U.N. intellectual property chief to s...

U.N. intellectual property chief to step down early

There are 1 comment on the Reuters story from Nov 15, 2007, titled U.N. intellectual property chief to step down early. In it, Reuters reports that:

“I personally urge all concerned in the best interest of the Organization to proceed soon with the formal approval of the 2008-2009 program budget”

By Laura MacInnis

GENEVA (Reuters) - The head of the United Nations' intellectual property watchdog will step down next year, a year early, after documents bearing a false birth date brought pressure on him to resign, diplomats said on Thursday.

Kamil Idris, head of the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) for a decade, was found by internal auditors to have signed documents with a false birth date -- making him seem nine years older -- when he joined the agency 25 years ago. Read more

Join the discussion below, or Read more at Reuters.


Geneve, Switzerland

#1 Nov 27, 2007
The letter was directed to the Deputy Commissioner for the Trademark Examination Policy of the USPTO, an employee of the US Government.

1. I always believed that you cannot serve two masters at the same time.
2. I sent Francis Gurry – Assistant Director General and Legal Counsel of WIPO an e-mail of July 17 2002. The e-mail said:“I am preparing an article on the Madrid Protocol. Please let me know where I can obtain a copy of WIPO’s regulations regarding its ethical conduct in regard to payments or gifts to officials of national patent and trademark offices”.
3. Mr. Gurry answered me on July 21, 2002 (Sunday)“WIPO does not make gifts or payments to officials of national patent and trademark offices”.
4. Dr. Idris’ Letter contradicts Francis Gurry’s statement that WIPO does not give gifts to officials of national PTO’s as the trip was a gift of $ 4, 881, 10. Clearly under the guidelines of WIPO’s Legal Counsel, Dr. Idris’ letter was grossly improper.
5. The gift also seems inappropriate as the 2001 USPTO Budget was over One Billion Dollars. The PTO could afford to pay for necessary travel by its PTO official.
6. The gift was effective in that the official was a vocal proponent of US adherence to the Madrid Protocol. INTA’s April 3, 2003 statement to the US Congress thanked her and others for their support of the Madrid Protocol. Despite receiving multiple favors from WIPO the official did not recuse herself from supporting WIPO’s projects.
7. It is worth pointing out that WIPO’s gifts to the official began in July of 1991 with the gift of a trip to Switzerland worth $1,028.25 and that, WIPO’s gifts to her ceased after the US joined the Protocol.
8. Dr. Idris’ gift of $ 4,881.10 to the official in 2001 was a follow up to her “election” on November 5, 1998 to WIPO’s Standing Committee on the Law of Trademarks International Designs and Geographical Indications. My FOI request for information on her compensation was denied. Perhaps Mr. Di Palma or members of Cincinnatus can comment on the amount of compensation for this position.
9. The fact that the Madrid Protocol will help WIPO’s finances and the national purposes of some countries does not justify these actions of Dr. Idris, especially where the adherence to the Protocol would harm the country in question, as may be the case with Brazil.
10. Currently WIPO’s is pressuring Brazil to join the Madrid Protocol. WIPO has recently hired the niece of the Brazilian Foreign Minister to join its staff in Geneva.
11. Clearly there is the need for WIPO to enact a code of Conduct and for Dr. Idris to be replaced as Dr. Idris cannot say his signature on the October 2, 2001 was a typographical error.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Patent / Trademark Law Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Judge Mayer's Concurrence in IV Shows the Probl... Jan 21 DavidSBell 7
News EDITORIAL: A case involving The Slants, an Asia... Jan '17 Anar 2
China patent in U.S. Jan '17 zlarson 1
International territories and selling preferences Oct '16 Anon 1
How Do You Bring an Idea to Market? (Oct '15) Oct '16 juegos de futbol 2
News RenovoRx Announces The U.S. Patent And Trademar... Oct '16 fnaf sister location 1
News Judge Oetken Holds that Amendments Made During ... Oct '16 run 2 2
More from around the web