Should evolution be taught in high sc...

Should evolution be taught in high school?

There are 178661 comments on the www.scientificblogging.com story from Feb 24, 2008, titled Should evolution be taught in high school?. In it, www.scientificblogging.com reports that:

Microbiologist Carl Woese is well known as an iconoclast. At 79 years of age, Woese is still shaking things up. Most recently, he stated in an interview with Wired that...

"My feeling is that evolution shouldn't be taught at the lower grades. You don't teach quantum mechanics in the grade schools. One has to be quite educated to work with these concepts; what they pass on as evolution in high schools is nothing but repetitious tripe that teachers don't understand."

Join the discussion below, or Read more at www.scientificblogging.com.

Level 6

Since: Aug 07

Arlington, VA

#116254 Feb 7, 2013
LowellGuy wrote:
<quoted text>
So, people could SEE the fat forming?
No idiot. They check the scale each week. Sheeez!

Level 6

Since: Aug 07

Arlington, VA

#116255 Feb 7, 2013
LowellGuy wrote:
<quoted text>
Maybe if you didn't lie so much...
How is stating something I believe is true because that is how I interprest the evidence a lie? It seems to me calling a person a liar knowing damn well they didn't makes you the liar.
One way or another

United States

#116256 Feb 7, 2013
Any entities capable of thought, MUST be capable pf asking itself questions, first.

Level 6

Since: Aug 07

Arlington, VA

#116257 Feb 7, 2013
appleboy wrote:
<quoted text>
Currently, we are not trying to contact other civilizations. We are looking for signs that other civilizations are sending intelligent signals using technology that should be available anywhere in the universe, providing they were advanced enough to exploit it (like radio signals or light signals). Though it is not an absolute assumption, it is a reasonable guess that radio or light technology would be at the base of any civilization capable of communicating beyond individual-to-individual.
The probability that there are other planets in the universe that have living organisms on them seems reasonably high. But the probability that they would be able to communicate beyond their own planet is much lower. For example, dolphins are highly intelligent, but given the environment they live in, it is unlikely they would ever develop ANY technology, let alone learn to communicate beyond their own inclosed environment.
We explore the possibilities because we can ask questions, not because we know the answer.
> Total waste of time.

> Dolphins are highly intelligent? Really?{Eye Roll}

“Don't get me started”

Level 1

Since: Jul 09

Minneapolis

#116258 Feb 7, 2013
Dogen wrote:
<quoted text>
Not necessarily. Perhaps a mild case or in partial remission. I don't think psychoboy has schizophrenia, even if I cannot rule it completely out by the indirect and anecdotal evidence we see here. He has worked most of his life and even run a business (even if an unsuccessful one). That is more than what many with schizophrenia can accomplish. OTOH Delusional Disorder fits perfectly as a diagnosis with the given information. And he certainly fits the paranoid/megalomaniacal type of Delusional Disorder.
A person with delusional disorder may be high functioning in daily life as this disorder bears no relation to one's IQ,[3] and may not exhibit odd or bizarre behavior aside from these delusions.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delusional_disor...
Some may think psycho is dumb, but I don't think this is so. Uneducated (or perhaps miseducated would be a better term) certainly, but not really dumb. His distortions of reality are the product of as good core processor that just does not have a better program to run than Ms Pac-man.
I'd agree that he seems to have an IQ in the normal range. The messages one gets in the process of education can make a very big difference.

When he first came to Topix he made lots of obviously intentional spelling and grammar mistakes. My first guess was that he was a sock puppet, but later came to the conclusion that he was attempting to grab sympathy--or perhaps projecting a means to protect his true identity. At any rate, he eventually cleaned up his spelling and grammar and showed that he could put ideas together in a flowing manner, though the premise for those ideas were flawed.

The delusion that his ideas would always be right regardless of contrary evidence was probably supported early in his education, either by his teachers giving up on him or by his mother's active praise for any effort he made.

