Roche, ImmunoGen Bullseye Breast-Cancer Drug Wins Approval
Join the discussion below, or Read more at The Washington Post.
Since: Dec 05
#1 Feb 22, 2013
In regards to response to anti-HER2 therapy after treatment with Kadcyla, Ive heard from breast cancer patients who were bumped from the T-DM1 clinical trial because of disease progression, which meant that their cancer was growing despite the drug. Bumped off the trial because of disease progression? Wonder how many more patients there were like this?
Response rates (how much a tumor decreased in size) can be inflated when excluding patients during clinical trials (evaluable patients). Patients not considered evaluable are often those who do not get the benefit of an entire treatment plan. The response rate is calculated after removing patients, who die or have been excluded, from the calculation. This inflates the response rate.
But clinical oncologists want to publish their papers. They need to report on the outcomes of their experiments, but if they had to wait for survival data, it could take years until all the data was aggregated. That wouldnt bode well for them to participate in pharma-sponsored trials in the future.
Response rates give clinical oncologists the opportunity to take a more optimistic look at therapies that have limited success. They can describe results as being complete remission, partial remission or simply clinical improvement.
If they treat all patients for three weeks, they can fairly evaluate the efficacy of a compound, which takes that lone (on average) before it can be regarded as effective. If they disregard all patients who die or were excluded after onset of therapy, and include only those treated three weeks or more, they can improve their data.
To justify their existence, they have to publish papers. Thats what they do.
Add your comments below
|What gives (Feb '15)||Feb '15||Bookrep||1|
|Company seeks approval for skin cancer drug (Jan '15)||Jan '15||Cathy Smith||1|
|UCSF geneticist joins Google's Calico project (Apr '14)||Apr '14||Guest||1|
|Zelboraf Ripoff of Melanoma Patients (Nov '11)||Nov '13||Ye li||4|
|Tarceva meets goal in first-line lung cancer trial (Nov '08)||Nov '13||Avi||5|
|Studies: Avastin may fight early breast cancers (Mar '12)||Sep '13||Sabastian||2|
|Questions Swirl Around Avastin (Jun '09)||Sep '13||Jesus||2|
Find what you want!
Search Genentech Forum Now
Copyright © 2016 Topix LLC