Battle over books breaks out in Westhampton Beach

Nov 23, 2007 Read more: Newsday 63
A tiny Westhampton Beach bookstore has become the frontline in a battle over the written word. Read more
First Prev
of 4
Next Last
BookWorm

Ridge, NY

#65 Jun 18, 2008
First let me say that If I use improper grammer it's not because I'm an "idiot", it's because I'm tired of this nonsense. I'm an english professor. If I'm calculating correctly the students who would be reading these books are 15/16 and above. I would like it if all of you parents out there would walk into the Westhampton Beach High School and find one 15 year old who didn't know about sex. I'm not saying that it is right for them to be reading about it. That's just point one.

Point 2 - This list is not a "required reading list" as most of the "antibooks" columnists on this blog are referring it to as. In fact it is a "self-select" list. This involves the parent to confer with thier child- the student, and pick out a book to read. If the parent was really that interested in what their child was reading they could read it first or at least skim it. Then THEY could censor it for THEIR child.

It is ridiculous for anyone to think that they can have control over how every parent parents their child. Frankly its none of your business. While you want to shelter your child and keep them from reading things they probably already know about others might want them to read it and be warned. They, of course, will call each other bad parents.

POINT 3- I read this book with the "gang rape" and the situation is not how anyone has been describing it. It's almost as if the town is playing telephone and this story got twisted into a completely different one.

Truthfully the section is small, maybe one or two pages. The girl is DREAMING about DEMONS raping her. Obviosuly, unless you are the family from Stephen King's Carrie, you KNOW that this is a fairytale, and that fairytales don't come true.

The reasons for being schooled has been lost, and I think it would be beneficial for everyone to stop arguing, look at the facts (NOT what YOU think is "right"), sit down, relax, take a breath. Deal with this like civilized human beings. The real reason for being educated is not to be filled with useless knowledge like how to form and solve a quadratic equation or,(okay, I'll say it) lines from Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet. It's to be inspired to do something. It's not the place for a teacher to perform, it's to make their students perform. If we regressed a little bit, past the regents and SATs, we'd find that again.

"Education should not be the filling of a bucket, but the lighting of a fire."

-Yeats
BookWorm

Ridge, NY

#66 Jun 18, 2008
Unfortunately, in time, people did not back down on either sides, and both sides suffered, They may not both know it yet, but they have. Obviously the side that was for keeping the books on the list lost the battle. But although they lost, both sides suffered defeat, and the other side will know it soon enough. Now that you've let them censor this, watch them do it again. And again and again and again. Until they hit a nerve for you and you'll hop the fence pretty quick to fight for the other side. Perhaps if you took my advice and stepped back to look at the facts you'd have realized.
Jordon

Parsippany, NJ

#67 Nov 20, 2009
Skool Dayz wrote:
<quoted text>
'Westhapton' Beach? Where is that-anywhere near Westhampton Beach? You're a Freshman like I'm Hillary Clinton-Hey wait, I AM Hillary Clinton!
Stop posting as a child-a child that can't spell !
oh gosh. its been a while since I've been on here. but i was in fact a freshman when i wrote that, I'm now a junior. just thought I'd clear things up a bit. Also. I probably didn't press down hard enough on the m key in Westhampton. Man, some people.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 4
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Westhampton Beach Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Principal Helen Anne Livingston of St. Isisdore... Apr 10 Dan 1
Debate: Occupy Wall St - Center Moriches, NY (Mar '12) Mar 25 red devil 82 9
Center Moriches Super not so..........after all (Oct '13) Mar 25 red devil 82 7
Review: Bitter Breeze HVAC and REFRIGERATION Mar 24 John212 1
cm middle school principal (Oct '13) Mar '15 Truth-seeker 6
Son Beaten by Riverhead Jail Sargent (Jan '09) Mar '15 yruohk 166
Wanted & Hiding in E Moriches (Apr '10) Feb '15 Aym3n 18
More from around the web

Westhampton Beach People Search

Addresses and phone numbers for FREE

Personal Finance

Mortgages [ See current mortgage rates ]