The Most Underrated Congress of All Time
Posted in the Columbus Forum
#1 Oct 1, 2013
The Most Underrated Congress of All Time
They may be nuts, but they're all you've got.
OCTOBER 1, 2013 By David Harsanyi
Liberals pundits and politicians like to refer to them as hostage takers,anarchists,politica l terrorists,lemmings with suicide vests, and so on. Grassroots conservatives think theyre a bunch of weak-kneed RINO defeatists. They have no charismatic stars, few compelling ideas, no one leading a grand ideological Gingrich-like charge against liberal institutions. There is no cohesive strategy to speak of, no Tom Delay whipping the troops into line, no ideological cohesion and no chance of winning very much.
And theyre probably the best thing going in Washington right now.
As we maneuver through another shutdown saga, John Boehners fate reminds me of the scene in Woody Allens Love and Death, in which a blundering war hero, returning from the Napoleonic Wars, is confronted by a Russian nobleman:
Nobleman: I understand your heroism was quite inadvertent.
Allen: You should have such inadvertent heroism.
There is a metaphysical truth that most small-government types would likely agree on but rarely admit: most of the time doing nothing is a lot more constructive than doing something. And no ones done nothing quite like the Boehner-led House. Sure, theres a lot of big talk from Republican Senators, but its the House that doesnt get stuff done.
After the passage of health care reform, the most consequential legislation in many of our lifetimes (enacted without a single vote from the minority), a new regulatory regime for the financial sector and a near-trillion dollar stimulus that funded an array of left-wing hobbyhorses, proper checks and balances finally kicked in. The House slowed the progressive agenda in 2010, stopping the majoritys steamrolling. Unless the GOP loses House in 2014, Obamas seen his last major reform.
And when the House anarchists do hold out, as they did with the debt ceiling in 2010, theyve compelled the majority to genuine compromise. Now, according to the Congressional Budget Office, sequestration only trims around $44 billion in 2013 or a 1.5 percent of the budget. Sad as it is, that makes sequestration one of the most successful spending cuts in the past two decades. Even more significantly, it illustrated to many voters that, contra the Chicken Littles, a cut isnt tantamount to national suicide.
Thats not to say that this brand of hostage taking(née negotiations) hasnt taken its toll. It seems that pundits have suffered most.Is this the kind of government our Founders envisioned? asks a worked-up Roger Simon in Politico. The answer is, yes, it probably is. In a Republic, majoritarian rule is checked and the president doesnt get to unilaterally dictate which legislation is negotiable.
Obamacare passed. The Supreme Court told us that government coercing Americans to purchase health care is kosher. Americans went ahead and voted for Obama a second time around. Thats life. And political reality means that Republicans probably wont be able to stop Obamacare any time soon if ever. At some point, theyll fold.
But in the meantime, the minority is using every leverage point available to them to try and slow implementation. This is neither unprecedented nor unfathomable. Do they know what the hell theyre doing? I doubt it. But, at the end of the day, the country is still talking about Obamacare rather than some phony administration job bill. Thats a win.
#2 Oct 1, 2013
The Washington Posts Dan Balz recently pointed out that House Republicans are continuing to grapple unsuccessfully with what it means to be a governing party. This is true. Being the party of limited government (well, rhetorically at least) puts you at a governing and political disadvantage. In todays world doing something is the only way to do something. But the GOP has been an effective opposition party. Boehner, even if his heroism happens to be mostly inadvertent, doesnt get enough credit for having stopped scores of progressive ideas, and often in the face of tremendous pressure. Obama, once on track to implement more wide-ranging reforms than any president since FDR, now nips at the margins through Executive Orders, court challenges and regulation by fiat. Its hardly ideal. But if you believe thats a positive development, thank the House.
#3 Oct 1, 2013
#4 Oct 1, 2013
If Its Not a Shutdown, Stop Calling It One
Filed under: General Patterico @ 5:34 pm
As of right now, I refuse to call it a shutdown.
The government is not shutting own. Not even remotely.
As I noted this morning, after the supposed government shutdown, the mail will get delivered. Social Security and Medicare will continue. Soldiers will defend our country. The USDA will inspect meat. Air traffic controllers will keep our skies safe.
On what planet is that a shutdown?
Propose your own language in the comments. Until I hear something better, I am calling it a government slowdown with a link to this post.
“animis opibusque parati”
Since: Oct 12
#6 Oct 1, 2013
B-b-b-b-u-t...it's the end of the world.
900,000 necessary government workers have been furloughed.
What? No one noticed?
#7 Oct 1, 2013
I had a feeling this was going to happen.
I could be wrong, but I seem to remember that the shut down in 1996 seemed to affect more things that people touch and feel. This might be going down the same road as the sequester.
I personally would love for the shutdown to succeed if for no other reason than to prove the RINOs wrong about standing your ground.
Standing your ground about fringe issues is a loser. Standing your ground about an issue where the public is squarely on your side should be a no brainer. In the long run it is going to be a winner.
Just look at Wisconsin. The lefties gave it everything they had, to the point of civil insurrection. And they lost. And Walker still has the majority on his side.
You don't prevail unless you fight.
Add your comments below
|Drumpf is Presidential?||53 min||Zeeba||20|
|Safety is priority during Red, White & Boom||1 hr||They cannot kill ...||5|
|Where will you go if Topix goes 404?||1 hr||Posting as myself||25|
|I <3 The BBC||1 hr||Zeeba comes out||4|
|Columbus veteran, ousted for sexual orientation...||1 hr||Zeeba comes out||27|
|City of Columbus issues nitrate warning for tap...||1 hr||Zeeba thinks deeply||5|
|Chipotle adding chorizo at Columbus restaurants...||3 hr||404 not found||10|
|Hillary's speech - thread is missing||9 hr||Seriouslady||160|
Find what you want!
Search Columbus Forum Now
Copyright © 2016 Topix LLC