BEst Tomato Pie In Utica
First Prev
of 3
Next Last

Utica, NY

#45 Aug 6, 2013
Mayor Of Utica wrote:
Star Bakery in East Utica on Catheran St. The Best.
On what street?

New Hartford, NY

#47 Aug 6, 2013
Fat Tony

New York, NY

#48 Aug 6, 2013
Without a doubt....Big O on Bleecker St

United States

#49 Aug 6, 2013
I prefer your moms pie
Utica34 wrote:
I prefer Tonys on Culver Ave.

Herkimer, NY

#50 Aug 6, 2013
Spit soaked nonpizza

United States

#51 Aug 6, 2013
Heather knows wrote:
Another Utica phony dish. Cold soggy pizza without cheese. Why do Uticans always try to make garbage sound appealing and "famous"?
Another example of Utica people making claims of "awesome" food. Cold wet like spit soaked wanabe bread with tomato paste on it the flies it collects sitting around on counters all day must be the secret ingredient.
Uticans would sell bald tires as "Racing Slicks" if the law would let them claim it was their big contribution to humanity.

United States

#52 Aug 6, 2013
teo wrote:
Hey Sticks,
As I said "of dubious provenance" not to mention that there is so little of it that it adds nothing to the crap that is "tomato pie".
Awful, awful stuff. Not fit for human consumption. Its Utica's version of Haggis, lutefisk or any of the other repellent foods that people around the world think is great.
If you want to make it even worse you might want to wash it down with some of that "Adirondack" "vodka" that they make over on the west side. That stuff is terrible as well.
well on napolis pie they use real romano cheese that you can actually taste. Thats why theirs is the best. I do agree that everyone elses cheese is just for looks.
Icky half pizza

Cheyenne, WY

#53 Aug 6, 2013
Nasty stuff. Get a grip Uticans!

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 3
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Utica Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Keeler caller Mario is Cretin 3 min KingAndrewCuomo 16
Idiot New Hartford Leaders 7 min Concerned 1
Wibx Keeler, the dead beat 11 min KingAndrewCuomo 41
Name A Hillary Clinton Accomplishment 17 min Accomplishments 66
Hat Etiquette No Longer Practiced By Males 24 min lol 5
Utica NY: Worst ecomomy in the US 24 min Own it Utica 2
HOw's the "Utica Nano Space Shuttle" doing? 25 min Dont cry 78
Frank Duross, all his teams, have failed. (Jun '13) 2 hr Ya mad bruh 38
Carbone Sold 3 hr Judu 18
House of Good Shepherd 5 hr Citizen 21
Ranking Utica Prostitutes 5 hr Mina 264

Utica Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Utica Mortgages