Tom Brady is Overrated

Tom Brady is Overrated

There are 10095 comments on the Dr. U story from Jan 14, 2006, titled Tom Brady is Overrated. In it, Dr. U reports that:

Tom Brady of the New England Patriots is the most overrated quarterback in the NFL.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at Dr. U.



#23 Feb 12, 2006
i couldnt disagree with you more obviously you dont watch football because if you did you would see he is the best qb and deserves alot more attention then he gets it seems to me you are a little jealous of someone who is more talented then you could ever be. i say keep on praising tom brady.


#24 Feb 12, 2006
i couldnt disagree more with you people who said he gets to much attention and isnt that good because if you watch football you would see he is one of the best if not the best so to those who say lets not talk about tom all i have to say is i think yall are a little jealous of what you can never be. he is a guy who doesnt complain and does everything he has to do to win so in my opinion they should honor him and respect him a lot more.

Concord, CA

#25 Feb 12, 2006
Tom Brady is the ice man; nothing rattles that guy when it comes to crunch time. How can you even compare Brady to mediocre QBs who haven't even won anything yet??? The point is that Delhomme and Hasselbeck are unproven and Brady, well, that resume speaks for itself.

Concord, CA

#26 Feb 12, 2006
jim from buffalo wrote:
<quoted text>Good you can keep him there.loser
wow...i'd like to get a whiff of what you're smoking...
jim from buffalo

Buffalo, NY

#27 Feb 15, 2006
Brady will never see another superbowl unless he is watching it from his couch at home.Brady the best what a joke.he will be 0-2 against buffalo this year.

Allentown, PA

#28 Feb 15, 2006
You're really trying to get that Idiot of the year award aren't you?
jim from buffalo

Buffalo, NY

#29 Feb 16, 2006
LOL wrote:
You're really trying to get that Idiot of the year award aren't you?
no you are the bone head.whats the matter can't take the truth? new englands reign at the top of the afc is coming to an end.i would say maybe 9and 7 next year or even 10 and 6 if they keep the horseshoe up their @%*!!!~~~

Allentown, PA

#30 Feb 16, 2006
jim from buffalo wrote:
<quoted text>no you are the bone head.whats the matter can't take the truth? new englands reign at the top of the afc is coming to an end.i would say maybe 9and 7 next year or even 10 and 6 if they keep the horseshoe up their @%*!!!~~~
Oh, so the truth is what you THINK is going to happen? There you go, just one more step toward that award for you moron...
jim from buffalo

Buffalo, NY

#31 Feb 16, 2006
crack is an illeagle drug. you should stop smoking it.

Allentown, PA

#32 Feb 16, 2006
Keep trying for the reaction that won't come tool....

Are you really that bored? LOL what a loser...
Drake of Hilo

Honolulu, HI

#33 Feb 16, 2006
keiso21 wrote:
<quoted text>
ARE YOU SERIOUS? Tom Brady is the greatest football player in the NFL right now and maybe the past 20 years. Tell me what other player would you rather have under center in a 2:00 situation? Name someone playing the game right now. I think your just mad cause Tom "2 time superbowl MVP" Brady isn't the type of quarterback to make a big fuss about being the best. Tom really is picture of a great team player. He has paid his time as a back up qb to Bledsoe and took his first chance swinging and won a superbowl. If anything I think has been rated fairly.
I think that Tom is a pretty lame QB in general. He isn't very physical and doesn't live up to his praises. If you want 2 compare QB's you really should be looking at BIG BEN. Now he is a QB that can be physical and get the job done.
Drake of Hilo

Honolulu, HI

#34 Feb 16, 2006
I BET $200 on 1-8 odds.\
Coach Gray

Tonica, IL

#35 Feb 21, 2006
As a huge Montana fan, I used to get irritated when people would compare the two of them. But, as I grow older and hopefully wiser, it's evident that the intangibles are what both of these guys have. They just flat win.

United States

#36 Feb 22, 2006
WHAT THE F&^$e%^&e#&($^ &^$%*%(*&%) ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT
Rob in Houston

Brooksville, FL

#37 Feb 25, 2006
..."isn't very physical and soes not live up to his praises." The dude posting from Hawaii should be hospitalized. What the hell does being physical have to do with playing QB in the first place? And not living up to his praises? You've just defined Peyton Manning's and Michael Vick's careers. Put it this way: take away all of Brady's staggering postseason success; in just 5 years as a starter,he lead the NFL is passing TD's one year('02)and passing yardage another('05). That alone would be tremendous on anyone's only 5 years as a starter. Brady is a flat-out certainty for the HOF and if you can't see his greatness by now, you just don't want to.


#38 Feb 25, 2006

What else must this QB make that he will get his LEGACY?

WIN 10 SUPERBOWLS in arow WITH a TD/INT: 100/0


Everybody who thinks Brady is overrated did not throw even one pass by his own!!!



so cal rider

Santa Barbara, CA

#39 Feb 25, 2006
keiso21 your hell of gay . Tom Brady is the most overated QB's in the game.

Omaha, NE

#40 Feb 25, 2006
i agree with you socalrider brady is way over rated hes good but not that good. you could take any qb and put there and done what he is done. oh i am a packers fan who would i rather have in a 2 min drill left in the game well lets see i am a packers fan a brett favre one of the best out there still he might of had a bad year but are people going to give up on him like montana and elway and so on. i know one thing i will not give up on favre.
people are dumb

North Dartmouth, MA

#41 Feb 27, 2006
I think people are just jealous of tom, they wish they could have all the success he has at the young age of 28. But since they can't they have to bash him because that makes them feel better about themselves. Deep down inside they all know hes awesome but they can't admit it because they are jealous. simple as that.
just another guy

United States

#42 Mar 5, 2006
Anyone who thinks Tom Brady is overrated has to have a mental problem. The fact that you cannot see what he has brought to the Patriots is ludacrous. I beg of anyone who is willing to argue to look at the stats (which are the facts - not someones opinions like we see here) and while you are there, check out the quarterback ratings. You will find Tom Brady is among the elite. He brought his team championships and almost always comes through in the big games. Thats a lot more than I can say for the second best quarterback in the NFL now (Payton Manning). To all who comment on Tom Brady being overrated please think and check out facts before you say he sucks- maybe you are just jealous he isn't on your team?

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

NCAA Football Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News UCLA FOOTBALL NOTEBOOK: Neuheisel says Prince w... (Sep '10) Jan 13 I Need U 35,345
Ncaa college football championship Jan 9 renner 7
News Penn State Football: News and notes from a busy... (Jul '12) Jan 4 What phartse 4
News Clemson has goods to beat 'Bama again if Kelly ... Jan 2 HasPhartts 2
News Analysis points: No. 12 Central Florida 34, No.... Jan 1 NationalPhartzs 2
News Defense makes 6-0 win stand over Eagles as Cowb... Jan 1 Juicy Fart Raiders 2
News UNC's Strong, Barbour suspended indefinitely (Jan '08) Dec 18 ThankPhartse 3
More from around the web