Tom Brady vs. Peyton Manning: Who's t...

Tom Brady vs. Peyton Manning: Who's the Best? - Part II

There are 481 comments on the Pats Pulpit story from Jul 11, 2007, titled Tom Brady vs. Peyton Manning: Who's the Best? - Part II. In it, Pats Pulpit reports that:

By tommasse Posted on Tue Jul 10, 2007 at 09:57:34 PM EDT Brady vs. Manning Who Is the Better QB and Why? In Part II of "Tom Brady vs. via Pats Pulpit

Join the discussion below, or Read more at Pats Pulpit.

First Prev
of 25
Next Last
Connor D

Phoenix, AZ

#1 Aug 1, 2007
tom brady is a much better quarter back than peyton manning..... in crunch time who would u rather have leading ur team down feild? Tom Brady he has proved it to the world on countless occasions including a 2 super bowl championships.... tom brady has won 3 super bowl titles and petyton has only won 1... peyton manning pulled himself together this year but years before has fallen apart
ronald42

Laveen, AZ

#2 Aug 3, 2007
conner, apparently the arizona sun has gotten to you. teams win super bowls not individuals. how many mvp's does brady have. i think the answer is NONE.remember to stay out of the sun
tommyd4207

Lewiston, ME

#3 Aug 20, 2007
ronald42 wrote:
conner, apparently the arizona sun has gotten to you. teams win super bowls not individuals. how many mvp's does brady have. i think the answer is NONE.remember to stay out of the sun
You should take your own advice and stay the F*#k out of public!
Sivy

United States

#4 Aug 29, 2007
Im pretty sure Brady is better.

Simply put, he wins more games with far worse wide outs.(untill this year. GO MOSS, GO WELKER)
Danielle Parker

Plainfield, VT

#5 Aug 29, 2007
brady
Cassie

Delaware, OH

#6 Aug 31, 2007
I'm from Indiana, and I would have to say Peyton, BUT Brady is a great QB non the less. Peyton has said many times that he is best friends with Tom, so I don't understand what the big deal is people. Get over it, and get a life!
Rick

Cincinnati, OH

#7 Sep 4, 2007
Has it occured to anyone that it doesn't matter who the wide outs are on the colts, Peyton has the ability to make any of them look great. I mean it wasn't but a couple years ago that Brandon Stokley had a 10 touchdown season. Marcus Pollard was a top rated tight end, then he got traded and you've never heard his name since then. Fill in whoever you want on that roster, Moorehead, Clark, Fletcher, Utech... they all have great games when they actually get the playing time. So while Manning is making the best out of the people he has around him, everyone is making excuses for brady "not having any wide outs"
tommyd4207

Lewiston, ME

#8 Sep 7, 2007
Rick wrote:
Has it occured to anyone that it doesn't matter who the wide outs are on the colts, Peyton has the ability to make any of them look great. I mean it wasn't but a couple years ago that Brandon Stokley had a 10 touchdown season. Marcus Pollard was a top rated tight end, then he got traded and you've never heard his name since then. Fill in whoever you want on that roster, Moorehead, Clark, Fletcher, Utech... they all have great games when they actually get the playing time. So while Manning is making the best out of the people he has around him, everyone is making excuses for brady "not having any wide outs"
Did it ever occur to you that Manning really sux and benefits from the system that Indy runs and has a few "pretty good"receivers.
tommyd4207

Lewiston, ME

#9 Sep 7, 2007
Cassie wrote:
I'm from Indiana, and I would have to say Peyton, BUT Brady is a great QB non the less. Peyton has said many times that he is best friends with Tom, so I don't understand what the big deal is people. Get over it, and get a life!
Well there is "somewhat" intelligent life in Inbrediana!
dillon

Houston, TX

#10 Sep 16, 2007
BRADY BY FAR..... LOOK AT THA NUMBER OF RINGS MANNING HAS...THEN LOOK AT THA NUMBER OF RINGS BRADY HAS

Since: Apr 07

Location hidden

#11 Sep 16, 2007
Brady is so much better under pressure, he doesn't loose his cool like Manning or like that over rated QB in San Diego.
max

