Mainsville man gets new trial in shoo...

Mainsville man gets new trial in shooting death of neighbor

There are 43 comments on the Public Opinion story from Jun 2, 2011, titled Mainsville man gets new trial in shooting death of neighbor. In it, Public Opinion reports that:

Chad Kirby's conviction in the 2009 shooting death of his neighbor has been overturned and a judge has ordered a new trial for the Mainsville man.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at Public Opinion.

First Prev
of 3
Next Last
Igor of Frankenville

Carlisle, PA

#45 Jun 3, 2011
Ms Stevenson wrote:
<quoted text> "Judge Learned Hand" - what kind of name is that? Besides one to hide behind when you make comments on a post and are too afraid to post your real name. That's a pretty big accusation to make against Weisbrod - "stole" money huh? Did you report him to the police - I mean that makes him a criminal right? DA Fogal will probably prosecute him for representing a client that paid him to defend him. Right? "After his malpractice" what? Do you realize that a jury made the decision to find him guilty? If you knew anything about the case (which you obviously don't) you would realize this is about the law.
HE STOLE HIS MONEY DOING A CRAPPY JOB! THAT IS WHY THE JUDGE GAVE A NEW TRIAL. HE SAID WISEBOARD SCREWED UP THE CASE. THE JURY FOUND HIM GUILTY BECAUSE WISEBORAD WAS A CLUELESS LAWYER.
DAVE GALLO

Carlisle, PA

#46 Jun 3, 2011
I think Mr. Kirby got a raw deal, he was only protecting his family. And Buttermore was way out of control and was the bad guy in this event. Any person who would go to an other person's house and do what he did was very much in the wrong.
If he had a problem with Kirby, he should have called the State Police. Instead of doing what he did. Mr.Kirby, thought his family was being threaten and he reacted to save his family. I think,that is what anyone would do if they were in his shoes.
Old Timer

Shippensburg, PA

#47 Jun 8, 2011
Was the invader really shot IN THE BACK? OR as it IN THE SIDE as he was getting ready for another swing with the baseball bat? By the way how many of you have personally bit hit with a swinging baseball bat in the hands of another person?
Personally I would like to read the autopsy report on the subject, not JUST hearing what someone else has reported as their version of events, seeing is much more believable than hearing another person's version.
10 persons at the scene of an event can give you 10 different versions at the time and 10 more different versions a few days later. Who would you really believe?

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 3
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Franklin County Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Vincent e martz-egor Mar '16 Paula stuff 1
News Local educator turns up in diploma-mill case | ... (Jun '10) Mar '16 TruthSquad 8
News Franklin County row officers suggest budget cuts (Mar '09) Feb '16 Ace1234 26
News Supreme Court refuses to hear CASD appeal (Jul '15) Aug '15 Backward Hicks 3
the four state slasher con! horror and rock n r... (Mar '15) Mar '15 fourstateslashercon 1
News Cold Case: The murder of Freddie Brumfield & th... (Jun '12) Mar '15 Carmella 5
News CASD seeks to remove Dusman as assistant superi... (Dec '14) Dec '14 GenPatton 5
More from around the web