Deputy-involved shooting under investigation

Apr 30, 2012 Full story: NBC2 News

An off-duty Collier County Sheriff's deputy was involved in a shooting around 6:45 a.m. Sunday morning at his home in Golden Gate Estates.

Full Story
Mick

Fort Myers, FL

#1 May 1, 2012
The mother of this man is on the television saying the man who shot the unstable intruder didn't have to shoot him. If someone was at her back door, breaking into her home and threatening to kill, what would she do? Would she ask the mental history of the intruder? Or would she feel threatened and attempt to protect herself?
The mother states she was afraid of her son, and knowing of his mental condition, allowed him to leave the home, apparently in a rage.
A responsible individual might would have called the authorities, at the very least followed the mentally unstable person until someone can take control of the situation. Now we have a mentally unstable person rampaging and terrorizing the neighborhood, and the mother is blaming the police officer for protecting himself. Who in this situation is really responsible? Why is the mother blaming the wrong person, perhaps the mother should take some responsibility.
If there was someone at my back door, threatening me and attempting to break into my home, I would attempt to protect my home as well, I would not stop to check the mental condition of the intruder.
The man suffering from Schizophrenia should have been in the care of individuals that can control the situation, and see that the individual is taking the proper medications. This incident could have been prevented; unfortunately we have irresponsible people in the world whom are not capable of taking responsibility.
ThatWhichisThus

Englewood, FL

#2 Jun 14, 2012
Mick wrote:
The mother of this man is on the television saying the man who shot the unstable intruder didn't have to shoot him. If someone was at her back door, breaking into her home and threatening to kill, what would she do? Would she ask the mental history of the intruder? Or would she feel threatened and attempt to protect herself?
The mother states she was afraid of her son, and knowing of his mental condition, allowed him to leave the home, apparently in a rage.
A responsible individual might would have called the authorities, at the very least followed the mentally unstable person until someone can take control of the situation. Now we have a mentally unstable person rampaging and terrorizing the neighborhood, and the mother is blaming the police officer for protecting himself. Who in this situation is really responsible? Why is the mother blaming the wrong person, perhaps the mother should take some responsibility.
If there was someone at my back door, threatening me and attempting to break into my home, I would attempt to protect my home as well, I would not stop to check the mental condition of the intruder.
The man suffering from Schizophrenia should have been in the care of individuals that can control the situation, and see that the individual is taking the proper medications. This incident could have been prevented; unfortunately we have irresponsible people in the world whom are not capable of taking responsibility.
What would you have done? I would imagine any law enforcement officer would tell you to call 911 and stay inside your home. No, instead this officer decided it bright to confront him and mow him down.

We live in a very high-strung society, and I feel so even more now that we cannot trust LEOs to abide by the laws of what would be considered a rational reaction to a threat from a highly troubled fellow human being.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Collier County Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Nachito Herrera, Cuban Piano Virtuoso, Returns ... Mon NWAC 4
Home invasion task force: - We won't leave any ... (Apr '14) Dec '14 Ugiftedgirl 2
Families struggle with poverty Dec '14 LEO 477 1
Sgt. Young appears in court for domestic violen... (Aug '14) Aug '14 lillian calloway 1
Naples neighborhood says 'No' to large gas stat... (Jul '14) Jul '14 Mark 1
Collier commissioners fighting mega gas station... (Jul '14) Jul '14 Tom Conroy 1
Group of local teens to participate in on-line ... (Jul '14) Jul '14 LEO 477 1
More from around the web