Math dyslexia imperils Orange County art teacher's job -- Eleme...

Full story: Orlando Sentinel

Tom Machacyk is no math genius. He's an artist who teaches at Waterford Elementary School and, he says, he's pretty good at it.

Comments (Page 13)

Showing posts 241 - 249 of249
|
next page >
Go to last page| Jump to page:
Mel

Los Angeles, CA

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#244
Apr 6, 2008
 
Informed wrote:
To Spencer, I am wondering when you got a degree in the subject area of Machacyk's life! Sounds like you are an expert on it to make such character statements about the man. I also believe you need to get a hobby and stop living your life on this discussion board. And lastly, Spencer, I would love to see you try teaching 22 5 and 6 year old students for 40 minutes!
You completely miss the point. You don't need math to do or teach art. It is not analogous to allowing a doctor to skip a biochemistry exam he found too hard, because a doctor NEEDS to know biochemistry to be a good doctor. You are setting up a straw man and burning it. An art teacher DOESN'T need math to be a good art teacher. As the article mentioned, it's not like he's a bus driver who is failing a bus driving exam, because math isn't related to teaching art.

It's not just a matter of going back to school and re-learning stuff, anyway. Dyscalculia is a LEARNING DISABILITY. That's why all the studying he's done hasn't improved his scores on the exam. The ADA states that any person qualified to do their job should not be prevented on the basis of disability. What is his job? Teach art. What is his disability? Dyscalculia. The dyscalculia does NOT make him an inept art teacher. That's like saying that an author wouldn't be qualified to teach creative writing if they weren't good at math.
Informed

Orlando, FL

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#245
Apr 7, 2008
 
Mel wrote:
<quoted text>
You completely miss the point. You don't need math to do or teach art. It is not analogous to allowing a doctor to skip a biochemistry exam he found too hard, because a doctor NEEDS to know biochemistry to be a good doctor. You are setting up a straw man and burning it. An art teacher DOESN'T need math to be a good art teacher. As the article mentioned, it's not like he's a bus driver who is failing a bus driving exam, because math isn't related to teaching art.
It's not just a matter of going back to school and re-learning stuff, anyway. Dyscalculia is a LEARNING DISABILITY. That's why all the studying he's done hasn't improved his scores on the exam. The ADA states that any person qualified to do their job should not be prevented on the basis of disability. What is his job? Teach art. What is his disability? Dyscalculia. The dyscalculia does NOT make him an inept art teacher. That's like saying that an author wouldn't be qualified to teach creative writing if they weren't good at math.
If you read all my posts you would have seen that I have said almost everything you followed up with! So, you missed the point.
Peter

Farmington, MN

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#246
Apr 15, 2008
 
Here is the problem:

An elementary teaching license allows you to teach ALL elementary subjects. Even a secondary art teaching license allows you to substitute teach in all subjects. If you can't do the math, you are UNABLE to teach it to students.

In the same way that we do not allow people who cannot pass a vision test to have a driver's license we should not allow someone who cannot pass a math test to become an elementary teacher.

Remember that if given the license he would have a license that allows him to apply for a regular elementary classroom position at a 6th grade level, and he can't do math at a 5th grade level.

We can accommodate for disabilities within reason. If the teaching license ONLY allowed for teaching art, he would have a very strong case for being able to earn it with dyscalculia. Unfortunately, he earn a license that allows him to teach anything.

Unless they create a completely alternate form of license that states specifically that he cannot substitute for, or even cover for a teacher who is late in any class other than elementary art he should not have a license.
Ricky

United States

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#247
Apr 15, 2008
 
The license does NOT allow him to teach anything. In order to teach math or English or any other subject exclusively, he would have to take and pass that subject area exam. The professional exam and art subject area exams do not allow all of these things you imply they do.
And he was already a substitute teacher- one does not usually go back to doing so until after retirement. Not to mention, all you need to be a substitute teacher in the state of Florida is a high school diploma. No previous experience, no exams, just a background check...so substitute teaching can't be lumped in with this argument at all.
Judy

UK

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#248
Apr 17, 2008
 
From the perspective of parent of a former Waterford Elementary student, it is the students who will lose if Mr. M. is unable to continue teaching. My daughter so looked forward to the days when she had Art with Mr. M. He was inspirational, involved and enthusiastic.

Thanks Mr. M.

