Jack or Tiger: Who's the greatest

Jack or Tiger: Who's the greatest

There are 8 comments on the The Sand Trap story from Apr 22, 2012, titled Jack or Tiger: Who's the greatest. In it, The Sand Trap reports that:

Jack has more majors 18-14 , did it for a longer period, dominated a decade+ , finished in the top 10 in majors in 35 of 40 majors in the 1970's....Tiger on the other hand had the best 2 1/2 year stretch '99 PGAA - '02 US Open and again in '05-'06....but he isn't the greatest yet, and probably won't reach that summit now that he has physical ... (more)

Join the discussion below, or Read more at The Sand Trap.


Saint Petersburg, FL

#1 Apr 23, 2012
No comparison, Jack will always be my greatest !!

Austin, TX

#2 Apr 23, 2012
Jack is the best, paws down!!

Hamilton, Canada

#3 Apr 23, 2012
Tiger put it in more holes.

Toronto, Canada

#4 Apr 25, 2012
Leave the guy alone. He is going to win again and will break Jack's record. He has lots of time for that. No one can predict the future but one thing you got to admit he can sell tickets to a golf event.Tour sponsors go nuts when he is part of a tournament.$$$$$....

Did he screw up his personal life and family? yes of course he did all that ! He has paid dearly for that and now he needs to be forgiven and we need to move on. I have not seen any consistence performance in any player besides tiger. Rory included, Luke Donald etc

Belleville, Canada

#5 Apr 30, 2012
Tiger will never be great again unless he can forgive himself. I don't know what his spiritual beliefs are but I'm sure he's not Christian. He's the greatest golfer in the history of the game (imo) but he'll never get Buddha or Mohammad to forgive him, or let him forgive himself. IMO he's in a very dark place right now and that's the worst place to be when you play golf.

Huntersville, NC

#6 May 5, 2012
Tiger's glory days are behind him. He never did measure up to Jack.

United States

#7 May 7, 2012
Jack's record is safe. Did you ever read about Jack driving around in trailer courts looking for skirts. Hell no!!!...He was and is still looked at as a true gentlemen. To judge Tiger as the greatest golfer ever is a disgrace to Jack's record. Tiger was the man until he was caught screwing anything that walked. A loser that will forever be remember as the man that gave up golf for skirts....FTW!!!!

Belleville, Canada

#8 May 7, 2012
I agree Jack's record is safe for today - however, Tiger is still a young man comparitively speaking. If one evaluates Tiger as simply a golfer and not a moral man, it is hard to ignore his accomplishments to date. I would still like to see Tiger pull up his boot straps and get on with his life. IMO, he needs to be his own man now. Daddy's gone. As far as the skirt chasing goes, my mother always said, "What's another slice off a cut loaf." It's just sex.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Tiger Woods Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Gavin to play alongside Woods in Safeway Open Oct 11 Spectre 1
News Golf | Couples aches to captain (Dec '07) Sep '16 Whocares 154
Early Tiger TV interview where veteran golfer l... (Apr '09) Aug '16 BEYOND THE GRAVE 4
News Some images are just too controversial (Jan '08) Jul '16 Tactics 63
News Jordan Spieth is filling the void left by Tiger... Jun '16 caltenn11 1
News Phil Mickelson and caddie Jim Mackay have the e... Jun '16 jfr927 1
News Brandel Chamblee says Tiger Woods looks like an... (Feb '16) May '16 Sshall57 6
More from around the web