“Don't get me started”

Level 1

Since: Jul 09

Minneapolis

#116259 Feb 7, 2013
Mugwump wrote:
<quoted text>
On your last point, whilst I accept that a virtual diagnosis is all but impossible - how would one know Jimbo isn't just a troll/Poe as UC suggests?
Not saying he dosent have mental issues, but suspect he does actually read posts and in his own way respond to them ( u notice often adds the superflorous word at the top of his posts every now and then since I pointed it out).
Whilst he seems to be deranged ( forgive me, I know it's not a medical term) how can we be sure he isn't the worlds best Edgar Allan.
Apologies If stupid question but am actually interested
Or perhaps stuck in an emotionally immature stage of development. Like when children throw a tantrum and expect that if they just hold out a little longer, their demands must be met. Not a delusion driven by halucinations or schizophrenia, but simply driven by an attitude of expectations that any opposition must eventually give way.
One way or another

United States

#116260 Feb 7, 2013
When one of you Evo children get a thought all your own, do let us know. Y'all have been here for years and not one of you has contributed even one new thought.

Housing fall

More new science by Jim Ryan

The failing school systems across the planet, due to government control, fail in the most important way and that is, to teach how to think for oneself.

The gov teaches A B C's and 1 2 3's, it teaches what to say and what to do. It teaches what not to say and what not to do.

Most of the housing bubble and fall were not due to lending to those who couldn't afford it, but it was due to the group think, taught all throughout school and work.

I'll bet none of you know what it was.
If you are able to think for yourself, it should be very easy to figure out, especially in hindsight and knowing that the rise and fall of the housing industry was due to group think and action.

The housing fall came not from the bad loans, but rather from the good loans. The good loans were the ones that borrowed money to renovate their homes. There were quite a number of tv shows touting the money to be made by renovation, coupled with politicians, realtors, home improvement stores, gov and more, making money by creating the schools, follow the leader mentality.
holy cow

Kent, WA

#116261 Feb 7, 2013
I cant believe we have telescopes that can see 20 light years away!! Isnt one light year 5 trillion miles?? Thats so amazing. After the discovery of millions of earth like planets not that far from us, i am convinced we are not alone and we are here because of aliens.

“I am Sisyphus”

Since: Nov 07

Location hidden

#116262 Feb 7, 2013
Mugwump wrote:
<quoted text>
On your last point, whilst I accept that a virtual diagnosis is all but impossible - how would one know Jimbo isn't just a troll/Poe as UC suggests?

Trolls have an agenda. What end does making oneself appear insane serve?

Alan Morgan wrote:[5] "Any sufficiently advanced parody is indistinguishable from a genuine kook."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poe%27s_Law

It is impossible to know for sure. Jim's anger is one of his driving mechanisms and I don't think he can control it this well for this long. He would do something to overtly out himself in one of his fits of rage.
Mugwump wrote:
<quoted text> Not saying he dosent have mental issues, but suspect he does actually read posts and in his own way respond to them ( u notice often adds the superflorous word at the top of his posts every now and then since I pointed it out).
Whilst he seems to be deranged ( forgive me, I know it's not a medical term) how can we be sure he isn't the worlds best Edgar Allan.
Apologies If stupid question but am actually interested

Not at all stupid question. Again, it is impossible to know for certain, but the shoe certainly fits and fits well.

Of more interest to me is what might be the cause of the disorder. There are known genetics, but most mental illnesses have environmental triggers. For Jim it would seem to be his traumatic childhood which he has spoken of several times (self disclosure does not seem to be of interest to the Poe). He seems to project all of this accumulated anger on us. And his nutty science is not only created, on the fly, in our forum, but he has referred to other things that were "stolen" from him in the past. And remember the big build up to his Final (cat pee) Solution.

Now, if I am wrong about Delusional Disorder and he is a COMPLETE Poe, then it would change my diagnosis, but would not change the fact there seems to be a mental illness driving it.

