Risk is at heart of debate on troop w...

Risk is at heart of debate on troop withdrawal

There are 6 comments on the The Kansas City Star story from Dec 3, 2012, titled Risk is at heart of debate on troop withdrawal. In it, The Kansas City Star reports that:

The debate over how many U.S. troops will remain in Afghanistan after 2014 comes down to risky business.There is a risk that leaving too few troops after 2014 would stop or stall the already slow development of the Afghan army and police, whose competence - and that of the Afghan government as a whole - is crucial to ending the war successfully.On ... (more)

Join the discussion below, or Read more at The Kansas City Star.

Robert

Douglasville, GA

#1 Dec 3, 2012
They may feel that it is important to leave enough troops so that they don't stall the development and competence of Afghan police and military and thus that of the Afghan government but that presumes that there is a unified Afghan government which there is not. Harmed Karzai in actuality is little more than the mayor of Kabul, the people of the country are part of tribal groups and have no feeling of nationalism towards Afghanistan and its elected government. The government will never be in control of the entire country and if we are waiting for that we will have people there for ever acting as a magnet for attacks.
Lance Winslow

San Jose, CA

#2 Dec 3, 2012
Robert wrote:
They may feel that it is important to leave enough troops so that they don't stall the development and competence of Afghan police and military and thus that of the Afghan government but that presumes that there is a unified Afghan government which there is not. Harmed Karzai in actuality is little more than the mayor of Kabul, the people of the country are part of tribal groups and have no feeling of nationalism towards Afghanistan and its elected government. The government will never be in control of the entire country and if we are waiting for that we will have people there for ever acting as a magnet for attacks.
We knew that before Bush led us into this quagmire.
Robert

Douglasville, GA

#3 Dec 3, 2012
Lance Winslow wrote:
<quoted text>We knew that before Bush led us into this quagmire.
Yes of course, it is bush s fault we all know that.

If we don't leave it will be bush s fault too I am sure.
Eleanor

Mundelein, IL

#4 Dec 3, 2012
Time to TOTALLY exit the occupation of this foreign country.

We invaded Afghanistan to 'get' the Taliban who were giving protection to Osama & Co.

Now the Afghan government is getting cozy again WITH the Taliban.

There is nothing more we can to for that god-forsaken country.

Bring our men and women HOME, NOW! Before another of our people are injured or killed in that crazy country.

Since: Dec 12

Bakersfield, CA

#5 Dec 3, 2012
Troop withdrawal won't even be happening. 10,000 US soldiers are scheduled to remain indefinitely after 2014 to 'train afghan soldiers'. Please what a farce.
Austinite

Austin, TX

#6 Dec 3, 2012
Afghan army and police are deserting with their weapons left and right as well as killing American soldiers on a regular basis. The Afghan government is as corrupt as ever from the top down and along with it's military is directly involved in the production and distribution of opium and the resulting heroin.
Afghanistan has never been conquered, not even the Soviets with a million soldiers and brutal methods was able to conquer the country in the 10 years they were there so America has not a snowballs chance.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

2012 Presidential Election Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Barack Obama, our next President (Nov '08) 12 min Kevin 1,263,743
News BARACK OBAMA BIRTH CERTIFICATE: Suit contesting... (Jan '09) 36 min Gilbert 194,516
Election 'Fox News Sunday' to Host Kentucky Senate Debate (Oct '10) 37 min AMERICAN SUNSHINE 190,065
News Stressful times for low-polling Republicans who... 1 hr Cat74 4
News Huckabee gets Fox facetime before debate rankings 2 hr stalk this 4
News Majority wants Congress to reject Iran deal 3 hr spocko 86
News House to Obama: Fire the head of the IRS or we'... Thu ima-Ilis Myka Ash... 1
More from around the web