United States

#12 Sep 21, 2007
it dont matter how many super bowls you won. its all about ur stats. tom brady won 3 super bowls, but it was mostly their defence that played. patriots are a bunch of cheaters. the rams and the eagles should of one. dam all the cheaters and crybabies like the patriots and tom brady. so peyton is better for his stats. and peyton has mvp season , and brady has none.
MigueNE

Boxford, MA

#13 Sep 21, 2007
Who is better now. I think Brady is the number one ranked QB. What does that tell you. One superbowl and manning is the greatest. Tell me how good he would be considered if he had 3 and MVP in 2 of them. This is like everywhere i read; Boston bashing. No our fault we got a great sports town.
Andrew

United States

#14 Sep 24, 2007
MigueNE wrote:
Who is better now. I think Brady is the number one ranked QB. What does that tell you. One superbowl and manning is the greatest. Tell me how good he would be considered if he had 3 and MVP in 2 of them. This is like everywhere i read; Boston bashing. No our fault we got a great sports town.
Next time, try to insert question marks after your questions. Then, re-read what you have typed so it actually makes sense.
Hollis

Minneapolis, MN

#15 Sep 24, 2007
Peyton is by far better, he has beter numbers, he has the most recent superbowl ring, and he has made his team great through out the years without a great defense.
Mike summers

United States

#16 Sep 25, 2007
ronald42 wrote:
conner, apparently the arizona sun has gotten to you. teams win super bowls not individuals. how many mvp's does brady have. i think the answer is NONE.remember to stay out of the sun
yeah but he does have 2 super bowl mvp plus this season he is incredible so ha ha Go Tom Go Pats
sam haller

Tupelo, AR

#17 Sep 25, 2007
brady is the better QB especially under pressure but peyton is also good but i think brady will win the super bowl again this year or shall i say the patriots. the colts lost their defense and new england is going to take advantage of that.
Andrew

United States

#18 Sep 25, 2007
sam haller wrote:
brady is the better QB especially under pressure but peyton is also good but i think brady will win the super bowl again this year or shall i say the patriots. the colts lost their defense and new england is going to take advantage of that.
How does that make for Brady being a better qb? Winning another superbowl on a loaded team? Rex Grossman could have won a superbowl if a few things changed during the superbowl...I know Tom Brady is finally throwing up better numbers so far this season. We are talking about Peyton vs. Brady, not the colts vs pats. I think Peyton Manning is better but everyone from both sides bring up valid arguements. It is a discussion that will go on probably forever.
peytonsgirl18

White Oak, NC

#19 Sep 26, 2007
They're both great quarterbacks, though by best friend would say Favre beats everybody. Gotta love Peyton though. He's my pick for best QB.
Sanit

Windsor, CA

#20 Sep 27, 2007
Connor D wrote:
tom brady is a much better quarter back than peyton manning..... in crunch time who would u rather have leading ur team down feild? Tom Brady he has proved it to the world on countless occasions including a 2 super bowl championships.... tom brady has won 3 super bowl titles and petyton has only won 1... peyton manning pulled himself together this year but years before has fallen apart
No lol peyton is way better than tom brady. Peyton manning has way better stats than tom brady.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 25
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Jeff Saturday Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News 2013 NFL Mock Draft: The Green Bay Packers Selecta (Jan '13) Jan '13 eric 3
News Green Bay Packers: Donald Driver, Jeff Saturday... (Jan '13) Jan '13 Laughing Bear Fan 1
News Green Bay Packers Power Rankings: 7 Most Disapp... (Jan '13) Jan '13 young fan 2
News Green Bay Packers Center Jeff Saturday Doesn't ... (Dec '12) Dec '12 Laughing Bear Fan 5
News 2013 NFL Mock Draft: The Green Bay Packers Select (Dec '12) Dec '12 Go Blue Forever 24
News 2013 NFL Mock Draft: The Green Bay Packers Select (Nov '12) Nov '12 Hollywoodless Kni... 5
News Green Bay Packers: Running game goes nowhere fast (Oct '12) Oct '12 Patches OHoulihan 2
More from around the web