Mark Purdy: Raiders could stand to learn a lesson from JaMarcus Rus...
#1 Jul 7, 2010
still a good judge of talent? Do you have any significant coaching background whatsoever to make that naive remark? I think you lost most of your readers at that juncture...
#2 Jul 8, 2010
this reader found the article refreshing. So what you are saying is that the writer of the article requires "significant coaching background" in order to comment. Don't think Mel Kiper has coached a down of football, is he qualified to comment...are you? I have coached football for 15 years, and have an opinion, but i'm not a journalist, nor would i feel qualified to evaluate talent for an NFL team. ONly thing naive here is your highly uninspired post, thinking coaching has anything to do with drafting or talent evaluation. Mike Ditka - good coach, buried a franchise with his talent evaluation and decision to trade 11 picks for 1. Bobby Beathard (google if u don't know him) is considered one of the best evaluators of talent in NFL history and has a solid case for NFL hall of fame. He drafted Ryan Leaf. It's an inexact science, and Al and the Nation blew the JaMayonnaise pick. Instead of bashing the dinosaur, you should appreciate the history and what he has done for the sport. He is an icon, whether u love him or hate him. Whiners are just as horrid, and hats off to Al for admitting mistakes, and putting together a great offseason.
#3 Jul 11, 2010
Well stated. JaMarcus was the overwhelming consensus #1 pick in his draft year. It is most definitely not an exact science. Interesting that Al's many detractors attempted to credit his "advisors" for this off-season's moves. Can't wait to see Mr. Davis hoist his fourth Lombardi.
#4 Jul 11, 2010
100% agree, and once you make it to pro sports of past collage for that matter arn't you supposed to be a grown up, your employer is not a baby sitter, if you need one then your road will lead the same place as russell although probably not as rich but still a loser. although i never agreed with him being drafted i am glad he rectified the situation. and if you are a true fan you take the good with the bad, we have definitely had some good and way more then our share of bad but a true fan stays with his or her team you don't just look at the standings to decide who you are going to root for.
Add your comments below
|NFL notebook: Bengals, 'Pacman' agree on contra... (May '10)||Jan '15||Same Story||10|
|Darren McFadden brings Oakland Raiders ground g...||Oct '14||Flatulence Fred||2|
|Pick 6: Biggest QB busts of the last 10 years (May '14)||May '14||TexasRaider||5|
|Former Chiefs Quarterback Matt Cassel to be an ... (Feb '14)||Apr '14||Reggie McWTF||6|
|The 5 Biggest NFL Draft Blunders in Oakland Rai... (Mar '14)||Mar '14||Reggie McWTF||6|
|How bad are things for Raiders? Even cheerleade... (Feb '14)||Feb '14||Laughing bear Fan||3|
|5 Potential First-Round Scenarios for the Oakla... (Feb '14)||Feb '14||King Ahzi||2|
Find what you want!
Search JaMarcus Russell Forum Now
Copyright © 2015 Topix LLC