ACLU wants random drug testing halted...

ACLU wants random drug testing halted in Pike County school district

There are 3 comments on the The Times-Tribune story from Jun 14, 2011, titled ACLU wants random drug testing halted in Pike County school district. In it, The Times-Tribune reports that:

A Pike County judge listened to several hours of arguments Monday on the legality of a random drug-testing policy at Delaware Valley School District but delayed issuing a ruling until more court papers are filed.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at The Times-Tribune.


Sacramento, CA

#1 Jun 18, 2011
I oppose random drug testing in schools strongly enough that I would homeschool rather than send my children to a school that does such a thing. The fact it is intended to help is irrelevant; any drug test anywhere would be justifiable based on that logic.

Effectiveness is also irrelevant. These policies can certainly be expected to deter the use of the drugs that reliably stay in the urine for more than two days. Of course, it would not deter the use of the many others that do not (or worse, those not detected at all). In any event, it does not matter.

As former Washington state supreme court justice Richard Sanders wrote in York v. Wahkiakum (the Washington state supreme court completely striking down RSDT), every person has a fundamental moral right to control his/her own bodily functions. Ordering a person to provide a urine sample on demand is, in itself, a significant intrusion on his/her moral right to privacy, regardless of how the sample is collected.

That should be obvious common sense. Certain judges, school administrators, and parents simply choose to ignore the truth because of expediency.

These policies are far more harmful to society than drugs. These policies raise children who will be contemptuous of search and seizure rights and other rights. The children will be more likely to buy into concepts such as "if you nothing to hide, you have nothing to fear." They will be more apt to allow police to freely search their homes.
Kathy Kiederer explains this issue very well.

It amazes me that proponents think that telling me stories of teens who died from overdoses or became addicted think that will have any effect on my stand. My stand is based on principles. My stand only holds firmer.
R M Poe

Pinnacle, NC

#2 Jun 19, 2011
More on this at
R M Poe

Pinnacle, NC

#3 Jun 19, 2011
or this one, both are great articles...

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Pike County Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Tonkin faces new threat (Sep '15) Dec '15 Mario 2
News Pike County man sentenced to decades for child ... (Sep '15) Sep '15 reneemoran32 1
News Support DA Tonkin for another term (Jun '15) Jun '15 Dan 1
News NJ man gets jail time for assaulting woman in P... (May '15) May '15 disgusted 1
News For Shohola's sake, end the Walls drama (Jun '12) Apr '15 Kathy D 7
News Kelly Gaughan announces run for Pike DA (Jan '15) Jan '15 goawayray 2
News Police: No comment on reports of Frein letter (Oct '14) Oct '14 Kelly 1
More from around the web