Bill would bar illegal immigrant stud...

Bill would bar illegal immigrant students

There are 12 comments on the WDUN-AM Gainesville story from Feb 16, 2011, titled Bill would bar illegal immigrant students. In it, WDUN-AM Gainesville reports that:

A legislative committee in Georgia voted Tuesday to approve a bill that would bar illegal immigrants from attending its state colleges or universities.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at WDUN-AM Gainesville.

true

United States

#1 Feb 18, 2011
THANK THE LORD, better yet arrest and deport the parasites
YeS

Seattle, WA

#2 Feb 19, 2011
YeS
this is fair for a 'change'

Since: Jan 11

Milton, MA

#3 Feb 19, 2011
"When you academically disenfranchise a segment of the population, who wins? Nobody does"

Wrong! We all win. State colleges and universities are taxpayer subsidized so even if illegals in Georgia are not eligible for the in state tuition rate, they are still receiving an indirect taxpayer benefit.

It is against the law for any employer to hire an illegal immigrant (regardless of their level of education) so there is no return on investment for taxpayers if illegals are permitted to attend state colleges and universities.
guesswho

Seattle, WA

#4 Feb 19, 2011
hmmm well if you ask californians about their financing illegals for free(or maybe they're trying to bring slavery back) most think they really did something-the bad thing is most are fleeing their state to infest their "progressive "fear infested police state" to whomever will sympathize with them,took em about a year to trash oregon,as usual everyone else will pick up after them and pay their bills for them while their unbelievable sense of entitlement and denial keeps them from being aware of what they have done!
guesswho

Seattle, WA

#5 Feb 19, 2011
surreal stupidity on californians part -as if their state wasent bad enough, they finance that drug cartel corrupted american welfare state complete with rapes,murders,suicides,cripple d economy(since the only ones prospering from all the millions of american money we have been sending them has been the cartels and corruption! and they pay them to have babies!,not to mention the only ones in america with free health care! can vote and get liberties and freedoms for free because of their "race" which is all they have to offer beside cheaper labor,tacos and heroin,kidnapping and slavery rings-WTF?
guesswho

Seattle, WA

#6 Feb 19, 2011
YE S-yeah washington is the last free state left on the west coast and its going down fast,thanks to all the liberal,compassionate devils advocate -you will suffer the same demise that made california SO AWESOME! THAT JUST LIKE MEXICO THEY MADE THEIR STATE SO GREAT THEY COULDN'T STAND TO LIVE IN IT! SO NOW YOU HAVE THE CALIFORNIA PLAGUE BRINGING THEIR FEAR INFESTED TYRANNICAL POLICE STATE COMPLETE WITH GANGS,CRIMES,CRIPPLING REAL ESTATE PRICES AND PLENTY OF TRASH FOR EVERYONE SO ENJOY PICKING UP AFTER THEM,PAYING THEIR BILLS FOR THEM AND CATERING TO THEIR ORDERS! I HAD A GOOD 20 YEARS HERE IT WAS NICE WHILE IT LASTED
teddyroosevelt

Corinth, MS

#7 Feb 20, 2011
They should be barred from ALL of our schools...their parents certainly don't pay their fair share for their K-12 educations, and the onus is getting more than the taxpayers can afford.

Since: Jan 11

Milton, MA

#8 Feb 20, 2011
teddyroosevelt wrote:
They should be barred from ALL of our schools...their parents certainly don't pay their fair share for their K-12 educations, and the onus is getting more than the taxpayers can afford.
I agree. Plyer vs. Doe needs to be overturned. Oklahoma has legislation in the works that will allow them to track the number of illegals who are enrolling. They can potentially use that information to challenge the Supreme Court Ruling on the grounds that educating illegals does indeed pose an excessive financial burden on the state.

Back in 1982, the SCOTUS argued that providing their K-12 education was not an excessive burden but with the explosion in illegal immigration over the past 30 years, I doubt anyone could reasonably argue that funding their education does not place a strain on taxpayers.
Down and Out

New York, NY

#9 Feb 20, 2011
Deece - See where you are going with this and under some semblence of normal terms that is reasonable and logical.

