Sarah Murnaghan Had Second Lung Trans...

Sarah Murnaghan Had Second Lung Transplant Operation

There are 8 comments on the WKXW-FM Trenton story from Jun 28, 2013, titled Sarah Murnaghan Had Second Lung Transplant Operation. In it, WKXW-FM Trenton reports that:

Her family in a statement reveals that the first lungs failed and that a second set were found and placed in her chest on June 15 according to WPVI TV .

Join the discussion below, or Read more at WKXW-FM Trenton.

WhoDoesNOTgetOne Now

Pottstown, PA

#1 Jun 28, 2013
I hate to say it but an adult set of lungs was basically wasted. They say the system or age limits on the tranplant list were there to save the most lives. Now one person is on her second set of lungs. That's possibly 2 adults that would've gotten lungs before this controversy.

I don't know which is worse the 2 people who actually died, the two people that might of gotten the lungs this child got or what this child is going through.

May the donors rest in peace the child have a speedy recovery.

How many more

Katy, TX

#2 Jun 28, 2013
So, first this girl gets put to the top of two lists, ahead of others who have been waiting, then she gets two sets of lungs within a week. Two people died and donated their organs which were intended to go to the next in line, the next person who waited their turn. Now, those two people may have also died while their lungs were wasted on this child who jumped ahead of them and was placed at the top of two lists, ahead of others who were in need, who also have families, who waited for their turn as intended, who didn't go to court to cut in line and who didn't not only get one set of lungs that weren't rightfully hers, but then got another set within a week.

This is really unfair to those who went without. How many more lungs will this girl get while others die waiting? How many children may lose their Mommy or Daddy who was waiting for lungs before this girl jumped ahead of them and got two sets of lungs while their loved ones lay dying.
WhoDoesNOTgetOne Now

Pottstown, PA

#3 Jun 28, 2013
I can't believe some strings weren't pulled or policies over looked for this second set of lungs. From waiting for months for one set then getting two in less than one month?

Then the parents go public for attention then keep her condition and the second set of lungs a secret?

I've read so much where not only kids don't fair as well with transplants/adult organs alot of people with cystic fibrosis patients will still have problems. So yeah if you are devising policies for a transplant list you should take survivability into consideration. Either that or simply first come first serve as far as a match.
How many more

Katy, TX

#4 Jun 28, 2013
This is just so wrong in so many ways.
meh

San Francisco, CA

#5 Jun 30, 2013
I'm confused, so doctors said she could die before or during surgery, so why did they risk putting in new lungs? That is sad that qualified adults did not receive lungs, while she got lungs that had to be cut to fit her. They really need to allocate these lungs to people at the least risk for rejection. I dislike the way the family is blaming the donor lungs, someone died and gave you a gift and all you can do is put them down, what a shame. If I was the family of donor, I would be offended and hurt that these people didn't even appreciate the last thing my loved one could give. This shows how selfish and uncaring the parents are to other people, be sensitive towards the donor, the lungs didn't come from a junkyard, but from a human that was loved by their family. In the end if these fail will she get a 3rd pair? a 4th? Where does it stop?
WhoDoesNOTgetOne Now

Pottstown, PA

#6 Jun 30, 2013
meh wrote:
I'm confused, so doctors said she could die before or during surgery, so why did they risk putting in new lungs? That is sad that qualified adults did not receive lungs, while she got lungs that had to be cut to fit her. They really need to allocate these lungs to people at the least risk for rejection. I dislike the way the family is blaming the donor lungs, someone died and gave you a gift and all you can do is put them down, what a shame. If I was the family of donor, I would be offended and hurt that these people didn't even appreciate the last thing my loved one could give. This shows how selfish and uncaring the parents are to other people, be sensitive towards the donor, the lungs didn't come from a junkyard, but from a human that was loved by their family. In the end if these fail will she get a 3rd pair? a 4th? Where does it stop?
Exactly. The paraded her daughter in public to garner sympathy. They used her like a prop because they could not accept the fact that she might die. Then they let hypocritical conservative politicians exploit the situation jumping on a government official for not interfering in private sector medical matters. To make matters worse they kept the second transplant a secret after going public begging for the first. And yes the donors have yet to properly acknowledged for their donation. They were slow to say it was an adult set of lungs after the first and I don't think they said where the second set of lungs came from.
How many more

Katy, TX

#7 Jul 1, 2013
@meh
Where does it stop? Good question.

@WhoDoesNOTgetOneNow
Now, the mom is shamelessly begging for money on Facebook. So, now we learn what she was really after. A sob story to rake in money in the name of her dying child and at the expense of at least two better suited patients who may die waiting for the lungs being hacked up to stuff into the too small body of her incurable daughter.

By the way, the second set of lungs also came from an adult donor.
WhoDoesNOTgetOne Now

Pottstown, PA

#8 Jul 1, 2013
If the mom is begging for money on facebook did she at least set up a charity in her daughter's name or is she asking direct.

And another adult with higher survivability chances missed another chance at a lung.

Still disgusted at the way the speak out of bothsides of their mouth politicians begged for the government to interfere in private medical matters.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Kidney Cancer Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Cystic fibrosis patients surviving longer in Ca... Mar '17 Evkan 1
News Mall, arenas, hospital projects make for exhila... (Jun '12) Mar '17 Time change Weekend 2
News You'll never guess how much Brits spend a year ... (Sep '16) Sep '16 Keiragambler 3
News This Sick 20-Year-Old Wants Her Parents Prosecuted (Apr '16) Apr '16 Hang um 1
can viagra make you go deaf? (Apr '16) Apr '16 Hewitt 1
can viagra make you go deaf? (Mar '16) Apr '16 Travis 3
natalie gregg: viagra and divorce: is there a l... (Mar '16) Mar '16 Webster 1
More from around the web