'Idol' party rocks for Overmyer

The End Zone Bar and Grill in Lafayette was home to dozens of Amanda Overmyer T-shirts, Amanda Overmyer signs and Amanda Overmyer wigs. Full Story
not a big fan

United States

#22 Mar 19, 2008
She needs to get on that Harley and get out of Hollywood and head back to reality. She is not a good singer or performer
Shearm17

New Smyrna Beach, FL

#23 Mar 19, 2008
Amanda Overmyer is a natural born STAR!!!!!!!!! Absolutely love everything she sings!!!!!!!!! You go girl-ROCK ON!
Shearm17

New Smyrna Beach, FL

#24 Mar 19, 2008
AMANDA OVERMYER ROCKS! I LOVE EVERYTHING SHE SINGS! YOU GO GIRL!!!!!
Freedom

Indianapolis, IN

#25 Mar 19, 2008
I think she's a blast! I'd love to go see her.

“ENJOY LIFE LIKE A SUNSET”

Since: Feb 07

United States

#26 Mar 19, 2008
I think the judges like to put someone different on every year. I do not believe they care if they are good or not. Screaming all the time is not star quality. Most people like to understand the words in the song. Oh I'm sorry maybe there is no words...
Shearm17

New Smyrna Beach, FL

#27 Mar 19, 2008
I just finished reading the other comments about Amanda! I can see that these other people haven't a clue to what real talent is!!
Jul

AOL

#28 Mar 19, 2008
I'd like to hear her sing another type song...because every song she sings sounds like the last...she'll be in the bottom 3 tonight
Jul

AOL

#29 Mar 19, 2008
I sorry but she sounds like she is constipated...you can't understand any of the words she sings...her hair is...well...hidious..Amanda, keep your nursing job..Idol is not for you...
monotonous

Indianapolis, IN

#30 Mar 19, 2008
ShinyLilMissa wrote:
<quoted text>
She is unique and different, which I see most people don't care for. I really like her. I get tired of the same old boring stuff. Nice to see something new. GO HOOSIERS!!!!!!! Where's the hometown spirit?
Unique and different is fine, but awful isn't. Once you hear one of her songs, you don't need to hear another. To me, SHE is boring. But, mostly I can't stand listening to her. Raspy, can't understand half of the lyrics, screaming instead of singing, and her hair makes her look old and dated instead of modern. I was shocked she even got to Hollywood in the first place.

The judges keep saying that she needs to try a ballad to show her diversity. Don't they recall her attempt at that a few weeks ago? Awful.

“I know you are, but what am I?”

Since: Dec 06

That way...

#31 Mar 19, 2008
And if she doesn't broaden her horizons the best she'll ever do is singing in a bar in Lafayette...
Cletus

Muncie, IN

#32 Mar 19, 2008
That Overmyer girl is a trainwreck. Her hair is just plain stupid looking. Unless she is screaming she can't carry a note to save her life. Looking t her, I know she is just one cheeseburger away from letting her inner fat girl out. Puke.
Freedom

Indianapolis, IN

#33 Mar 19, 2008
Cletus wrote:
That Overmyer girl is a trainwreck. Her hair is just plain stupid looking. Unless she is screaming she can't carry a note to save her life. Looking t her, I know she is just one cheeseburger away from letting her inner fat girl out. Puke.
And I'm sure your are an extremely charming individual yourself.
Amanda Who

Rushville, IN

#34 Mar 19, 2008
Shearm17 wrote:
AMANDA OVERMYER ROCKS! I LOVE EVERYTHING SHE SINGS! YOU GO GIRL!!!!!
I think I hear an echo...and it's from a deaf girl.
George

AOL

#36 Mar 19, 2008
She is like Janis Joplin.. Great on certain songs and a bust on most others. Yet I did like her in the 101 Dalmations as Ms. DeVil
Shearm17

New Smyrna Beach, FL

#37 Mar 19, 2008
Amanda Who wrote:
<quoted text>
I think I hear an echo...and it's from a deaf girl.
It was only typed twice,because I didn't realize it had gone thru and honey I'm not deaf but maybe you're blind. You couldn't see talent right in front you if it slapped you in the face. And by the way Feedom you're right on!

Since: Jan 08

Indianapolis, IN

#38 Mar 19, 2008
ShinyLilMissa wrote:
<quoted text>
I get tired of the same old boring stuff.
Talent is boring?
lol

Collinsville, MS

#39 Mar 19, 2008
Cletus wrote:
That Overmyer girl is a trainwreck. Her hair is just plain stupid looking. Unless she is screaming she can't carry a note to save her life. Looking t her, I know she is just one cheeseburger away from letting her inner fat girl out. Puke.
Are you under the impression somebody gives a crap what you think? Here... I'm sliding a quarter into the computer. Go call someone that gives a hoot about your uneducated, redneck point of view.
Shearm17

New Smyrna Beach, FL

#40 Mar 19, 2008
Ol Satchmo wrote:
<quoted text>
Talent is boring?
YOU'RE SO RIGHT SATCHMO!!
NancyIndy

Indianapolis, IN

#41 Mar 19, 2008
I don't like her style and I don't like the "lilly munster" look. I agree with Simon...borrring.

“Butler Wins Again”

Since: Jan 08

Connersville, IN

#42 Mar 19, 2008
Well, I had lost interest last year which almost made me believe all of the talent in America had been used up. I am back this year though, and I think these contestants are the best since season one. I love the way Amanda rocks, but then my favorite all time women singers are Janis Joplin and Grace Slick. I put this girl in the same talent category and believe she could reach that stature in the rock world. Last night I though she and Ayesha were the top two performers. I also enjoyed all the other girls. Sorry guys, you were OK, with Eze my fovorite, but I hope it comes down to three girls, Amanda, Ayesha and the Irish Lass.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Indianapolis Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Arizona's running back Jon Dwyer ? 6 hr Dave 1
Obama lied to Hispanics 8 hr Dave 2
Paul George tweeting trash ? 8 hr Dave 6
Very useless deputy sheriff at colts game last ... 11 hr toad smasher 19
WalMart Adventures on west side 16 hr Curious 1
Islam=I stink like a monkey 20 hr farvinston 2
Bin Laden images Tue The Zombie 2
•••
•••
•••

Indianapolis Jobs

•••
•••
•••

Indianapolis People Search

Addresses and phone numbers for FREE

•••

Indianapolis News, Events & Info

Click for news, events and info in Indianapolis
•••

Personal Finance

Mortgages [ See current mortgage rates ]
•••