Consider this before stepping out to far (being Devil's advocate here). The feds appear to have a built in 'Out" here, since it is "Hands off" counting illegals (can't ask their immigration status!) there will never ever be an accurate accounting for their numbers in this nation. Without that number, even approximate, a case to be made for overturning Plyer vs Doe would have little chance of success. Understand me, I would applaud a decision to overturn this nightmare we live with, what little we have to work with as far as accurate information on the TRUE number of illegal aliens in this nation is extremely difficult to assertain due to the policy of molly coddle to the illegal aliens by all levels of government.
Your thoughts?

Since: Jan 11

Milton, MA

#10 Feb 20, 2011
Down and Out wrote:
Deece - See where you are going with this and under some semblence of normal terms that is reasonable and logical.
Consider this before stepping out to far (being Devil's advocate here). The feds appear to have a built in 'Out" here, since it is "Hands off" counting illegals (can't ask their immigration status!) there will never ever be an accurate accounting for their numbers in this nation. Without that number, even approximate, a case to be made for overturning Plyer vs Doe would have little chance of success. Understand me, I would applaud a decision to overturn this nightmare we live with, what little we have to work with as far as accurate information on the TRUE number of illegal aliens in this nation is extremely difficult to assertain due to the policy of molly coddle to the illegal aliens by all levels of government.
Your thoughts?
It will be interesting to watch. If the bill passes, it will no doubt be subject to a law suit by the ACLU. If it is upheld, Oklahoma will be the first state to inquire about the legal status of students enrolling in their public schools.

I would love to see some hard numbers to quantify the costs associated with educating illegal immigrant students (including ESL classes and the breakfast lunch programs).
mole

Vancouver, WA

#11 Feb 20, 2011
guesswho wrote:
YE S-yeah washington is the last free state left on the west coast and its going down fast,thanks to all the liberal,compassionate devils advocate -you will suffer the same demise that made california SO AWESOME! THAT JUST LIKE MEXICO THEY MADE THEIR STATE SO GREAT THEY COULDN'T STAND TO LIVE IN IT! SO NOW YOU HAVE THE CALIFORNIA PLAGUE BRINGING THEIR FEAR INFESTED TYRANNICAL POLICE STATE COMPLETE WITH GANGS,CRIMES,CRIPPLING REAL ESTATE PRICES AND PLENTY OF TRASH FOR EVERYONE SO ENJOY PICKING UP AFTER THEM,PAYING THEIR BILLS FOR THEM AND CATERING TO THEIR ORDERS! I HAD A GOOD 20 YEARS HERE IT WAS NICE WHILE IT LASTED
Your an idiot.. Senator Pork Salad patty murry used illegals to get reelected, King county has codified the county as a santuary county and the roaches have increased 35% in the last three years here.http://seattletimes.nwsou rce.com/html/localnews/2014102 546_illegalimmigrants02m.html? prmid=obinsite
Down and Out

New York, NY

#12 Feb 21, 2011
Deece - I'm in your corner for sure!! This knot needs to be untied for the sake of the taxpayers and the nation.
The illegal aliens continue to hide behind the thin veil of support and protection generously provided by the government at all levels. Frankly that veil needs to be pulled open or ripped and shreaded - either method would expose the illegals and government to the collusion that is currently rampant in this mess. Hopefully one of the states can find a way to navigate through the numerous roadblocks here and kick the snot out of this treasonous activity.
Indeed, the truth would be a good shot of clean fresh air!!

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

University of Georgia Kennewsaw State Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Cheerleaders to kneel in stadium tunnel during ... Oct 18 25or6to4 1
News The Un-Pretty History Of Georgia's Iconic Peach Jul '17 KIR SUCKA 8
News Mexican woman's deportation protection temporar... Jun '17 HOLLA ISABELLA 4
News Illegal Alien Who Works As Paralegal For 'Kuck ... May '17 spytheweb 3
News KSU graduate awarded Ph.D. in field of genetics (Aug '16) Aug '16 Stephany McDowell 1
News Zombie 101: KSU instructor appears in - The Wal... (Oct '15) Oct '15 Go Blue Forever 1
News Kennesaw mayor addresses growth, SunTrust Park,... (Feb '15) May '15 toots810 3
More from around the web