Ilan Wins! Robuchon coming to Chicago?

Ilan Wins! Robuchon coming to Chicago?

There are 5 comments on the story from Feb 1, 2007, titled Ilan Wins! Robuchon coming to Chicago?. In it, reports that:

There is no reason to beat around the bush: Ilan kicked the fois gras out of Marcel in last night's Top Chef finale.

Join the discussion below, or


Lakeport, CA

#1 Feb 1, 2007
Though I not a fan of Marcel's attitude, I don't think most of the others were without blame in their own attitudes and I think he was scapgoated. I think he is a superior cook to Illan because I think the competition was not about Spanish cusine. It seemed to me Ilan could not step outside of this box, though he obviously is talented. I believe Marcel would have won had he had the fish for the one dish in the finale.
Bob V

Omaha, NE

#2 Feb 2, 2007
I could'nt agree more with Pam-I have been slightly put off by Marcel throughout the competition, but there was never any question as to his ability, and moreover, his creativity. And as far as I could tell, anytime there was a conflict, while Marcel was always involved, he never initiated it. And throughout the competition, while most of the other chefs were content to languish in the middle of the pack by playing it safe(ie Ilan) Marcel was never afraid to step outside the boundries of conventional cuisine. Regardless of the finale, despite the title "Top Chef", its obvious to anyone that the more talented chef, was easily Marcel-congratulations young man-your future is very bright indeed!!
Bob B

Phoenix, AZ

#3 Feb 5, 2007
First of all, this should have been between Marcus and Sam. This last episode felt like many that came before it. I thought I was in junior high again. While Marcus is not my favorite personality, he was put upon and picked on in very imature ways throughout this entire series. Grow up people.

OK, what posessed Marcus to pick Mike in the end?

The way I heard the final course judging, I had Marcus up by one. He even wowed a very experienced table with a taste they had never had before. OK, by accident. It came down to a personality contest and the judges bias was clear.

I'll think I'll pass on this series from now on. It lacks ethics in my opinion.

United States

#4 Feb 7, 2007
Marcel would have won had he presented anything but his plain salad (though beautiful) as his second dish. Also, Ilan couldn't have pull it off without Eliah, who was by far a better cook than he was and executed his dishes better than he cold have done himself. Also, he didn't hurt Ilan than his teammates were behind him 100% while Marcel's were, let's say, less than enthusiastic about his presence on the finale.

Greenville, SC

#5 Jun 5, 2007
C.I.A. Student wins two years in a row!!

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Molecular Gastronomy Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News 4 Foods Americans Don't Eat Much Anymore (Aug '15) Aug '15 Elise Likes Vanilla 1
News Cuba's latest revolutionary trend: Fine dining (Jan '15) Jan '15 Thor 1
News Boy, 12, bitten by snake on Rottnest (Nov '14) Nov '14 The ADELAIDEAN 2
News Decoding Neanderthals (Jan '13) Oct '14 whatisyourneed 2
News LongHorn SteakHouse Open Soon (Dec '12) Sep '14 whatisyourneed 2
Molecular Gastronomy Studies (Apr '07) Aug '14 whatisyourneed 25
News The 10 Best Toronto Cocktail Bars (Oct '12) Oct '12 Bill 1
More from around the web