And our legal marriages won't increase the incidence of such behaviors in strauight people.
The Worlds Biggest Lie

Huntington, MA

#272 Mar 27, 2013
Quest wrote:
<quoted text>
Why ask such an off topic question? Gay folks aren't responsible for the inapproriate behavior of straight men.
And our legal marriages won't increase the incidence of such behaviors in strauight people.
Oh but they do affect the inappropriate behaviors of straight men AND women through pornography. Many vviolent criminals and murderers have been exposed to lesbianism through porn. This degrades and demeans women more than a 'normal' male and female engaged in intercourse.
If it didn't affect ANYBODY then why has homosexuaity rarely been portayed often on television or in movies? You can't claim people are being "homoophobic" and then say this has NO affect on anybody at all. This dangerous lifestyle is being wrongfully projected upon our youth for decades, and it shows.

Cha-Ching!!!

“unstoppable”

Since: Jul 11

Hell

#273 Mar 27, 2013
The Worlds Biggest Lie wrote:
<quoted text>
Oh but they do affect the inappropriate behaviors of straight men AND women through pornography. Many vviolent criminals and murderers have been exposed to lesbianism through porn. This degrades and demeans women more than a 'normal' male and female engaged in intercourse.
If it didn't affect ANYBODY then why has homosexuaity rarely been portayed often on television or in movies? You can't claim people are being "homoophobic" and then say this has NO affect on anybody at all. This dangerous lifestyle is being wrongfully projected upon our youth for decades, and it shows.
Cha-Ching!!!
What a whiner you are!
The Worlds Biggest Lie

Huntington, MA

#274 Mar 27, 2013
This could be made law of the land tomorrow and yet it will never end or be enough, for children is and always has been the main goal. Just like NAMBLA.

Roberta Kaplan has an unusual speech impediment.
Sodomy has a funny way of affecting people.

“unstoppable”

Since: Jul 11

Hell

#275 Mar 27, 2013
The Worlds Biggest Lie wrote:
This could be made law of the land tomorrow and yet it will never end or be enough, for children is and always has been the main goal. Just like NAMBLA.
Roberta Kaplan has an unusual speech impediment.
Sodomy has a funny way of affecting people.
Honey, you are the one who is so affected!
The Worlds Biggest Lie

Huntington, MA

#276 Mar 27, 2013
_Olive_ wrote:
<quoted text>
Honey, you are the one who is so affected!
Well, you are a social disease, so I guess you got one right today.

“No Headline available”

Since: Jan 08

Defiance, Ohio

#277 Mar 27, 2013
Francisco dAnconia wrote:
hey idjit, did you see the quote from oral arguments relying on that very case?
my your not to bright...
I just wanted to point out your idiocy, not play pete and repeat again so try away but FYI, that "superseded case" was cited in oral arguments yesterday dumbass...
Another ad hominem and no real argument. Feel free to keep proving that you are a bigoted fool. You are clearly incapable of rticulating an intelligent arguement against equal protection as required by the 14th amendment.

If you really are a lawyer, which I find doubtful, I feel sorry for your clients. I wouldn't retain you to argue against a parking ticket.

“HAVE A HAPPY 4TH OF JULY”

Since: Aug 08

WEEKEND:-)

#278 Mar 27, 2013
lides wrote:
<quoted text>
Another ad hominem and no real argument. Feel free to keep proving that you are a bigoted fool. You are clearly incapable of rticulating an intelligent arguement against equal protection as required by the 14th amendment.
If you really are a lawyer, which I find doubtful, I feel sorry for your clients. I wouldn't retain you to argue against a parking ticket.
LOL:-)

“No Headline available”

Since: Jan 08

Defiance, Ohio

#279 Mar 27, 2013
NorCal Native wrote:
LOL:-)
They are more than a few French fries short of a happy meal. Then again, what should one expect from a purported lawyer who frequently refers to legal decisions that have been superseded by legislation, and seem utterly incapable of constructing an argument in support of the irrelevant clip quotes.

Honestly, I'm not certain they have the wherewithal to be a paralegal.

Since: Mar 07

Location hidden

#280 Mar 28, 2013
The Worlds Biggest Lie wrote:
<quoted text>
Oh but they do affect the inappropriate behaviors of straight men AND women through pornography. Many vviolent criminals and murderers have been exposed to lesbianism through porn.....!
Again, why re you blaming gay folks for the bad behavior of straight folks? And if you think "lesbian porn" is about, or created by, lesbians, you are delusional.

It also begs the question as to why heterosexual murders and violent criminology turned that way through viewing two straight women pretending to have sex on camera.

Since: Mar 07

Location hidden

#281 Mar 28, 2013
The Worlds Biggest Lie wrote:
<quoted text>
.
If it didn't affect ANYBODY then why has homosexuaity rarely been portayed often on television or in movies? You can't claim people are being "homoophobic" and then say this has NO affect on anybody at all. This dangerous lifestyle is being wrongfully projected upon our youth for decades, and it shows.
Cha-Ching!!!
That didn't make sense. Are you trying to say that since the majority of characters on TV aren't gay, that gay people are bad as a result?

