It's the Darwin crowd that lacks the facts in evolution debate

I would like to respond to the letter 'Recent letter offered no examples of Darwinian disingenuousness,' . He responds to an article with, 'He says evolution is 'so riddled with holes,' yet fails to provide a ... Full Story

“I Am No One Else”

Level 7

Since: Apr 12

Seattle

#105991 Jan 2, 2013
Usuallyunique wrote:
<quoted text>
KAB, you believe that life on Earth was destroyed in a flood 4000 years ago right? How can dendrochronologists count tree rings thousands of years through that time? Did God come down and put a plastic bag over them?
The best part about the bible, is that it's all scriptured inspired. You can't ignore a single comment or in this case a flood. But, I have already debated this with JWs, and they all in fact stated that the trees could live under 30000ft of water for a month. And jehovah had a resurrection of the insects. O and just recreated all of the flora/fauna in every other part of the world. Like a platypus. Or a venus flytrap.
Then what was the point? Why couldn't he have just zapped the bad guys?
Gah! You gave him a way to avoid asking your perfectly valid question. You know he'll ignore all the relevant and valid portions of your post, make up some lame excuse to a few points, then pull an ad hom. It's how the dishonest game they play.

“Darwin was right..of course.”

Level 9

Since: Jun 11

Park City, Utah

#105992 Jan 2, 2013
He is Coming Soon wrote:
www.scribd.com/doc/99737182
Sorry guy...the Tower of babel never happened...we have proof.

Another dead Biblical myth.

“Darwin was right..of course.”

Level 9

Since: Jun 11

Park City, Utah

#105993 Jan 2, 2013
marksman11 wrote:
<quoted text>Can I play? You have no observable evidence to counter that GOD might just actually did do it. IF God didn't do it, show us observable evidence of what did, and let us test and replicate it.<quoted text>GOD created us that way.
God doesn't exist. How do I know this??

There are no pictures of God.

There are no eyewitnesses to God.

Prayers to God are never answered.

No one throughout history has ever been able to prove the existence of God.

There is nothing but people of faith testifying to his existence.

God is not needed for anything...Billions of people have existed for hundreds of thousands of years without any thought or need of the Christian God.

People who follow other Gods are no better off, or worse off, than those who follow the Christian God.

You have to believe in magic to accept God.

You also have to believe in supernatural creatures if you believe in God.

People have killed others and used God as an excuse...even in modern times.

There is enough evidence against God that if you want me or any other atheist to believe this phantom of yours...Prove Him to be real.

Level 2

Since: Feb 12

Roseville, CA

#105994 Jan 2, 2013
KAB wrote:
<quoted text>
Would you please just give us specific data proving evolution so we can believe in it instead? Short of that, everyone's entitled to his choice of religion, right?
You shouldn't be here KAB. You know what the society has to say about you chatting with us. I know you've probably come up with a flimsy rationalization, like time spent on here can go on your Publisher Report.

What congregation are you in?

Level 2

Since: Feb 12

Roseville, CA

#105995 Jan 2, 2013
marksman11 wrote:
<quoted text>It is you guys that ignorantly demand proof. We creationists are honest enough to admit that our beliefs are faith based. We don't have to scientifically prove our beliefs. Science is not qualified to verify our beliefs. It is ignorant to even request scientific proof for beliefs rooted in a supernatural deity. Your premise is all wrong. You keep requesting we provide scientific proof, when our beliefs are beyond scientific verification. We are not like you. WE don't think like you. We don't want to think like you. We pity people that do think like you, and we teach our children not to think like you.
Without proof, there is nothing demonstrating your beliefs to be more correct than others. You couldn't even tell a Norse Mythologist that he was is wrong.

Secondly, if this is the case, then why do you even care to fight evolution? If your right, then we are gonna get ours in the afterlife. God should be fighting us, not you.

Most importantly, without proof we will descend back into the bronze age. When your car breaks down, you don't take it to you village elder and have him dance around it. You take it to someone that can prove they can fix it.