Contrast him to UC who is just a religious nut and sticks to the typical religious nut agenda.

Mugwump

Manchester, UK

#116263 Feb 7, 2013
One way or another wrote:
When one of you Evo children get a thought all your own, do let us know. Y'all have been here for years and not one of you has contributed even one new thought.
Housing fall
More new science by Jim Ryan
The failing school systems across the planet, due to government control, fail in the most important way and that is, to teach how to think for oneself.
The gov teaches A B C's and 1 2 3's, it teaches what to say and what to do. It teaches what not to say and what not to do.
Most of the housing bubble and fall were not due to lending to those who couldn't afford it, but it was due to the group think, taught all throughout school and work.
I'll bet none of you know what it was.
If you are able to think for yourself, it should be very easy to figure out, especially in hindsight and knowing that the rise and fall of the housing industry was due to group think and action.
The housing fall came not from the bad loans, but rather from the good loans. The good loans were the ones that borrowed money to renovate their homes. There were quite a number of tv shows touting the money to be made by renovation, coupled with politicians, realtors, home improvement stores, gov and more, making money by creating the schools, follow the leader mentality.
Evidence?

“What, me worry?”

Since: Mar 09

I'm a racist caricature!

#116264 Feb 7, 2013
Urban Cowboy wrote:
<quoted text>
How is stating something I believe is true because that is how I interprest the evidence...
You don't know enough to interpret the evidence properly. You, in all your wisdom, are declaring yourself a better critic and analyst of the facts than people who are actually trained to do so. You are basing your beliefs on ignorance being applied to the facts. Since when has that EVER been a valid and useful method of determining how things actually work?

“What, me worry?”

Since: Mar 09

I'm a racist caricature!

#116265 Feb 7, 2013
holy cow wrote:
I cant believe we have telescopes that can see 20 light years away!! Isnt one light year 5 trillion miles?? Thats so amazing. After the discovery of millions of earth like planets not that far from us, i am convinced we are not alone and we are here because of aliens.
Because we have hair, I am convinced that bigfoot exists.

This is your claim, in a nutshell.

Is there anything at all amiss about it?

“I am Sisyphus”

Since: Nov 07

Location hidden

#116266 Feb 7, 2013
Russell wrote:
<quoted text>
For goodness sake!
Education is highly over-rated
Which "cretard", as you lovingly refer to creationists, has lied? Making bigoted statements does not endear you to the masses nor function as a "badge of honour" for "being educated"...
You're tired again?
You're half asleep all day
Whatchoo gotta sleep at night for?

All of them lie. Some of them have gone to prison for tax evasion, too.

“What, me worry?”

Since: Mar 09

I'm a racist caricature!

#116267 Feb 7, 2013
Urban Cowboy wrote:
<quoted text>
No idiot. They check the scale each week. Sheeez!
So, they only see the EFFECTS, and not the actual phenomenon, and they just declare that fat formed. Interesting. And you consider that science, eh?

“I am Sisyphus”

Since: Nov 07

Location hidden

#116268 Feb 7, 2013
Russell wrote:
<quoted text>
Why not start with the age of the Universe
Let's say...
Comets?

Comets, as a class of objects, are over 4 billion years old in this solar system.

“I am Sisyphus”

