Replay review not granted by head off...

Replay review not granted by head official

There are 24 comments on the Las Cruces Sun-News story from Mar 23, 2010, titled Replay review not granted by head official. In it, Las Cruces Sun-News reports that:

An NCAA representative said the decision not to review the game clock during the final second of New Mexico State's 70-67 loss to Michigan State last Friday was a judgment call made by the head official and the stand-by official sitting courtside.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at Las Cruces Sun-News.

First Prev
of 2
Next Last
BB Season Ticket Holder

Fredericktown, OH

#1 Mar 23, 2010
Through the years the officating at Pan AM towards the home team has sometimes been horrible.
I recommend that we do not allow the obvious Aggie haters to ref our games.
All we need is an even playing surface.
I am sick of UTEP and Lobos getting home court calls on our floor.
Talk to past Aggies. We do NOT get those calls at the PIT!
AUG

United States

#2 Mar 23, 2010
Judgement call, huh? You can be sure if Michigan State was on the other end of that there would have ben a review
84 Alum

Lacey, WA

#3 Mar 23, 2010
Since it is a judgment call, and a great deal was riding on having the call be correct, it speaks volumes about the judgment of head official. I hope he has the decency to feel ashamed. In my view, Dick Cartmell should not be refereeing in the tournament if that represents his level of judgment.

MSU probably still would have won, but in this case the 0.3 seconds potentially could have an impact.
NotGonnaHappen

Las Cruces, NM

#4 Mar 23, 2010
AUG wrote:
Judgement call, huh? You can be sure if Michigan State was on the other end of that there would have ben a review
And ironically there was, at the end of the first half when Izzo complained. But for little ole NMSU? Not Gonna Happen.
Former Resident Pee J

Kihei, HI

#5 Mar 23, 2010
Great call and the right call by the ref's.
Mr Bill

Olympia, WA

#6 Mar 23, 2010
Given the fact that MSU took down the Terps, it seems the Aggies were just a split second from the Sweet 16. Coach should use the controversy to instill the desire to play hard every single second.
Michael Ash

Santa Fe, NM

#7 Mar 23, 2010
im one of those fans that you always see yelling at the refs at aggie games. I know there should have been more time on the clock and agree completely with the rest of you... whether you are certain you're right as an official, you should double check because there may be a small percent you are wrong. and with such a valuable game on the line, they definitely should have reviewed. But in the end, even as someone who believes NMSU got cheated, i agree with menzies, its in the book, and nothing can change that now, its time to move on and look to the bright future, look what we have accomplished this season... we won our conference and UTEP didnt!(Reeeg. season title doesnt count)
Mr Bill

Olympia, WA

#8 Mar 23, 2010
Former Resident Pee J wrote:
Great call and the right call by the ref's.
correct call? yes
great call? no way, at that point in the game(any game)you let the players play. it was an infraction that happens frequently but is never called unless the shooter's position is compromised.
Crimson and White

Santa Fe, NM

#9 Mar 23, 2010
Mr Bill wrote:
<quoted text>
correct call? yes
great call? no way, at that point in the game(any game)you let the players play. it was an infraction that happens frequently but is never called unless the shooter's position is compromised.
Don't try to reason with pee j that guy has it in for the aggies for whatever reason, he also has a stick so far up his butt it isn't even funny.
I agree with you in that type of game, in that situation you don't take the game out of the players hands. It was a shame the game had to end that way with the lane violation call and the clock issues, both teams played hard and like I said it was just a shame it had to end the way it did.
XPS

Albuquerque, NM

#10 Mar 23, 2010
Former Resident Pee J wrote:
Great call and the right call by the ref's.
Why do you hate us so much? I just don't get it. Anybody without a bias knows it should have at LEAST been reviewed. Maybe there really was 0.3 left. But take a look.
Aggietude

Dallas, TX

#11 Mar 23, 2010
Kalin Lucas's season is over.
Let's see the refs bail them out this week.

