'Noah's biblical flood may have actua...

'Noah's biblical flood may have actually happened'

There are 3 comments on the India.com story from Dec 11, 2012, titled 'Noah's biblical flood may have actually happened'. In it, India.com reports that:

Washington: An acclaimed underwater archaeologist believes that he has found evidence that the Great Biblical Flood of Noah's time may have actually happened after all.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at India.com.

Steve Ballone

Old Lyme, CT

#1 Dec 12, 2012
What an odd headline. That a gigantic flood into the Black Sea occurred between 7,000 and 10,000 years ago is actually not in question. And it would be foolish to think that this event did not generate mythic/archetypal explanations at the time which contributed to or became the Gilgamesh Epic and Noah's Ark story. What is in question -- and shouldn't be -- is the existence of Noah and a wholly fantastical Noah's Ark timeline. These stories from the Old Testament have lots of value for linguists and historians of various ilks and persuasions, but they are just stories. There was no Noah just as there was no Abraham just as there is no "God." We're in this entirely on our own and we're not doing well. I pity our children who will be growing up in an era of unprecedented and probably unstoppable global climate change. Actually, maybe it's God's way of telling us we look better with tans, or as we might call them in 30 years "chars." Anyway, the "Noah's Flood" is balderdash.
REALLY

United States

#2 Dec 12, 2012
There were Noah, Abraham et al. And the Earth is not 6,000 yo.

Floods happened from time to time.
Bobby Bukbuk

Old Lyme, CT

#3 Dec 13, 2012
REALLY wrote:
There were Noah, Abraham et al. And the Earth is not 6,000 yo.
Floods happened from time to time.
You are correct in saying that floods happen from time to time. Sadly, floods will now be happening quite regularly. I wonder if you think this is God's actual plan, or maybe he's reading the paper and not paying attention or something. You might say that he works in mysterious ways and also he doesn't work in mysterious ways. Or maybe he's been laid off.
I'd like you to know that I say this without animus, but your statement that "There were Noah, Abraham et al." is endearingly infantile. You need a supernatural father figure, you need help in structuring your ego and superego and you use the Judeo-Christian tradition to do that. You cleave to the (illusory) enduring permanence of the Judeo-Christian edifice.
That's all. Religion is inescapable in our culture, but to understand it as some Hogwartian uber scheme permeating all life and thought is pretty cracked. Life without reliance on religion might seem unbearable to some. What it's really like is throwing open the shutters and shades and letting the sun shine in. And then, when night comes, it's night. Just night. No boogeymen. And when pain and suffering come, you don't turn to some magical being for reasons or comfort, you just deal with it.
I submit that Abraham and Noah et al. are every bit as real and every bit as effective in making life better or worse or more fulfilling as Mr. Softee, the guy with the soft-serve swirl head and the natty bow tie. Some people can't imagine life without Mr. S, some people just say "meh."

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Flood Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Global warming made Paris floods far more likel... 2 hr IB DaMann 110
News The Latest: Obama pledges federal support in fl... 3 hr Sneaky Pete 3
News Rainelle natives and mayor uncertain of what's ... 12 hr Dennis Neathawk 1
News At Least 26 Dead in West Virginia Flooding Sun ELISE GINGERICH 1
News Crews rescue the stranded in West Virginia floo... Sat Sharon Wilkerson ... 1
News Life-saving decision on flood swollen river (Dec '15) Sat THE COMEDIAN 3
News Alison Saar traces diasporas in the exceptional... Jun 18 Oh No You Di-nt 1
More from around the web