The core of this is:
Your beliefs are comforting and feel incredibly good. I know the feeling. Going outside that feeling is scary and has no real attraction to you. That's why someone as smart as Mazhere can reject anything that comes between him/her and those feelings. Doesn't really matter what it is. Its strong, I remember.
KAB

Oxford, NC

#105996 Jan 2, 2013
Usuallyunique wrote:
<quoted text>
KAB, you believe that life on Earth was destroyed in a flood 4000 years ago right? How can dendrochronologists count tree rings thousands of years through that time? Did God come down and put a plastic bag over them?
The best part about the bible, is that it's all scriptured inspired. You can't ignore a single comment or in this case a flood. But, I have already debated this with JWs, and they all in fact stated that the trees could live under 30000ft of water for a month. And jehovah had a resurrection of the insects. O and just recreated all of the flora/fauna in every other part of the world. Like a platypus. Or a venus flytrap.
Then what was the point? Why couldn't he have just zapped the bad guys?
Provide data from a single piece of wood with a continuous set of rings spanning the time of the flood and we'll have something to consider.
KAB

Oxford, NC

#105997 Jan 2, 2013
Usuallyunique wrote:
<quoted text>
You shouldn't be here KAB. You know what the society has to say about you chatting with us. I know you've probably come up with a flimsy rationalization, like time spent on here can go on your Publisher Report.
What congregation are you in?
Like everything else, just provide the data, in this case society quote(s).

“I Am No One Else”

Level 7

Since: Apr 12

Seattle

#105998 Jan 2, 2013
KAB wrote:
<quoted text>
Provide data from a single piece of wood with a continuous set of rings spanning the time of the flood and we'll have something to consider.
You really just don't pay any attention to any scientific finding:

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_oldest_trees

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_dend...

“Nihil curo de ista tua stulta ”

Since: May 08

Orlando

#105999 Jan 2, 2013
KAB wrote:
<quoted text>
Provide data from a single piece of wood with a continuous set of rings spanning the time of the flood and we'll have something to consider.
Prometheus. A living tree when cut down in August 1964. Dendrochronology listed to be AT LEAST 5000 years old.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prometheus_ (tree)

Damn the bastards that cut this tree down.

“Nihil curo de ista tua stulta ”

Since: May 08

Orlando

#106000 Jan 2, 2013

“Nihil curo de ista tua stulta ”

Since: May 08

Orlando

#106001 Jan 2, 2013
dammit

“That's just MY opinion...”

Since: Jan 07

Location hidden

#106002 Jan 2, 2013
KAB wrote:
Provide data from a single piece of wood with a continuous set of rings spanning the time of the flood and we'll have something to consider.
No problem. Give a date for the Flood.

Level 6

Since: Mar 12

Location hidden

#106003 Jan 2, 2013
marksman11 wrote:
<quoted text>1....if it proved that no designer was necessary, then no scientist would be necessary.
No, not if the scientist was merely replicating conditions that might have existed naturally on Earth billions of years ago.
2....abiogenesis and human from non-human evolution are absolutely related. Chemicals, or the building blocks of life, had to somehow mix, with what ever other ingredients are necessary, to change into...or EVOLVE into life. You guys try to keep it seperated because you have no observable evidence at all for abiogenesis, which then sheds a bad light on the validity of human from non-human evolution.
On the contrary. YOU are trying to entwine two different things because you know that we have a huge amount of evidence for evolution but little understanding of aboigenesis by comparison. So you try to claim that one depends upon the other, which is false.
If it is found that a divine designer is absolutely necessary for the origin of life, then there is no need for evolution.
In order to create a testing ground for human souls, which is what you seem to think this universe is for, was there any need for 10^23 stars, or galaxies so distant their light took 13 billion years to get here? Any need for the Red Spot? Any need for billions of generations of extinct cnidarians?

Saying evolution was not NECESSARY is just silly, given the superabundance of practically everything else in this universe!

