First Niagara Profit Rises as Bank Re...

First Niagara Profit Rises as Bank Readies for HSBC Branches

There are 2 comments on the American Banker story from Apr 19, 2012, titled First Niagara Profit Rises as Bank Readies for HSBC Branches. In it, American Banker reports that:

First Niagara Financial Group's first-quarter profit rose, as the bank boosted its commercial lending and picked up more checking account customers.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at American Banker.

Michael Mason-Mahon


#1 Apr 20, 2012
Did the Chairman and CEO HSBC PLC show "Courageous Integrity" in India?

Once again reading HSBC's Annual Report and the words of the Chairman and CEO what wisdom these men have, you may think.

Please do not be fooled by their words, the following details will call into question how truthful these words are.

Mr Flints states
"Similarly when things go wrong, as they will from time to time, we judge ourselves, inter alia, against how we respond and how quickly we learn from the experience. Nothing is more important than our reputation". He goes on "We are truly sorry to all those who were adversely affected by our failings"

On being transparent “Once you’ve got used to the fact of being more transparent, it becomes a way of life".

Dealing with complaints in India and around the world I have found HSBC, the Chairman and CEO to be less than transparent.

Will the Chairman be telling the truth to shareholders at this tear's AGM or like last year providing more False and Misleading information to shareholders. Try telling the truth Mr Flint? That would be something New.

Mr Gulliver states
"We are putting a new emphasis on values at HSBC, so that our employees are empowered to do the right thing and to act with courageous integrity.
"We are profoundly sorry about what happened and are committed to standing fully behind our customers".

When we contacted the Chairman and the CEO about a complaint and asking them to make sure HSBC India released information to the complainant that they had complied with the Rules and Regulation in India, they did not even answer her. Sent her statement to the wrong address for over five years.Many more complainants has received the same treatment in India.

Is this what they mean about "courageous integrity and are committed to standing fully behind our customers" ask their customers in India what they think about the Chairman stating "We are truly sorry to all those who were adversely affected by our failings".

They are just words with no real action to resolve the failing of HSBC India, their only action was to sell off the written off credit card and personal loan debt for $10 million. Is this less than what has been awarded to the CEO Mr Gulliver this year?

His award was for showing personal adherence to leadership in promoting HSBC Values. This over-riding assesses behavior around the HSBC Values principles of being 'open, connected and dependable' and acting with "courageous integrity"

Mr Laidlaw (CEO of Centrica) sits on the Remuneration Committee of HSBC (Fee £125,00), this is the same man who is the CEO of Centrica owners of British Gas who was fined £2.5 million is the largest ever issued by Ofgem for customer service issues.

Mr Laidlaw should deal with the problems at his company instead of sitting as a Board Director of other companies. Has he showed "Courageous Integrity" to the customers of British Gas?
Michael Mason-Mahon


#2 Apr 21, 2012
It is not just customers that have had problems with HSBC?
HSBC Holdings Plc (HSBA) settled a lawsuit brought by a group of Taiwanese banks that accused HSBC Bank USA of helping deceased financier Danny Pang’s PEM Group defraud them of more than $500 million.
The Taiwanese banks accused HSBC Bank USA of lying to investors about how long the bank serviced PEM Group’s investments and falsely representing that PEM Group’s previous investment products had performed in conformity with their offering memorandums. Hua Nan Commercial Bank claimed $191 million in losses.
“The parties to the litigation did reach a settlement on mutually agreeable terms,” Alexander Pilmer, a lawyer for the Taiwanese banks, said in an e-mail. He said he couldn’t provide additional information.
Is this HSBC's idea of "Courageous Integrity????
Mr Flints says "Nothing is more important than our reputation" may I ask what are you doing to HSBC's reputation?

"and values to do well for those who place their trust in us, thereby meeting their expectations of us and contributing to the fulfilment of their aspirations and ambitions. That is what we exist to do".

I have to say Mr Chairman it is my personal belief that by your's and Mr Gulliver's behaviour to people in India you have killed their aspiration and ambitions. Is that what you exist to do? For this is what you have done.

Is it "Courageous Integrity" (Fearless Honesty) that they showed the complainants in India or was it Faint -Hearted-ness (Cowardice)? People put their trust into HSBC India which they have come to deeply regret.

"Reputational issues which remind us that our good work can be destroyed by lapses of judgement or control".

Did the Chairman have a lapse of judgement or control when he gave false information at last years AGM about the problems in India?

Ask the people in India who have had very serious problems with the employees and the way HSBC Business has effect them?

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

First Niagara Financial Group Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Harleysville National to be sold (Sep '11) Sep '11 Josh 1
News Harleysville National Corp. Being Acquired by B... (Jul '09) Jul '09 comment 11
News First Niagara purchasing 57 branches and $4.2 b... (Apr '09) Apr '09 Observer 1
News Branch buyer eyed (Mar '09) Mar '09 cldk 2
News First Niagara Names Frank J. Polino as Interim ... (Aug '07) Aug '07 Dumb Redneck 2
More from around the web