Is coffee really dehydrating?

Is coffee really dehydrating?

There are 2 comments on the New York Daily News story from Jan 10, 2014, titled Is coffee really dehydrating?. In it, New York Daily News reports that:

A small study of 50 men by Birmingham University found that drinking four cups of coffee a day left subjects no more dehydrated than when they drank water instead.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at New York Daily News.

My2Yen

Toyonaka, Japan

#1 Jan 12, 2014
PLOS is a peer-reviewed journal....  Do most of the peers also receive money from the coffee industry?  By reading the study (which I did), it was obvious the researchers had already decided what kind of a result they wanted to find!

Based on the source of their funding, the researchers had set up the research study to reduce the concerns about dehydration.    
"Furthermore, if participants felt they were not allocated a sufficient volume of water at any point during the first trial or indeed if they had too much water, they were permitted to return to the laboratory to have their fluid allocation amended. "

Feel parched?  Come to the lab, and we will give you more water! End of research period, nobody appears dehydrated!  Conclusion = Coffee does not make you dehydrated!

WHAT KIND OF A SCIENTIFIC STUDY (for dehydration) IS THIS?

BOGUS, fake, spurious, false, fraudulent, sham, deceptive; counterfeit, forged, feigned; make-believe, dummy, pseudo, phony, pretend, fictitious.(any more synonyms?)  

It is shoddy research practices and shoddy reporting like this which promotes politicians to reduce funding for real research!
shailluis

Moradabad, India

#3 Jul 4, 2014
no sir ,i dont think so that coffee dehydrates our body ........
but i think that coffee refresh our body as well as our mind......

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Coffee Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Jammin' Java's Going Head to Head With the 9:30... Jun 30 Thunder 1
News Starbucks Baristas in Trouble for Putting 'Buil... Jun 27 totallydisgusted 4
Coffee instantly or nearly so Jun '17 best coffee hack 1
News A fixture for 60 years, the Safety Harbor Post ... May '17 AmyBryant 2
News Fantastic New Option for Coffee in The Valley May '17 Erik 3
News NYC cafe suing Starbucks over 'unicorn frappucc... May '17 Suezanne 4
News New Coffee Roasting Business Coming To Downtown... Apr '17 Dusty 5
More from around the web