Calcium, Vitamin D Won't Prevent Brea...

Calcium, Vitamin D Won't Prevent Breast Cancer

There are 2 comments on the HealthDay story from Nov 11, 2008, titled Calcium, Vitamin D Won't Prevent Breast Cancer. In it, HealthDay reports that:

Although calcium and vitamin D may keep your bones strong, these vital nutrients don't appear to help postmenopausal women lower their risk of breast cancer.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at HealthDay.

Gail Perry

Pinellas Park, FL

#1 Nov 11, 2008
While calcium and Vitamin D may not prevent breast cancer, it is possible that these supplements will help prevent its spread to the bones, because those met cells are opportunistic and likely to go where the bones are weaker.

So ladies, remember that one study does not provide all the answers. Sometimes researchers, excited by their findings, lose sight of that. Each piece of research has to be fitted into the bigger picture.

The fact is that having strong bones is a really, really good idea whether you've had breast cancer or not. I believe all women should have their Vitamin D levels checked as some people absorb it much better than others. I'm one of those who has to take a WHOLE lot more than was in that study (it has to be prescribed) to get benefit from it. 400 units a day? I might as well not be taking it.

So don't hang everything on this one study. They are just starting to look at these factors. And while the article was right that double-blind studies are often considered the "gold standard," there's an important place for studies that are just the opposite -- epidemiological studies.

They all have their place, and each piece of research is just one small piece in a very large puzzle. Don't make decisions based on one piece of research any more than you would assume you can see the whole picture from one piece of a thousand-piece jigsaw puzzle.
Bill Lauer

Charlottesville, VA

#2 Sep 8, 2011
Check the dose of vitamin D. The study as presented seems inconsistent with other evidence. Learn more here:

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Baylor College of Medicine Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Immigrant children in Texas detention center gi... Jul 5 Donny Brook 1
News Jen Arnold, of TLC's 'Little Couple,' discusses... (Dec '13) Dec '13 Sharon Cooper 1
News There's no evidence to support parental fears a... (Nov '13) Nov '13 MORE VACCINE VICTIMS 27
News Autism: Grant Aims to Accelerate Development of... (Oct '13) Oct '13 Vaccine injury 1
News Debunking parents' stubborn fear of vaccines (Sep '13) Sep '13 friend 9
News China reports more bird flu cases (Apr '13) Apr '13 2faces 1
News Birth control pill for men being tested in mice (Feb '13) Feb '13 hypedude 1
More from around the web