Top 5 Picks for Next American Idol

Top 5 Picks for Next American Idol

There are 12 comments on the ABC News story from Mar 18, 2011, titled Top 5 Picks for Next American Idol. In it, ABC News reports that:

There's no shortage of talent this season on "American Idol," but there's still only one winner.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at ABC News.

Tru Dat

Minneapolis, MN

#1 Mar 18, 2011
Goodbye and good riddance to Karen Rodriguez. It's AMERICAN Idol, not Hispanic Idol.
Totally mean

Dunlap, TN

#2 Mar 18, 2011
That comment was really uncalled for.
Virginia Girl

Richmond, VA

#3 Mar 18, 2011
I agree with the totally Mean comment. I am glad Tru Dat is not on the show. With that attitude they would not get far.
Carolina Girl

Mebane, NC

#4 Mar 18, 2011
Agreed....that comment was totally uncalled for. However, if "Ignorant Idol" comes along we got the #1 contestant.
Pleasure Beach Lover

Richmond, VA

#5 Mar 18, 2011
Is that Casey guy wearing a disguise or is that what he really looks like?
lol
Tru Dat

Minneapolis, MN

#6 Mar 18, 2011
Are you guys 12 years old? Look up the word "pandering" in the dictionary and tell me Karen wouldn't be booed out of a Karaoke bar.
screen

Reedley, CA

#7 Mar 30, 2011
As sweet as Karen is, she just didn't have what it takes, her voice just wasn't strong enough. Tru Dat's earlier statement may have seemed to be mean, but it Was "on target".

If you recall, Karen's first interview showed her stating that she wanted to be the first "hispanic" Idol, as opposed to simply saying that she wanted to be the next American Idol.

None-the-less.. she's still a doll, and I hated to see her go. Heck.. I hate to see any of the rest of them go, they're all good.
screen

Reedley, CA

#8 Mar 30, 2011
Pleasure Beach Lover wrote:
Is that Casey guy wearing a disguise or is that what he really looks like?
lol
Think of the doll "Chucky" with a beard and curly hair...=:-D
Pleasure Beach Lover

Richmond, VA

#9 Mar 30, 2011
screen wrote:
<quoted text>
Think of the doll "Chucky" with a beard and curly hair...=:-D
Or the young Santa Claus in the "Santa Claus is coming to town" TV special.
screen

Stockton, CA

#10 Apr 1, 2011
Well whatta-you-know.. a clipped and trimmed Casey who this week, as expected, wasn't even close to being eliminated.
Pleasure Beach Lover

Richmond, VA

#11 Apr 1, 2011
screen wrote:
Well whatta-you-know.. a clipped and trimmed Casey who this week, as expected, wasn't even close to being eliminated.
Would you have noticed the clipping/trimming if you weren't told about it?
I sure wouldn't. He still looks like sasquatch.
screen

Stockton, CA

#12 Apr 2, 2011
Pleasure Beach Lover wrote:
<quoted text>
Would you have noticed the clipping/trimming if you weren't told about it?
I sure wouldn't. He still looks like sasquatch.
No, I would not have (noticed).

In fact I was quite disappointed in that the only thing that had noticeably changed was his demeanor, which in itself just may be another act.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

What's Love Got to Do with It? Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Adrian Thrills sorts Valentine's champagne truf... (Mar '14) Mar '14 Martin Thomas 1
News American Idol Top 10 Girls Perform: Whose Boobs... (Mar '13) Mar '13 concerned parent 1
News What Color Is Your Racism? (Nov '12) Nov '12 white genocide 4
News Rihanna - Rihanna Lined Up to Play Whitney Hous... (Mar '12) Mar '12 Here comes trouble 2
News Whitney Houston biopic reportedly already in th... (Feb '12) Feb '12 MAREE 1
News Montana Fishburne Follows the Kim Kardashian Se... (Aug '10) Jan '12 sansui 3
News 'American Idol' Sends Another Finalist Home (Mar '11) Mar '11 Pleasure Beach Lover 1
More from around the web