Different results for beam3 and beam188

Different results for beam3 and beam188

Posted in the ANSYS Forum

Since: Jul 11


#1 Jul 25, 2011
I tried to use ansys13 to study the effect of self weight on a Cantilever Beam, by following this tutorial: http://www.mece.ualberta.ca/tutorials/ansys/I... . But I used beam188 as beam3 is no longer supported in ansys13, and I defined a rectangular section (B=50,h=10) instead of defining real constants (which is not possible for beam188). Instead of obtaining a 5.77 mm deflection (result found in the tutorial), I obtained a 0.22 mm deflection!! I tried to modify beam188 options, but I obtained the same result :(
Can you explain that? Is that due to the difference between beam3 and beam188? or there is a parameter that I should fix?
Thanks for your answers.

Kollam, India

#2 Sep 23, 2011
can anyone pls do help me in getting an awareness for using beam 188

Guangzhou, China

#4 Aug 21, 2012
I just come to here and see there was no reply to princebouja. The diferent results come from the use of different gravity direction.

Indore, India

#5 Jan 29, 2013
In beam-common section option interchange the B and H values.

Athens, Greece

#6 Sep 4, 2013
Hi at sections, in b put the number of h, and in h the number of b, the reason is the Izz . . .

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

ANSYS Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
ANSYS workbench toolbox (Jul '10) Wed A Q kHAN 49
Combin14 Rotation Wed Mark Gerega 2
no servers provided (Jul '10) Nov 21 Harvey 12
Safety Factor on a layered section (Apr '13) Nov 12 Random 2
Ansys harmonic loading Nov 12 sumit0501012 1
Protruding rod from a 3d block Nov 2 newuser 1
Problem in applying rotational constraints in a... Oct '15 alexskerhut 1
More from around the web