And why would the married lifestyle be bad for ANY family? Why would marriage and family life be a bad thing to "project" onto our straight AND gay youth?

Since: Mar 07

Location hidden

#282 Mar 28, 2013
The Worlds Biggest Lie wrote:
This could be made law of the land tomorrow and yet it will never end or be enough, for children is and always has been the main goal. Just like NAMBLA.
Roberta Kaplan has an unusual speech impediment.
Sodomy has a funny way of affecting people.
You are a bit confused. People marry because they love their spouses and want to form strong families, not because they want to harm innocent children.

Can you tell us the numbers of active members of nambla, and the percentage of the male and female gay population who support it, and prove that support for it increases when people marry?

Or, are you just throwing out anything you can think of and hoping to hurt others by it?

Since: Mar 07

Location hidden

#283 Mar 28, 2013
The Worlds Biggest Lie wrote:
<quoted text>
Well, you are a social disease, so I guess you got one right today.
Humans cannot be a social disease. But irrational behaviors like bigotry and homophobia certainly are.

Fortunately, they are becoming less and less prevalent within our society, giving gay kids a better chance in life, and allowing all gay citizens the same equality under the law that is cherished by every American.
2nd hand poker

Huntington, MA

#284 Mar 28, 2013
Quest wrote:
<quoted text>
Humans cannot be a social disease. But irrational behaviors like bigotry and homophobia certainly are.
.
But I thought you said this has no affect on other people?
Young Teen Love

Huntington, MA

#285 Mar 28, 2013
lides wrote:
<quoted text>
They are more than a few French fries short of a happy meal. Then again, what should one expect from a purported lawyer who frequently refers to legal decisions that have been superseded by legislation, and seem utterly incapable of constructing an argument in support of the irrelevant clip quotes.
Honestly, I'm not certain they have the wherewithal to be a paralegal.
Lides, what is your 'opinion' and do you find that men in their 40's having affairs with sophomore high school girls as being appropriate behavior?

“HAVE A HAPPY 4TH OF JULY”

Since: Aug 08

WEEKEND:-)

#286 Mar 28, 2013
2nd hand poker wrote:
<quoted text>
But I thought you said this has no affect on other people?
It doesn't.......my legal marriage has had no affect on you or your marriage(if married).....just as your marriage(if married) has had no affect on mine!!!
Dr Raquel Madcow

Huntington, MA

#287 Mar 28, 2013
NorCal Native wrote:
<quoted text>
It doesn't.......my legal marriage has had no affect on you or your marriage(if married).....just as your marriage(if married) has had no affect on mine!!!
Then why was there a commercial on Super Bowl Sunday suggesting that "homophobia" is a real problem and should be 'treated'
Why do most homosexuals assert people disagreeing with them as homophobic, suggesting that INDEED there is a problem here.
Hmmmmm???

“HAVE A HAPPY 4TH OF JULY”

Since: Aug 08

WEEKEND:-)

#288 Mar 28, 2013
Dr Raquel Madcow wrote:
<quoted text>
Then why was there a commercial on Super Bowl Sunday suggesting that "homophobia" is a real problem and should be 'treated'
Why do most homosexuals assert people disagreeing with them as homophobic, suggesting that INDEED there is a problem here.Hmmmmm???
I'd say because of the comments made by other NFL players about playing with an out and open Gay football player is why the Super Bowl ad was done!!!

Personally, I don't care if you agree with me or not, but when people fight to make sure that I am not treated like an American Citizen and try to treat my marriage differently, then yes.....those folks can be considered homophobic.......just by the definition!!!

Frankly, everyone knows why Prop 8 and DOMA were put into place......and it has to do with how folks feel about Gays and Lesbians.......sorry, but moral disapproval is NOT legal grounds to discriminate against a class of individuals!!!

Uve

Since: Nov 12

Location hidden

#289 Mar 28, 2013
Dr Raquel Madcow wrote:
<quoted text>
Then why was there a commercial on Super Bowl Sunday suggesting that "homophobia" is a real problem and should be 'treated'
Why do most homosexuals assert people disagreeing with them as homophobic, suggesting that INDEED there is a problem here.
Hmmmmm???
You're a perfect example of the real problem of homophobia..How many names have you used on here POS coward? Maybe you should go back watching TV for the meaning of your sorry a$$ life.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Gay/Lesbian Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Same-sex marriage fight turns to clerk who refu... 6 min marriage redefined 294
News Gay marriage opponents propose 2 Colorado ballo... 22 min NorCal Native 18
News Governors vow to fight SCOTUS ruling on gay mar... 22 min WasteWater 699
News Malloy takes lead in fight for gay rights 26 min WasteWater 3
Which Brand Of Douch Does NE Jade Use? 29 min WasteWater 5
News Clerk to quit, cites 'moral conviction' 51 min Synque 76
News The Zen Report: Just because you can get marrie... 55 min NorCal Native 2
News Is Polygamy the Next Gay Marriage? (Sep '14) 1 hr NorCal Native 7,037
News Supreme Court extends gay marriage nationwide 1 hr TomInElPaso 507
More from around the web