Either it pleased God to create a universe with evolution and Quasars, or these things just happened. Either way, they happened. Just because primitive men writing the Bible were not aware of them and do not mention distant galaxies, bacteria, or radio waves, does not mean they don't exist. Just because any Genesis account of creation is at best an inaccurate potted summary of the last 13.6 billion years, or at worst merely another pre-scientific human myth...

...evolution is too well supported to ignore.

I would suggest that like other Christians who have actually learned science, even going back to Thomas Aquinas, but today including the likes of Glen Morton, Craig Ventor, and Michael Denton, you look at the facts and accommodate them into your Christianity instead of banging your head against the wall.
marksman11

Asheville, NC

#106004 Jan 3, 2013
KittenKoder wrote:
<quoted text>
Ape is a group of species, not a specific species. Our species is part of that group. It's not rocket science here.
I am a human being, they are apes. Apes are not human beings.

“I Am No One Else”

Level 7

Since: Apr 12

Seattle

#106005 Jan 3, 2013
marksman11 wrote:
<quoted text>I am a human being, they are apes. Apes are not human beings.
Do you have evidence of your assertion that apes are a specific species and not a collection of species that includes homosapien?
marksman11

Asheville, NC

#106006 Jan 3, 2013
Chimney1 wrote:
<quoted text>
No, not if the scientist was merely replicating conditions that might have existed naturally on Earth billions of years ago.
Well guess what? That is easy to do, and they ain't done it yet!!! THey can use any conditions they want to, AND IT STILL AIN'T HAPPENING!!!!!and I'm telling you that life is far to complex to randomly occur through natural processes. HECK.... SCIENTISTS CAN'T EVEN FORCE IT TO OCCUR!!!!!
Chimney1 wrote:
<quoted text>
On the contrary. YOU are trying to entwine two different things because you know that we have a huge amount of evidence for evolution but little understanding of aboigenesis by comparison. So you try to claim that one depends upon the other, which is false.
1....they are entwined because both must, according to your world view, happen without the aid of a designer. At present time science can't even force life to spontainiously generate, let alone nature randomly produce it. 2....You have evidence for micro evolution. You have zero observable evidence for human from non-human evolution. You can't even force it to occur just like abiogenesis. THey are perfectly entwined because these chemicals and building blocks must "change" or "evolve" into life. And then these primitive life forms much eventually "change" and "evolve" into humans. All in your world view, without a divine designer. It ain't happening for you. THey are entwined, ESPECIALLY for an atheist!!!!
Chimney1 wrote:
<quoted text>
...evolution is too well supported to ignore.
I would suggest that like other Christians who have actually learned science, even going back to Thomas Aquinas, but today including the likes of Glen Morton, Craig Ventor, and Michael Denton, you look at the facts and accommodate them into your Christianity instead of banging your head against the wall.
Funny, this was my message to the children of our church tonight.Psalms 118:8

"It is better to trust in the LORD than to put confidence in man."

so true!! Albert Einstines teacher told his father that Albert would never accomplish anything. The man over the US Pantend Office said in 1899 that there was nothing left to invent. Western Union said after the telephone was invented that there would never be a demand for it. And Charles Darwin said humans are a product of evolution. GOD said he created man. I'll go with GOD. It fits what i observe. Evolution does not.
marksman11

Asheville, NC

#106007 Jan 3, 2013
KittenKoder wrote:
<quoted text>
Do you have evidence of your assertion that apes are a specific species and not a collection of species that includes homosapien?
Mrs. Ape, that is just world games and labels. Humanly assigned labels has no effect on the validity of evolution. I am a human being. Apes are not human beings. Nice try but not even close, although I do love your atheist word games.
marksman11