Since: Nov 07

Location hidden

#116269 Feb 7, 2013
Urban Cowboy wrote:
<quoted text>
I am using the word species as it is normally used. Dogs are all one species but come in a wide variety of shapes and sizes but they can all still produce offspring and they all share common characteristics that we collectively define as the that species. That is the most specific category of life. The next is genus. Two different genuses cannot produces viable vertile offspring but still share much of the same characteristics of which we collectively define it. There is virtually unlimited genetic variation possible within a species with regards to size, shape, color, etc. For example, no two humans share the exact same fingerprint, facial features, eye pattern, or DNA. So this is a perfectly valid definition based on our current knowledge.
And now briefly, I am basing my rule on what is routinely observed and not what is speculated to fit the TOE. Gradualism and the slow fossilization of bones is generally not accepted by anyone therefore there really is no geologic column of fossils that represent vast eons of time and by deduction, no macroevolution. In order for a fossil to form, the creature must be quickly buried in mud under pressure. The old idea that an animal dies and its lies out in the sun and rain with all the decomposers and regardless of what we routinely observe that there is basically nothig left after a few days, the animals is slowly covered by dirt and leaves day after day, year after year, for thousands and millions of years and finally becomes fossilized. And then a framework whereby the fossil pattern found was used to create the framework of a theory is much weaker - and circular - than what is routinely observed. Plus the fact that there are as many or more out of place fossils than evolutionary ones. Plus the fact that there are so many living fossils. Fossils of creatures in very old layers that look just like their living counterparts. Got to go to work.

You must know that most of this is simply not true and is just made up 'just-so' stories by creationists and for creationists. They are not things supported by evidence nor taken seriously by any objective person.

“I am Sisyphus”

Since: Nov 07

Location hidden

#116270 Feb 7, 2013
Russell wrote:
<quoted text>
So what do evolutionary astronomers do?

Evolutionary astronomers.......?

“I am Sisyphus”

Since: Nov 07

Location hidden

#116271 Feb 7, 2013
One way or another wrote:
Today's failing educational system is little more than monkey see, monkey do. That fact is painfully obvious to everyone that went to school.

Translation: I am a 10th grade drop out who was a social misfit when I was in school.

Maybe what happened to you in school was not your fault. But you are still responsible for what you are doing now.

“I am Sisyphus”

Since: Nov 07

Location hidden

#116272 Feb 7, 2013
Russell wrote:
<quoted text>
No
Of course not....
http://www.creationastronomy.com/evolution-ha...

LOL. Hysterical site. Nice satire.

“I am Sisyphus”

Since: Nov 07

Location hidden

#116273 Feb 7, 2013
Urban Cowboy wrote:
<quoted text>
So you say I twist things but then what is the mechanism that places the evolutionary order of life in the right layers? This is my point. Every fossil must be buried quickly under pressure. There is no layers of depths from which you can trace backward in time. And another thing. You could equally have said, at some earlier point when the theory was being developed, that so and so fossil preceeds or follows this so and so fossil. It is impossible to know for sure because it is the unobservable past.
You always place much greater weight on the unobservable past than the routinely observed and testable present: we don't see beneficial mutations or macroevolution as the rule. There are only 1 or 2 highly questionnable cases. We have never seen a bone fossilize by the process of slow gradualism. This means that by and large, all fossils form by catasrophism not uniformatariansim. This blows the lid off the geologic column! My rule places much more weight on the observable and testable. Your theory is devoted almost entirely on the unobservable past and the very rare exception.
And as you always do, I'll sprinkle a few supporting comments: The arrow of time is in the exact opposite direction of evolution. Everything in the known universe is moving toward less complexity, including all living genomes. The radiometric dating is only as good as its assumptions about quanties of parent and daughter elements and rates, and it doesn't explain always finding elements that should have been long decayed away.
So regardless of the geologic column or any guesses about how old the earth is, my Rule of Non-Macroevolution stands.

This is getting pathetic and desperate. Please read some real science.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Evolution Debate Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News It's the Darwin crowd that lacks the facts in e... (Mar '09) 1 hr Paul Porter1 142,587
News Evolution vs. Creation (Jul '11) 1 hr showmethemoney 171,799
evolution is correct. prove me wrong 2 hr Paul Porter1 9
Beware of Kamikaze Snakes. They Are Evolving in... 2 hr Paul Porter1 36
News "Science vs. Religion: What Scientists Really T... (Jan '12) 2 hr thetruth 20,593
News Intelligent design 15 hr Paul Porter1 3
News Pope Francis Affirms Evolution and Big Bang Theory Thu Paul Porter1 266
More from around the web