Winchester eatery serves up fine food...

Winchester eatery serves up fine food in a nice atmosphere

There are 18 comments on the The Star Press story from Oct 28, 2012, titled Winchester eatery serves up fine food in a nice atmosphere. In it, The Star Press reports that:

Seated in the attractive bar of the Randolph Grille, general manager Joy Chalfant was lauding her equally attractive restaurant.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at The Star Press.

different topic

Indianapolis, IN

#1 Oct 29, 2012
Someone must have known the press was coming to get good reviews!
Grille Fan

Chicago, IL

#2 Oct 30, 2012
Good Job Joy!
honey boo boo

United States

#3 Oct 30, 2012
there food SUCKS
GREAT FOOD

Winchester, IN

#4 Oct 30, 2012
i enjoy the breakfast buffet and always get great service . One of the nicer cleaner places in randolph county . I wish the other places were that clean and nice . anyone that trashes this fine place is no doubt another competing business or a disgruntled exemployee
different topic

Indianapolis, IN

#5 Oct 31, 2012
GREAT FOOD wrote:
i enjoy the breakfast buffet and always get great service . One of the nicer cleaner places in randolph county . I wish the other places were that clean and nice . anyone that trashes this fine place is no doubt another competing business or a disgruntled exemployee
No, not either. Just a customer that was dumb enough to give the place a second shot. They are horrible, especially for the price.
honey boo boo

United States

#6 Oct 31, 2012
honey boo boo wrote:
there food SUCKS
I have never worked there and do not have a bus. i gave them many chances there food sucks and high priced but i will say its clean place
Ashton

Chicago, IL

#7 Oct 31, 2012
if you dont like it then dont eat there...quit your bitching and get a real hobby
allaroundtown

United States

#8 Oct 31, 2012
Ate there the other evening. It was nastey. Wont go back. Went there once before, thought I would give them a second chance... YUCK YUCK YUCK
Michael Myers

United States

#9 Nov 1, 2012
The food there can be hit and miss. I have had food that was awesome. On the other hand i have had meat that is just tasteless. no seasoning or anything at all. I hope they would get consistency, I actually like going there to eat with the family.
different topic

Indianapolis, IN

#10 Nov 1, 2012
Ashton wrote:
if you dont like it then dont eat there...quit your bitching and get a real hobby
I don't eat there. I was giving my opinion sweet heart, not bashing, so grow up. They do need a better chef in there that is consistent. If it was good food I would pay the price, but it isn't. Therefore, this is one customer and family that will not be eating there until I see a real chef in the kitchen.
Michael Myers

United States

#11 Nov 2, 2012
Actually because of this post, thought about getting food there last night. Wasn't bad but just expensive. Not that I am complaining, but just shows you that sometimes it is good and sometimes it is bad. Service sucked much though. There wasn't very many people last night, but you would think with the service level, that place was packed.
honey boo boo

United States

#12 Nov 2, 2012
Ashton wrote:
if you dont like it then dont eat there...quit your bitching and get a real hobby
Dont worry smartass I dont and wont ever eat there again!
allaroundtown

United States

#13 Nov 2, 2012
The service does suck for sure, and that gay guy in there should not pose as the manager. He was suppost to be a cook or something to begin with.
frank

Elkhart, IN

#14 Nov 2, 2012
Have been many times. The food has never been bad or really good...just consistently "OK". It has always been expensive...service has been hit or miss...usually miss.Oh, and the atmosphere pretty much sucks. Other than that, its a great place.
Michael Myers

United States

#15 Nov 2, 2012
You know I am all for people in Randolph County having jobs and business thriving for this community. I love living here and pretty much this is where I was born and raised. Saying that, when things don't add up, I feel compelled to add my opinion, which last time I checked, pretty much one of my god given rights as an American. I don't see how a place can charge 8 dollars 95 cents for a cheese burger, 2 dollars 25 cents for a drink, and like 3 dollars 25 cents for french fries with a clear conscious. It was a good cheeseburger, but not 9 dollar good. Service did not make up for it. Spent a while with an empty glass. The waitress did come by grab my glass and return it to me. Unfortunately it was when I asked for my check, because I told her I was thirsty and was going to McDonalds to get a drink. Might have been rude, but if i am going to be ignored and treated like a hindrance, I will pretty much just stay home and let the wife do it. No need to pay good money and be treated like I wasn't there.
TCS

Cincinnati, OH

#16 Nov 2, 2012
Foods not great, not horrible. Yes, it is very clean, prices on the high side. SERVICE SUCKS!!! Been in there a few times & IT ALWAYS SUCKS. Wouldn't mind paying the price if you didn't wait forever for your food & check when they aren' that busy. Would much rather go to El Careton for great food, great prices & excellent service ALWAYS!!
Visitor

Chicago, IL

#17 Nov 3, 2012
Attending meeting in area next week, will have a meal and report back.
different topic

Indianapolis, IN

#18 Nov 5, 2012
TCS is right. El Carreton is the best and has great prices. The environment of the Grille doesn't make up for the poor service and food. I would rather eat good food with decent service in a shack than eat at the "fancy" Grille.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Food Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Why do I often crave eating clay? (Jan '09) 2 hr hajra mirembe 9,214
News Vienna Farmers Market Opening Soon 6 hr abe farag 3
News Captain D's Now Open in Franklin North Carolina (Nov '15) 12 hr Franklin eater 8
News Owners of The Bayou, Grain putting final touche... 17 hr Richard Kranium 2
News 'Man Fire Food' is enjoying 'Puerto Rican Grill... (Oct '15) 17 hr Caciques a liar 52
News Veganism - doing the right thing (Jul '11) Sep 26 Human 965
News Best places for breakfast in Buffalo: 5 WNY pla... (Dec '15) Sep 26 Kilhoffer Street ... 4
More from around the web