Asheville, NC

#106008 Jan 3, 2013
Usuallyunique wrote:
<quoted text>
Without proof, there is nothing demonstrating your beliefs to be more correct than others. You couldn't even tell a Norse Mythologist that he was is wrong.
I won't try to tell a Norse mythologist that he is wrong. He is allowed his beliefs without attack. I would debate him if he attacked my beliefs, just like the ones in this group have.
Usuallyunique wrote:
<quoted text>
Secondly, if this is the case, then why do you even care to fight evolution? If your right, then we are gonna get ours in the afterlife. God should be fighting us, not you.
That is true and GOD will handle it in the afterlife. I'm not trying to save you. I'm trying to save those that you try to drag with you. I could say the same for you, why battle creationist? In the end, it doesn't matter. More so in your case than mine. I like to keep up with atheististic views so if I run across someone who is truly searching, Hopefully I'll have an answer for them. I know what's coming next.....all evolutionists aren't atheists. I know, but I'd say all atheists are evolutionists. They have to be.
Usuallyunique wrote:
<quoted text>
Most importantly, without proof we will descend back into the bronze age. When your car breaks down, you don't take it to you village elder and have him dance around it. You take it to someone that can prove they can fix it.
I fix it myself.
Usuallyunique wrote:
<quoted text>
The core of this is:
Your beliefs are comforting and feel incredibly good. I know the feeling. Going outside that feeling is scary and has no real attraction to you. That's why someone as smart as Mazhere can reject anything that comes between him/her and those feelings. Doesn't really matter what it is. Its strong, I remember.
THen you were ignorant for leaving it. The bible says without faith it's impossible to please GOD. Faith is awesome...you ought to admit it sometime.
marksman11

Asheville, NC

#106009 Jan 3, 2013
thewordofme wrote:
<quoted text>
God doesn't exist. How do I know this??
There are no pictures of God.
There are no eyewitnesses to God.
Prayers to God are never answered.
No one throughout history has ever been able to prove the existence of God.
There is nothing but people of faith testifying to his existence.
God is not needed for anything...Billions of people have existed for hundreds of thousands of years without any thought or need of the Christian God.
People who follow other Gods are no better off, or worse off, than those who follow the Christian God.
You have to believe in magic to accept God.
You also have to believe in supernatural creatures if you believe in God.
People have killed others and used God as an excuse...even in modern times.
There is enough evidence against God that if you want me or any other atheist to believe this phantom of yours...Prove Him to be real.
Another ignorant atheist requesting scientific proof for GOD when science is unqualified to deal with the supernatural.

As in Romans one, it is obvious by your remarks that GOD has turned you over to a reprobate mind. You say ignorant things like...."There are no eyewitnesses to God."

How about James, John, Thomas, Peter, Andrew, Barthlomew, Pilot, Simeon, Mary, Joeseph, Anna,......etc and the list goes on and on. You see, you are ignorant of what christianity is. You don't even know that Jesus was GOD. Then you make other ignorant statements like....."People have killed others and used God as an excuse...even in modern times."

People have also killed people with automobiles, and they exist! People have killed people with guns....and guns exist. You should be embarassed because of what you posted.

“I Am No One Else”

Level 7

Since: Apr 12

Seattle

#106010 Jan 3, 2013
marksman11 wrote:
<quoted text>Mrs. Ape, that is just world games and labels. Humanly assigned labels has no effect on the validity of evolution. I am a human being. Apes are not human beings. Nice try but not even close, although I do love your atheist word games.
If it was just "word games and labels," as you say, not that you were wrong on that point, why would it matter so much to you? Humans are one of the ape species. Would you rather be related to dirt or to something living?

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Evolution Debate Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
"Science vs. Religion: What Scientists Really T... (Jan '12) 10 min Jaimie 17,022
Should evolution be taught in high school? (Feb '08) 18 min Jaimie 177,036
evolution of Eyes - size - skin color - shape -... 1 hr Strel 5
Creationism isn't a science and doesn't belong ... 2 hr dirtclod 731
Evolution vs. Creation (Jul '11) 2 hr MikeF 150,004
Humans DID evolve from apes! 4 hr Denisova 42
Birds Evolved From Dinosaurs Slowly—Then Took Off 4 hr emrenil 37
More from around the web