McStay Family Of 4 Has Been Missing F...

McStay Family Of 4 Has Been Missing For 3 Years

There are 1 comment on the The Huffington Post story from Jan 28, 2013, titled McStay Family Of 4 Has Been Missing For 3 Years. In it, The Huffington Post reports that:

Authorities have received hundreds of tips on the whereabouts of the family of four -- Joseph McStay, 43; his wife, Summer, 46; and their two kids, Gianni, 7, and Joseph Mateo, who would be 6 this month -- but have little more than a single clue in the case.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at The Huffington Post.


Riverside, CA

#1 Jan 28, 2013
Even though it is a mystery to us, something very real had to have happened. If one is to look at this case with pure logic then you will come to the 100% conclusion that Joseph McStay did not disapear on purpose.
The fact that he did not use his credit cards or go to the bank between feb.4th and feb. 8th proves this and infact that it is not him seen crossing the border. You can clearly see the head shape above the shoulders in the video and it is not Joseph McStay.
Also a sucessful small businessman with new family and house would never run away to mexico with his family and leave everthing behind including relatives and beloved dogs unless he committed some capitol crime. Which I'm sure did not happen. If he did then he would have taken some of, if not all, his money and made some kind of plans. That is the only way it could have happened with respect to this case.
I believe one can conclude with 100% certainty that something happened to Joseph McStay just after his last call on feb 4th.
I would also believe something happened to Summer McStay at that time except for one undenialable fact. Some adult in their home actually typed into a search engine the words to the effect "Do I need passports to bring children into Mexico", one week before they disapeared. Nothing was typed into a search asking "Do I need passports return back to the U.S. with my children". There is no realistic way in which someone would type those words into a search unless they were atleast thinking about doing just that, leave for good to mexico with their children.
Then one week later their car is parked 2 blocks away from the Mexico border along with the fact a family of four with
two small children is seen on video walking on foot across the border, around two hours later. These 3 facts combined together make it beyond being coincidence that atleast one McStay parent, the one who typed the search, and the two children are infact crossing the border. Someone may disagree with this conclusion, but when you have 2 extremely unlikely events occur that match together, the computer search and the car found 2 blocks from the border. Then along with a third event, a family seen crossing the border on video at the time which matches the time in which the
car was left, you now what must be a certainty.
With that said , if Joseph McStay did not leave on purpose then it then becomes a fact it must be Summer McStay who typed the search and went to Mexico with her children. In the border crossing video the woman is wearing a jacket that is an exact match with one Summer McStay was known to have. The jacket is one on the few things that is clearly seen. Also one can see that there is a man in the video with Summer McStay. Who is it? Since it cannot be Joseph McStay.
Furthermore these facts, as I have shown them , are the only logically way one can explain the fact that Joseph McStay did not use his credit cards or go to the bank after he disapeared feb 4th. However it can be easily explained how Summer McStay managed not to use any credit cards or go to bank after they disapeared, She had some help from someone, presumeably the man in the video.
Honestly I know only a few things about Summer McStay. Which only tend to fit the scenerio as I have shown. The fact that she did not want to leave San Clemente and move to Fallbrook. She changed her name a few times. Also She had recently had two children after being single most of her life.
These facts about Summer McStay alone mean nothing, but when combined with the facts of this case. Summer McStay is the only one between herself and her husband who could be involved with the disapearance of her family, as her husband Joseph McStay could not have been. The Police should ask their San Clemente neighbors what they saw if they have not already. The answer to who may be the unidentfied man in the video may be there.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Kids Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Unwanted Wizard101 accounts (Jun '10) 4 hr Clayton 2,736
News N.J. clears way for children of undocumented im... 7 hr wild child 1
News City kicks off annual Civic Days at Riverfront ... 8 hr Golf club 2
Unwanted "Stardoll" Accounts (May '10) 13 hr sydneyk19775 1,410
News College Kid: I'm Scared Of Having Kids Because ... 14 hr tina anne 3
News Best phone to track your kids? -- OrlandoSentin... (Jun '07) 16 hr Nikolas 15
fantage account (member) (Feb '10) Tue bellastram 5,254
moviestarplanet free account! (Jul '13) Tue Pump169 574
More from around the web