Bon Scott vs. Brian Johnson

Bon Scott vs. Brian Johnson

Posted in the Rock-N-Roll Forum

Bill

Wayne, NJ

#1 Oct 27, 2009
Tough choice.
Bill

Wayne, NJ

#2 Oct 27, 2009
oops sorry I was trying to start a Jon Bonham vs Keith Moon thread.
Tony Vincent

New Zealand

#3 Nov 19, 2009
Bon the best by a long way - Brian fine rock vocalist but o a lower rung

Bon the best front man - a lizard who would seduce the front row - Brian would vomit on them.

Bon best all the way
Bill

Wayne, NJ

#4 Nov 20, 2009
Sorry I personally like Brian Johnson's voice better, (He has 9 octaves in his voice) but I think that Bon Scott was a better songwriter.
random 101

Australia

#5 Nov 27, 2009
I like Bon better, but Brian has done extremely well to fill his shoes. Tough one.
Let there be rock

Velenje, Slovenia

#6 Jan 12, 2010
Let we see the facts...

Far better songwriter: Bon
much better frontman: Bon
Charisma: absolutely Bon
Better voice: hmm... Bon/Brian (personall choice)
Stronger voice: Brian
The best replacement in history: Brian

Greatest albums:

Bon with the boys:

High Voltage
DDDDC
Let There be Rock
Powerage
If you want blood...(live)
HTH

Brian with the boys:

BIB
FTATR
FOTS (partely)
The Razors Edge
Black Ice

Long live to AC/DC ...

quootar

Calamvale, Australia

#7 Jan 27, 2010
cant decide
Bill

Wayne, NJ

#8 May 22, 2010
Both have a lot of respect for each other, especially the respect Brian had for Bon, but Bon told Angus and Malcolm that if anything happened to him that they should hire Brian as the lead singer...so obviously Bon respected him.
Rosie

Sioux Falls, SD

#9 May 23, 2010
No doubt it was Bon, true, Brian filled the void "Like a frickn hammer". Ya, hard call, anyways rock lives on..
Rosie

Sioux Falls, SD

#10 May 23, 2010
I agree, hard decison. I started by saying Bon all the way, but then instantly reconsidering. It's messed up because AC/DC was destined to Live Forever. Rock And Roll!!!!!!
Bill

Wayne, NJ

#11 May 23, 2010
Back In Black was incredible. Black Ice is pretty good too.
Rocko

Velenje, Slovenia

#12 May 27, 2010
Bill wrote:
Back In Black was incredible. Black Ice is pretty good too.
Yeah, true. What about Let There Be Rock, Powerage, High Voltage, mighty Highway to Hell...? Bon is one of the most charismatic rock icons ever and clearely better. Anyway great, great thanks also to Brian for everything.
Tony Marsh

Warren, IN

#13 Sep 29, 2012
Bon best hands down... Brian does great job, as long as he doesn't try too sing Bon's songs. Bon was a singer fast or slow, Brian just a good screamer. Don't take me wrong, AC/DC still my number 1 band period. Shoot to thrill and Rock n Roll train my two fav's, Bon's are too many to list :)
fish

Burnaby, Canada

#14 Dec 15, 2012
brian johnson with ease.... he does most of bons songs better than bon himself like sin city /whole lotta rosie/let there be rock.........if you doubt what i say go check out ac dc 81 landover on youtube...BRIAN JOHNSON IS ON FIRE

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Rock-N-Roll Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Priscilla Presley on Why She Divorced Elvis Pre... 1 hr Lol 4
News Little Richard Calls Same-Sex Relationships ''U... Oct 12 Kasick of Pancakes 29
News Concert review | Bon Jovi: Band pays tribute to... (Mar '17) Aug '17 PrinterBench Tech 3
News Elvis Presley Eclipses Michael Jackson (Jul '09) Aug '17 Pop Tart- 53,066
News On Religion Jul '17 Mockingjay cristol 1
News George Wendt coming to Bucks County Playhouse t... Jul '17 Sam Mayday Malone 2
Top 10 best rock n roll bands of all time (Dec '06) Jul '17 javajav 1,545
More from around the web