Who has the worst tomato pie in Utica?

Who has the worst tomato pie in Utica?

Posted in the Utica Forum

The First from lainey

United States

#1 Feb 23, 2014
Roma's has the worst tomato pie in Utica.

Level 4

Since: Jul 13

New Hartford, NY

#2 Feb 26, 2014
I don't agree, I think it has the best!
Old Memory

Utica, NY

#5 Feb 26, 2014
comets uc wrote:
Kinda hard to screw up tomatoe sauce and Romano cheese on a pizza dough crust....
Believe it or not, they do. Mainly the sauce. Too much sugar. too runny making dough soggy, sour, etc. I compare today's to the original from back in the 50's, that was in the individual wax paper bags for 10 cents. It was great. Haven't had any yet that compares to that. I believe that was from Diorio's Bakery but not sure.
You Are Right

Utica, NY

#7 Feb 27, 2014
Wboro Trashes Kid wrote:
Did you know tomato pie wasn't actually invented in Utica? Check out the Wikipedia page.
Interesting. Never thought to search it, just thought it was a local tradition. I thank you for your post! At least Utica is mentioned along with greens and riggies. Also surprisingly, O'scugnizzos is mentioned.
johnny

Ithaca, NY

#8 Feb 27, 2014
Old Memory wrote:
<quoted text>
Believe it or not, they do. Mainly the sauce. Too much sugar. too runny making dough soggy, sour, etc. I compare today's to the original from back in the 50's, that was in the individual wax paper bags for 10 cents. It was great. Haven't had any yet that compares to that. I believe that was from Diorio's Bakery but not sure.
Yes, exactly correct, it was awesome.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Utica Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Katrina Smith is pregnant AGAIN 18 min Dale 16
New hartford is the new east utica 3 hr Stugots 128
attn 75 PERCENT OF THE WORLDS POOREST COUNTRIES... (Jul '16) 5 hr sad but true 190
apes BRUTALLY THRASHED ON URBAN DICTIONARY 5 hr sad but true 7
Gary Kingsley - Crackhead trouble at NANAs hou... (Nov '11) 5 hr Karma 27
WHY Utica is a rustbelt poverty hole of FAIL. 5 hr sad but true 47
Claudia to senior citizens: Thanks for the vote... 5 hr Gorsuch 16
Two Utica cops beat up 15 year kid on Albany st... 6 hr Utica dd 24
How Much Does H & R Block charge To Do Your Taxes (Jan '09) 7 hr Low Income Area 928
c h e a t 18 hr Yummy 21

Utica Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Utica Mortgages