Second trial set to start in Cambridg...

Second trial set to start in Cambridge Springs homicide

There are 23 comments on the Go Erie story from Sep 14, 2009, titled Second trial set to start in Cambridge Springs homicide. In it, Go Erie reports that:

Jury selection has begun in the second homicide trial of a Cambridge Springs woman accused of fatally injuring her former fiance's young daughter.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at Go Erie.

First Prev
of 2
Next Last

“6 times baby! Count 'em!”

Since: Feb 09

Meadville

#1 Sep 16, 2009
Double jeporady?
Waiting on verdict

Meadville, PA

#2 Sep 16, 2009
It's not "double jeporady" ! There was NO verdict in the last trial - learn your terminology!

“6 times baby! Count 'em!”

Since: Feb 09

Meadville

#3 Sep 17, 2009
Go F*** yourself eh.
Waiting on verdict

Meadville, PA

#4 Sep 17, 2009
Say, why don't you go f**k yourself! Oh, and Melynda too!! That B**CH is GUILTY!!!! LMAO!!!! TOLD YOU!

“6 times baby! Count 'em!”

Since: Feb 09

Meadville

#5 Sep 17, 2009
Being found guilty and being guilty,............two different things.
you no me

Belle Vernon, PA

#6 Sep 17, 2009
I NEW THE BITCH KILLED HER I TOLD U ALL..
Waiting on verdict

Meadville, PA

#7 Sep 17, 2009
Ya, ya, ya .... it's your "story", tell it how you like! The truth is out and the jury is back! Time for you all to face the fact that she IS GUILTY!! Funny, you all said you were waiting on the JURY to decide and would accept whatever they said. Now that they've done it, and it's not what you wanted, you can't accept it for what it is and now come up with more excusses! Face it, she's guilty and will NEVER shake another baby again!!!

“6 times baby! Count 'em!”

Since: Feb 09

Meadville

#8 Sep 18, 2009
you no me wrote:
I NEW THE BITCH KILLED HER I TOLD U ALL..
The only thing I am positive that you know, is that your spelling and language skills are shat.
Tell ya the truth, I could give a crap less.
you no me

Belle Vernon, PA

#9 Sep 18, 2009
BoomOfSteel wrote:
<quoted text>
The only thing I am positive that you know, is that your spelling and language skills are shat.
Tell ya the truth, I could give a crap less.
are u upset cause she was found guilty..i'm sorry that ur friend is now listed as a BABYKILLER..justice was served an me an my family are happy with the verdict..thank u an may god bless u..

“6 times baby! Count 'em!”

Since: Feb 09

Meadville

#10 Sep 18, 2009
She is not my friend, I have never met her. If she did indeed do this, she will face far worse than what the courts have in store for her.

“GodBless+KeepYou”

Since: Oct 08

Crawford County

#11 Sep 18, 2009
Ladies, meet BoomOfSteel... he works at the CS SCI. He knows what he's talking about.
BTW, Boom: very astute comment. Thanks.
GBKY
you no me

Belle Vernon, PA

#12 Sep 20, 2009
there is no point in tryin to talk to people anymore..justice was served to kierstan an thats all i will say..why are u guys still talkin..melynda was proven GUILTY..now she has to live with that her WHOLE life..now my niece shall REST IN PEACE..god bless all u..

“6 times baby! Count 'em!”

Since: Feb 09

Meadville

#13 Sep 20, 2009
God bless you too. Now go crawl back under your rock.

“GodBless+KeepYou”

Since: Oct 08

Crawford County

#14 Sep 20, 2009
LOL, Boom! What's funny is you've probably met all of us --'somewhere' in Cambridge Springs. I guarantee it!
GBKY

“6 times baby! Count 'em!”

Since: Feb 09

Meadville

#15 Sep 20, 2009
Agreed. I used to frequent the coffee shop, now I am an infrequent visitor. I used to stop for an ale occasionally, now it's too risky.
Waiting on verdict

Meadville, PA

#16 Sep 22, 2009
Too risky is right! Especially if your kids are with you! NO one is safe until that murder is behind bars where she belongs!!! Dec 7th - 9:15am - woot woot!!

“6 times baby! Count 'em!”

Since: Feb 09

Meadville

#17 Sep 23, 2009
Waiting on verdict wrote:
Too risky is right! Especially if your kids are with you! NO one is safe until that murder is behind bars where she belongs!!! Dec 7th - 9:15am - woot woot!!
To be specific, the term is "murderer". Also I believe it's spelled "whoot whoot". But I shouldn't correct someone (yes, someone, NOT some one) as perfect as you.
Please do not take this post as a defense of Melinda, it is not.
I followed this case only in the papers, and unless you know something I don't genius, it didn't prove a thing to me.
2 experts said two different things. So one of them isn't an "expert" is he?
Only 2 people know if she did something wrong. Her, and the Lord Almighty. Dispute that.
Waiting on verdict

Meadville, PA

#18 Sep 23, 2009
Well maybe you should have sat through the trial and listened to ALL the testimony and evidence like I did! The paper doesn't report everything! BOTH doctors agreed on what her injuries were - the conclusion was different!

Dr. Veys conclusion was that ALL of Kierstans injuries could NOT have come from a simple fall onto a plastic car seat! If that were the case, children would be dieing on a daily basis!! COMMON SENCE!!

Dr. Smith agreed with EVERYTHING Dr. Vey said, except that it was a result of abuse. Of course he's going to say that, he was paid $4,000 to do so!! All coming from a Dr. who hasn't practiced medicine since the late 70's!

Think what you want ... doesn't really matter now does it? She's been found guilty in a court of law by a jury of her peers! In a few short months, she'll be off to prison - to rot away! AMEN!!

“6 times baby! Count 'em!”

Since: Feb 09

Meadville

#19 Sep 24, 2009
You seem dissatisfied with just the verdict. Get over it. She was found guilty. There is your closure.
Or..........you can continue to be classless, you can taunt and say "YEAAAAHHH! I told you so!!!"
I don't much give a rats azz either way on this verdict. As I said, if she did it, a bigger punishment awaits her. If she didn't, I am sorry she is serving years of her life for something she didn't do.
Now, what ya gonna do Waiting? Take the high road with closure, or the low road like trailer scum?
Waiting on verdict

Meadville, PA

#20 Sep 28, 2009
Didn't need a verdict to give me closure, I had that long before! The only thing the verdict did was close the legal case!!

FYI, I am not dissatisfied with the verdict!! I am VERY satisfied with it - but thanks anyway.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 2
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Crawford County Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News 2 firefighters injured in Cochranton-area blaze (Jul '10) Jun '16 Cochranton Knights 3
Pumpkin Fest (Apr '16) Apr '16 rsmrmyr 1
News Erie County's population sinks for a fourth str... (Mar '16) Mar '16 GOP 6
News Coming Aug. 23, Kickoff has you covered (Aug '15) Aug '15 Not in HS anymore 1
News Cochranton Man to Serve Jail Time for Child End... (Mar '15) Mar '15 poop stain 1
News The Voodoo they do so well at this Meadville br... (May '14) May '14 jeff 4
News Thunderstorm watch, flood warning issued for Er... (May '14) May '14 Uncle Ted 2
More from around the web