Waitress Blew Out Knee When Checking ...

Waitress Blew Out Knee When Checking On Her Dogs, but Appellate Court ...

There are 5 comments on the Phoenix New Times story from Sep 26, 2011, titled Waitress Blew Out Knee When Checking On Her Dogs, but Appellate Court .... In it, Phoenix New Times reports that:

Shaydak brought her two dogs to work with her that day, saying later that she was sure they would be warmer in her car than stuck outside at home.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at Phoenix New Times.

Pinky

Tucson, AZ

#1 Sep 26, 2011
So much for fence climbing on the Mexican border. Wonder if she had a lawyer?
Pinky

Tucson, AZ

#2 Sep 26, 2011
Although this claim was clearly not worthy it should be pointed out that the Workman's Comp system in Arizona is known for denying legitimate claims.

Once I was injured at work and required surgery. The claim was approved, but took 6 weeks for the approval, another month to schedule the surgery and then I was not released to return to work for another 3 months at which time there was no longer a job. I was off work for 6 months total and the claim payed for only 6 weeks. Yes I could of appealed but you need to hire an attorney that you pay for yourself. A 7 dollar an hour job does not leave much for Attorny fees.

Workman's comp is administrated by well paid employees of the state. THAT is where the money your employer pays into the system goes.
onceuponatime

Bisbee, AZ

#3 Sep 26, 2011
Pinky wrote:
So much for fence climbing on the Mexican border. Wonder if she had a lawyer?
How could any part of that story be construed to fall under 'Workman's Comp.? How was that injury part of her assigned job? I hope you can clarify this, because I cannot see a claim or a complaint.
Pinky

Tucson, AZ

#4 Sep 27, 2011
Clearly the claim should have been denied, she had NO claim. I never suggested she should have prevailed.
My tale was cautionary because the system is rigged against legitimate claims, to make difficult and avoid paying claims while handsomely rewarding administrative law judges to deny claims.
Denial of claims is common requiring appeals.

My first comment was a "joke". I hope YOU will clarify how I suggested her claim was legitimate.
onceuponatime

Bisbee, AZ

#5 Sep 27, 2011
Pinky wrote:
Clearly the claim should have been denied, she had NO claim. I never suggested she should have prevailed.
My tale was cautionary because the system is rigged against legitimate claims, to make difficult and avoid paying claims while handsomely rewarding administrative law judges to deny claims.
Denial of claims is common requiring appeals.
My first comment was a "joke". I hope YOU will clarify how I suggested her claim was legitimate.
My bad. I have to eat the crow on this one. I read the article first, and knowing that the "New Times" is not the most unimpeachable source of fact, made some bad assumptions.
As a side note, however, I have worked with the system from both the labor and management sides of the fence, and have not personally witnessed denial of legitimate claims.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Naco, Mexico Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Residents of border alarmed (Jun '07) Feb '16 whatever 2
if white people left america (Jul '13) Jul '13 Serrano Red 1
News the Border Report - Return of the Minuteman Pro... (Aug '07) Jul '13 enrique 105
News Mexican Consulate asks for donations to help mi... (Oct '08) Jul '13 GulchGeek 26
News Detained illegal immigrants face mistreatment, ... (Oct '08) Jul '13 Girl With HairyArms 5
Beware of Naco!!! (Nov '08) Jul '13 Girl With HairyArms 3
News Mexico concerned about U.S. bid to beef up bord... (Jun '13) Jul '13 See the Light 38
More from around the web