Judged:

1

This story sounds very familar. I seem to recall a Twilight Zone, Outer Limits, or similar series telling of the same basic thing. And I also seem to recall reading a short story by Richard Matheson along the same lines - which makes sense, since Matheson wrote for Twilight Zone for years. I seem to recall the Twilight Zone version being much better than what your reviews leads me to believe the movie is...