Since: Apr 08

Lake Mary, FL

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#249
Apr 18, 2008
 
Judy wrote:
From the perspective of parent of a former Waterford Elementary student, it is the students who will lose if Mr. M. is unable to continue teaching. My daughter so looked forward to the days when she had Art with Mr. M. He was inspirational, involved and enthusiastic.
Thanks Mr. M.
That vote of confidence should be all that is required to end this debate. Can the man teach art? It sure sounds like it, so LET HIM TEACH!
Ghotit

Kefr Saba, Israel

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#250
Apr 18, 2008
 
www.Ghotit.com offers unique writing and reading online services for people who suffer from dyslexia, dysgraphia or people who are not native-English speakers. Ghotit’s first service is an online context sensitive spell checker.

Ghotit received great bloggers users report:

Bloggers:

http://blog.buzvia.com/site-review-ghotit-co-...
http://speedchange.blogspot.com/2008/02/ghoti...

Users comments:
• My god I have been look for this for all-my life, help that understands me. I write with a dictionary and thesaurus and some times cant even find the word looking for. I could not hold back the tears from the emotion then when I worked out how helpful this spellchecker will be for me.
• i really like it and i'm so glad i found it!! it will really help with my homework etc and my teachers wont get angry at me annymore!!
• Thank you for contacting us with your product. I tinkered with the spell checker for sometime this morning, entering common mistakes that our dyslexic students (and ADD) students make in spelling. I must say that I am extremely impressed with your product and would certainly like to further evaluate it with our students over the next several weeks.
• that spell checker is SO good, its actually waaay better than microsoft because it tells you the reasen why you are usuing the correct word. i really like it, its really good!!
Kyla

Pittsburgh, PA

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#251
May 8, 2008
 
bet wrote:
Machacyk has a very valid point - as teachers, we do everything we can to help students overcome their learning disability. This gentleman is an example to those students that there is hope for them. We place so much value on numbers, when we should be placing value on the individual and his/her accomplishments. This gentleman is teaching Art, not math or science - let him teach!!
I am in the same situation, I passed all of the tests needed for teaching and cannot pass the math portion of the test. I have a learning disablility in mathematics and noone is willing to adapt, the test is not only timed you are not allowed to use calculators! I am going to be an Enlgish teacher as well it is rediculous. I can't get my certification without it no matter what I even wrote a letter to Harrisburg and they did not offer me any assistance!

Since: Apr 08

Lake Mary, FL

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#252
May 9, 2008
 
Kyla wrote:
<quoted text>
I am in the same situation, I passed all of the tests needed for teaching and cannot pass the math portion of the test. I have a learning disablility in mathematics and noone is willing to adapt, the test is not only timed you are not allowed to use calculators! I am going to be an Enlgish teacher as well it is rediculous. I can't get my certification without it no matter what I even wrote a letter to Harrisburg and they did not offer me any assistance!
I am in the same situation. I passed all of the tests needed for teaching and cannot pass the math portion of the test. I have a learning disablility in mathematics and no one is willing to adapt. The test is not only timed, but you are not allowed to use calculators! I am going to be an Enlgish teacher, as well. It is rediculous. I can't get my certification without it no matter what. I even wrote a letter to Harrisburg and they did not offer me any assistance!
Above you will find the corrected version of your post. I am worried if you are truly going to be an English teacher.

Tell me when this thread is updated: (Registration is not required)

Add to my Tracker Send me an email

Showing posts 241 - 249 of249
|
next page >
Go to last page| Jump to page:
Type in your comments below
Name
(appears on your post)
Comments
Characters left: 4000
Type the numbers you see in the image on the right:

Please note by clicking on "Post Comment" you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Other Recent Waterford Discussions

Search the Waterford Forum:
Topic Updated Last By Comments
The 25 Most Dangerous Cities in the U.S. Are Mo... (Nov '10) 9 min toomanymistakes 18,494
NY Who do you support for U.S. Senate in New York ... (Oct '10) 28 min positronium 6,321
Dominica "Dolly" Deppas (Apr '11) 11 hr Life Coach 6
NY Who do you support for Governor in New York in ... (Oct '10) 13 hr positronium 6,317
NY New York Primary Election Sept 14: Will you vote? (Sep '10) Wed Habanero Harv 16,760
hotdogs Wed drunk 5
...FARMER...is...GOD,..not.... (Jul '13) Jul 3 PAUL SHYKORA artsdiscuss 5
•••
•••
•••
Waterford Dating

more search filters

less search filters

•••

Waterford Jobs

•••
Enter and win $5000
•••
•••

Waterford People Search

Addresses and phone numbers for FREE

•••

Waterford News, Events & Info

Click for news, events and info in Waterford
•••

Personal Finance

Mortgages [ See current mortgage rates ]
•••