Spain celebrates Columbus, descendant...

Spain celebrates Columbus, descendants defend his legacy

There are 67 comments on the South Asian Women Forum story from May 20, 2006, titled Spain celebrates Columbus, descendants defend his legacy. In it, South Asian Women Forum reports that:

The argument over whether Columbus was a source for good or a wealth-crazed egoist who ran roughshod over native American culture when he and his fellows came ashore in 1492 has fuelled interest in the ...

Join the discussion below, or Read more at South Asian Women Forum.

First Prev
of 4
Next Last
just stand up

Chicago, IL

#62 Oct 21, 2012
The sad part is that my country the USA still celebrates a holiday for this piece of s**t. The fact that Columbus came here by mistake going to India/China, and then came back only to have the natives mine the land for a gold to fill up queen Isabella's pockets in return have the natives all massacred and plagued by diseases so they could clear the islands of Hispaniola to make way for a new Spanish colony for Spain and set up catholic churches to convert what was left of the natives and ten have slaves to cultivate the land while dehumanizing them which Columbus was aware of. To still have this holiday is sickening ,and I think here should be a petition to cut Columbus day. For real!!!
Fernando

Miami, FL

#63 Aug 27, 2013
I'm Dominican and your points are incorrect.
We share very little with Haiti, even though we have our own variety of Spanish. It does not preclude us from at least sounding "educated" Mr. Afro.
Plenty of Dominicans have mixed European and African blood, but also many others exclusively European and others are exclusively African. As it were my friend, who I truly greatly doubt are in face Dominican. Many of us are mulatto, and others indeed mestizo.

Your ignorance and inaccurate comments do us all a great diservice my friend.

Because even though we all have a voice it does not mean that voice, if foolish like yours must be heard.
What you are is a Haitian, a Haitian who denies his background and claims he is a Dominican in order to impeach, denigrate and generalize.

"I know I'm great, cuz haters gotta hate"
AfroDR wrote:
Colombus only brought terror to the western hemisphere. The dominican republic is majorly of african descent and thanks to him and the spaniards along with most europeans. We still live in mental slavery. Good hair bad hair, all that bull. Everyone wants to be so european, even though they are not. We have to deal with tryign to speak like a spaniard, and are ashamed to speak our africanized spanish, "ke lo ke". We also have to deal with false borders like the one diving us from Haiti. We are one people, one african brethren, we even come from the same regions of africa. The only thing dividing us is a language and lots of ignorance. In central america and mexico they have to deal with borders and all these names, guatemala, el salvador, names that never existed prior to colombus. In wish the Anauhac people of mexico lived as one stretching from the midwest USA down to central america. Thankyou colombus, for, wiping out millions of native americans, enslaving millions of africans, and bringing over with you all these dividers that split the land like cake. Thankyou for making it so that everyone who does not look like you, is born inferior. Thankyou.
Milkdud

Killeen, TX

#65 Oct 21, 2014
I agree. Columbus and his men did cause chaos upon the natives they encountered, but I will argue, it was the times. Everyone who has something to say about what he did, or didn't do, is simply looking at the past through modern eyes. Perhaps if one can gain access to a time machine, go back in time, then slay him before he makes his big landing then....wait, we wouldn't be here discussing this - we would have never existed because the timeline of History would have changed. Sooooo, thanks Columbus!
Eduardo

Mexico

#67 Oct 26, 2014
just stand up wrote:
The sad part is that my country the USA still celebrates a holiday for this piece of s**t. The fact that Columbus came here by mistake going to India/China, and then came back only to have the natives mine the land for a gold to fill up queen Isabella's pockets in return have the natives all massacred and plagued by diseases so they could clear the islands of Hispaniola to make way for a new Spanish colony for Spain and set up catholic churches to convert what was left of the natives and ten have slaves to cultivate the land while dehumanizing them which Columbus was aware of. To still have this holiday is sickening ,and I think here should be a petition to cut Columbus day. For real!!!
Columbus day is celebrated because it was originally intended as one of those Ethnic Days, like Saint Patrick's Day or Cinco de Mayo but for the Italian-Americans.
Basque_Spaniards

Bilbao, Spain

#68 Oct 27, 2014
One thing that in america is unknown. Isabel, the Catholic queen of spain, made a law to protect the Indians. Nevertheless, what spain sent to the Americas was the worst people of spain: Thieves in majority of the cases.
When Columbus showed the Spanish Queen the Indians of America with chains and badly treated at the court, she get angry enourmously and blamed Columbus of that. Columbus, at the end, was imprisioned and dispossessed of all titles.
Columbus cant controlled the spanish troops that were sent to the americas and was charged as the responsible maximum. After that the Queen gave controll to the Church the american enterprise.
Spain did good and bad things in america like the British did. Everything was made to magnify the glory of the country.
karmaisabeach

Fort Lauderdale, FL

#69 Oct 29, 2014
You say white people conquer so what...But those Haitian were enslaved and raped for hundreds of years all over the world, but when a few Haitians fight back and get free then rape your women, you want to kill them all...no you kill yourself for coming from white heat..The Bible says the sins of the father will be visited on the son...aka...karma is a bitch.

Since: Dec 14

Hanoi, Vietnam

#72 Dec 17, 2014
Dont allow ignorance to separate us any further
----
http://www.clickjogosclick.com/jogos-dia-de-p...

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 4
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Sanchez, Dominican Republic Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Family of Merrimack drowning victim looking for... (Aug '14) Aug '14 Sanchez 2
News In Cuba, trend seen away from eccentric names (Feb '14) Feb '14 WE JUST DONT CARE 2
News Former girlfriend of Clifton Powerball jackpot ... (Nov '13) Nov '13 wicked people stink 15
News NJ man in court over Powerball win (Nov '13) Nov '13 John Snow 12
News Danbury Jerk Fest (Sep '13) Sep '13 Black Peter 1
News 200 fall sick due to food poisoning at Dominica... (Apr '10) May '13 mybackfkinghurts 5
News N.J. Deli Worker With $338 Million Lottery Tick... (Mar '13) Mar '13 carlos 2
More from around the web