Pee Gay, Sit & spin biaatch!
Yeah

Albuquerque, NM

#12 Mar 23, 2010
I agree with XPS at the very least reviewed to take a look at to be sure it is correct. Nothing wrong with that unless you got something to hide but what is done is done.
REfs

Albuquerque, NM

#13 Mar 23, 2010
BB Season Ticket Holder wrote:
Through the years the officating at Pan AM towards the home team has sometimes been horrible.
I recommend that we do not allow the obvious Aggie haters to ref our games.
All we need is an even playing surface.
I am sick of UTEP and Lobos getting home court calls on our floor.
Talk to past Aggies. We do NOT get those calls at the PIT!
Refs are refs even though I do not think the college refs are not that bad compare to the NBA refs.
Crimson

Las Cruces, NM

#14 Mar 23, 2010
The head official was also the one that called a ridiculous technical on Menzies and the lane violation. Seems he had it out for the Aggies from early in the game. My uncle is a college official. This guys days in good games are numbered. Your peers don't want to be on the floor with you and you end up with the arm pit assignments. With that said, if we had played better defense in the first half the officials might not have had the chance to make a difference.
Former Resident Pee J

Kihei, HI

#15 Mar 23, 2010
Everyone hates the Aggies even the ref's.You guys have no friends anywhere.
Crimson and White

Santa Fe, NM

#16 Mar 23, 2010
Former Resident Pee J wrote:
Everyone hates the Aggies even the ref's.You guys have no friends anywhere.
Go jump in a volcano you piece of trash.
NMSU BALLA FAN

Las Cruces, NM

#17 Mar 23, 2010
Doug Fullerton and DICK (HEAD) Cartmell are garbage. They work for the NC Double AA-Holes and if the situation was reversed they would have done everything in their power to make the right calls.I call it 8 against 5. MSU make the NC Double AA- Holes a lot of money and would not like to see that money train derailed. These two F-ups are not the reason NMSU lost, yet for this DICK (HEAD)CARTMELL to call or whoever call a lane violation that never should have been called took the game out of the player hands. I hope this make NMSU more motivated to have a better season in 2010-11. This team has to win the WAC regular season and tourney title because the NC Double AA-Hole are who they are and it is what it is. Let me say again those two bad calls are not the reason NMSU lost the game but it did not help any either.
Hater-aid

Las Cruces, NM

#18 Mar 23, 2010
Good ole P e e P e e & B e e J o b. Everyone hates you brotha.. Your a fomer resident of Southern New Mexico prison, that where the name comes from. The inmates miss you.
I see

Albuquerque, NM

#19 Mar 24, 2010
Former Resident Pee J wrote:
Everyone hates the Aggies even the ref's.You guys have no friends anywhere.
I see that you have no life becoming a big troll on a message board huh? It's ok man someday you might find a life that you might be proud of for once.
I know who you are

Albuquerque, NM

#20 Mar 24, 2010
Former Resident Pee J wrote:
Everyone hates the Aggies even the ref's.You guys have no friends anywhere.
I know who you are old friend of mine, guess what? Whatever you are doing right now you better stop your none sense oh and guess what again? Which I am completely forgot to tell you that I had reported your ISP with your behavior on the internet. If you think I am bluffing you will find out soon when I am not.
See ya later old friend

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 2
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Michigan State University NCAA Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Future Hall Of Famer Says Steelers Le'Veon Bell... (Sep '14) Sep '14 Bell Bong 3
News Pittsburgh Steelers to Meet with Cornerback Pro... (Mar '14) Mar '14 Myron Cope 2
News Detroit Lions fans want team to draft Michigan ... (Jan '14) Feb '14 Bob D 2
News Michigan State knocks Ohio State out of BCS tit... (Dec '13) Dec '13 ART DECO MAN 19
News No. 10 Michigan St. shocks No. 2 Ohio St. 34-24 (Dec '13) Dec '13 COACH ARTIE 2
News Braxton Miller shows in Big Ten title game whif... (Dec '13) Dec '13 ART DECO MAN 2
News Off-the-radar recruit Darqueze Dennard had no s... (Nov '13) Nov '13 Ty Coleman 1
More from around the web