What makes Ilan Hall Top Chef? - AM N...

What makes Ilan Hall Top Chef? - AM New York

There are 2 comments on the AM New York story from Feb 7, 2007, titled What makes Ilan Hall Top Chef? - AM New York. In it, AM New York reports that:

What did you make of Bravo's Top Chef, and what is this thing called "molecular gastronomy" that everyone kept talking about? I was completely addicted to the program, and, what's more, I think that the final ...

Join the discussion below, or Read more at AM New York.

Alexandra

Orange Grove, TX

#1 Feb 9, 2007
Obviously, you didn't bother to watch the whole season as you would have known the judges unfavorable belief on chefs cooking within their comfort zone. They gave Sam a whole speech on 'playing it safe' during the finale and sent him home because of it. So to assume that it was alright for Ilan to do so is unbelievable. Marcel was innovative and cooked dishes he had never done before. This was what the judges had been stressing from the beginning. In fact at the judges table they raved about his dishes while ridiculing Ilan's 'same ol' same ol' Spanish dishes, so why the total 180 by choosing him? And yes, some might say Marcel's underdevelopes social skills might have played a factor in his loss, Ilan was not a person of integrity. He bullied Marcel any chance he got and truly displayed poor sportsmanship throughout the season. In the end, the judges decided it was not who's food was better but who was mature enough for the title. To say that Ilan was 'mature' is an insult, he was downright mean and still to this day I believe he robbed Marcel of that title.
David

Orange Grove, TX

#2 Feb 9, 2007
Ilan didn't deserve that win. He has poor culinary skills to be matched with his poor people skills.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Spanish Cuisine Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News 50 meals everyone should eat in their lifetime (Nov '15) Nov '15 vietnam my love 1
News Bridgeport's East Side hopes to prosper from St... (Apr '15) Apr '15 American Gentlema... 1
How do you buy Spanish products in UK (Aug '14) Aug '14 Richard 1
Curso de cocina espaņola el 19 al 23 de Agosto ... (Jul '13) Jul '13 CervantesEI 1
spanish cuisine!! (Feb '08) Jun '13 Jose Granero 6
News Day 3 of Todd's Favorite Things brings Grand Ra... (Dec '12) Dec '12 Go Blue Forever 1
News The United Colors of Rice (Dec '11) Dec '11 Lisa Bentley 1
More from around the web