Tomato Pie!!!
First Prev
of 2
Next Last
Yum

United States

#1 Aug 2, 2008
Wheres that from, it looks great?
I'd add a little more cheese though,but looks tasty.
Goober

Fayetteville, NY

#2 Aug 3, 2008
nice does need some more cheese though

Since: Jul 08

New York, NY

#3 Aug 4, 2008
Yum wrote:
Wheres that from, it looks great?
I'd add a little more cheese though,but looks tasty.
Roma's over on Bleeker Street towards Frankfurt. Them and Napolie's got the best pie
Mootzadell

United States

#4 Aug 4, 2008
Rintrona's makes a good one...check out the meatballs Sunday only.
Disgusted

Syracuse, NY

#5 Aug 4, 2008
Yum!!!I could go for some with some red hot crushed pepper!

Since: Jul 08

New York, NY

#6 Aug 5, 2008
Mootzadell wrote:
Rintrona's makes a good one...check out the meatballs Sunday only.
Over on Mohawk Street?

Level 1

Since: Sep 08

Location hidden

#8 Sep 3, 2008
O'scugnizzo's used to be the best.
Are they still in Utica ?
bruno old forge ny

Rome, NY

#9 Sep 3, 2008
no on bleeker
donkey

Fayetteville, NY

#10 Sep 3, 2008
try danielle's on mohawk- and the meatballs are great
Wop Slop

Utica, NY

#11 Sep 3, 2008
Tomato Pie is very typical of most of Utica's "claims" to fame.

Make a half pizza without cheese and call it "THE BEST!" LOL! When family comes and we give them "tomato bread" they always laugh and ask "where's the cheese"? LOL!

Uticans ALWAYS settle for less while calling it MORE! It's how it looks around Utica not how it IS!

Get som cheese! Utica has enough cheesy wops can't we get some cheese?
donkey

Fayetteville, NY

#13 Sep 3, 2008
you ass tomatoe pie is not the typical pizza only cheeze on it should be a grated hard cheese- pecorino romano- not mozz.- not alot of sauce either.
bruno old forge ny

Rome, NY

#14 Sep 4, 2008
has anyone tried Rintrona's pusties or provolone bread? they have the BEST in town
xxx

Manlius, NY

#15 Sep 8, 2008
dumb a*s in new hartford pays high taxes and reaches out his window to get milk from neighbor
Wuzer

New York, NY

#17 Dec 9, 2008
FORMULA 50 wrote:
<quoted text>
Roma's over on Bleeker Street towards Frankfurt. Them and Napolie's got the best pie
Roma is always stale and flavorless. That big goon at the counter acts like he's doing you a favor.
Tom T

New York, NY

#18 Dec 9, 2008
I hate ignorance wrote:
O'scugnizzo's used to be the best.
Are they still in Utica ?
I asked those guys once to put topping on a 1/4 rather than 1/2 a pizza. They looked at me like I was giving them a math quiz.
Lioness23

New York, NY

#20 May 12, 2010
I never heard of these until i came to Utica. We never had them in Brooklyn! They are good if you get it from a good place!

Utica Lies and Riggies

Since: May 14

Clifton Park, NY

#21 May 26, 2014
Yum wrote:
Wheres that from, it looks great?
I'd add a little more cheese though,but looks tasty.
It was invented in Trenton New Jersey.
welfare kids

Chicago, IL

#22 May 26, 2014
Trenton tomato pie has mozzarella on it. People around Utica that say tomato pie are talking about a version without mozz that was sold in Utica since 1914.

I would love to know who sold the first one but I can't find any evidence prior to 1914.

Utica Lies and Riggies

Since: May 14

Clifton Park, NY

#23 May 26, 2014
welfare kids wrote:
Trenton tomato pie has mozzarella on it. People around Utica that say tomato pie are talking about a version without mozz that was sold in Utica since 1914.
I would love to know who sold the first one but I can't find any evidence prior to 1914.
It's right here. 1910 in Trenton.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tomato_pie
welfare kids

Chicago, IL

#24 May 26, 2014
http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:TomatoPie...

The photo is from Utica. Do you really need me to explain?

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 2
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Utica Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Hey MADE in Utica group 4 min Ribbbzzz 5
Hillary seizures 16 min Empty Pantsuit 15
Rachel WKTV 17 min Wills 2
Wibx Keeler, the dead beat 21 min Loan officer 9
Marlena Tran 23 min Carlyn 5
Mayors $20,000 raise 24 min Anonymous 5
House of Good Shepherd 1 hr imp 2
Affair outside bennu in whitesboro 1 hr Gram 17
Biggest RAT in ufd 2 hr Always got your 6 33
Sam wessing 3 hr Dee D DEE de DEE 29
Ranking Utica Prostitutes 3 hr Granny 237
kristen drama queen copeland (Sep '14) 8 hr trask5139 26

Utica Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Utica Mortgages