O'Scugnizzo's Pizzeria
bbb

Oneonta, NY

#22 Oct 6, 2011
I am 62 years old have been going to o's for many years I live out of the Utica area. when we felt like a pizza we would drive about 50 miles to get a pizza.they were excellent.Last yaar the pizza has been terrible. I would not walk to get a pizza for free now from o's. it to bad.
city

Rome, NY

#23 Oct 6, 2011
friend in from California last week no complaints
manbearpig

Utica, NY

#24 Oct 6, 2011
The one in utica suks, every fing order they fk up. The one in washington mills seems to be better. The place in whitesboro, Joes is good, but the people who work their have some serious mental problems. Upside down pizza is awesome.
Fat Tony Salerno

Rochester, NY

#25 Oct 6, 2011
smurfie wrote:
I moved here from the Rochester area and have had a very hard time finding really good pizza around here. I like most pizza but around here there is no pizza I love! Why can't utica make awesome pizza? Pontillo's Pizza RULES!!!
Pontillo's is very good in Rochester. In Utica, try a large #8 at O'Scugnizzo's. It's great.
Cornhill Escapee

Benson, NC

#26 Oct 7, 2011
Try some of O's chicken wings cooked in fish grease, NOT. They have lost a loyal customer.

Level 2

Since: Sep 11

Location hidden

#27 Oct 7, 2011
Fat Tony Salerno wrote:
<quoted text>
Pontillo's is very good in Rochester. In Utica, try a large #8 at O'Scugnizzo's. It's great.
Ever have a garbage plate at nick tahou's?
bernie

Utica, NY

#28 Oct 7, 2011
hmmm wrote:
<quoted text>
The one over by ACS makes their pizza's in a very sloppy way, and the sauce does not taste the same compared to the one in Washington Mills. Not only that, but whenever I have gotten a slice from the one by ACS, it looks and tastes 3 days old. I don't care if they have the same sauce, or shells, the people who run the one in Washington Mills are better at what they do. Simple as that.
go suk a tail pipe will you , its the same damb pizza both places are the same
jpj3

Utica, NY

#29 Oct 7, 2011
its all garbage wrote:
Dudes, if you are used to eating chitt, then all chitt will taste GOOD to you.
That's a metaphor for all things Utica, and for the Utica-Rome MSA.
Utica & Rome pizza really blows, but you won't know that it does until you try something better, SOMEWHERE ELSE.
ok einstein i see you have a syracuse ip ,how about people in syracuse dont even know what tomato pie is , r u kidding me , they said to me why would you by cold pizza lmao lol . yo no italian thet i know doesent know what tomato pie is .u go syracuse , next youll tell us you put mayonaise on ur pizza lol
OS SCO NEETS OHHHHHHH

Ithaca, NY

#30 Oct 7, 2011
hmmm wrote:
<quoted text>
The one over by ACS makes their pizza's in a very sloppy way, and the sauce does not taste the same compared to the one in Washington Mills. Not only that, but whenever I have gotten a slice from the one by ACS, it looks and tastes 3 days old. I don't care if they have the same sauce, or shells, the people who run the one in Washington Mills are better at what they do. Simple as that.
You lie because they don't make slices beyotch.
Fat Tony Salerno

Rochester, NY

#31 Oct 7, 2011
smurfie wrote:
<quoted text>Ever have a garbage plate at nick tahou's?
Hundreds. One of the better variations is the plate they sell at Frontier Field (home of the Red Wings). You can get it with chili. Very tasty.
Truth

Utica, NY

#32 Oct 7, 2011
OS SCO NEETS OHHHHHHH wrote:
<quoted text>You lie because they don't make slices beyotch.
Yes they do....often out of them though.
Mark

Syracuse, NY

#33 Oct 7, 2011
jpj3 wrote:
<quoted text>ok einstein i see you have a syracuse ip ,how about people in syracuse dont even know what tomato pie is , r u kidding me , they said to me why would you by cold pizza lmao lol . yo no italian thet i know doesent know what tomato pie is .u go syracuse , next youll tell us you put mayonaise on ur pizza lol
Amazing how many people don't realize that the ISP location is the location of the ISP's server, and not the location of the person posting on Topix. That said, tomatoe pie is a Utica thing. No one outside of Utica knows what it is. It does not exist anywhere else (except for a small town in Pennsylvania, although it is not the same as the Utica version). Tomatoe Pie is unique to Utica. Italian Americans outside of Utica do not know what it is. It is not an Italian thing, tomatoe pie as you know it is only found in Utica. Please keep in mind that the universe does not revolve around Utica.

Level 2

Since: Sep 11

Location hidden

#36 Oct 10, 2011
Fat Tony Salerno wrote:
<quoted text>
Hundreds. One of the better variations is the plate they sell at Frontier Field (home of the Red Wings). You can get it with chili. Very tasty.
I miss home. I haven't been to a red wings game in forever.:(
coast tocoast

AOL

#37 Oct 10, 2011
smurfie wrote:
I moved here from the Rochester area and have had a very hard time finding really good pizza around here. I like most pizza but around here there is no pizza I love! Why can't utica make awesome pizza? Pontillo's Pizza RULES!!!
No way ...Salvatores beats Ponjtillos anytime. Second in line Marks' aand Pudgies reminds me of pizza in Utica. Utica pizza is always better anyway.
tomato pie sucks

Rome, NY

#38 Oct 10, 2011
first of all its not an italian dish at all. its more what a mayonaise face would make. all it is is crushed tomatos seasoned poorly on a shell. anybody by the name of swartz can make it,but has the smarts not to. you definitly wont find that or any of your garbage you call pizza in any of the 5 boroughs,long island,or westchester. why do you t.hink we call you people cow pushers keep cracking open that shit for sauce you make,and wow that friggin pan pizza that we wouldnt give our dogs. but then again what do you expect from friggin farmer bastards. go play tip the cows and slam it to your sisters. YOUR PIZZA AND MAKE BELIVE ITALIAN FOOD SUCK.

Level 2

Since: Sep 11

Location hidden

#39 Oct 11, 2011
coast tocoast wrote:
<quoted text>
No way ...Salvatores beats Ponjtillos anytime. Second in line Marks' aand Pudgies reminds me of pizza in Utica. Utica pizza is always better anyway.
Salvatores has the best subs. Marks pizza is good. I always love pontillos in Canandaigua. Never really ate at pudgies. Nothing is better in utica. Chicken wings unless from the boro in deansboro are nasty around here. oily and soggy wings are not good.
Joe Cool

Lowville, NY

#41 Oct 11, 2011
Oscugnizzo's pizza is best when it's hot. Some people like to eat it cold the next morning. I'm not one of them. I like eating it at Bleecker Street when it comes right out of the oven..the best..they only sell slices at lunch time during the week so all the slices are fresh..so you can't get a 3 day old slice..
bubba

Syracuse, NY

#42 Oct 11, 2011
Mario's in Oriskany Falls. Best Pizza in CNY! Second best is NY Pizza in Waterville.
antonio

Utica, NY

#43 Oct 16, 2011
tomato pie sucks wrote:
first of all its not an italian dish at all. its more what a mayonaise face would make. all it is is crushed tomatos seasoned poorly on a shell. anybody by the name of swartz can make it,but has the smarts not to. you definitly wont find that or any of your garbage you call pizza in any of the 5 boroughs,long island,or westchester. why do you t.hink we call you people cow pushers keep cracking open that shit for sauce you make,and wow that friggin pan pizza that we wouldnt give our dogs. but then again what do you expect from friggin farmer bastards. go play tip the cows and slam it to your sisters. YOUR PIZZA AND MAKE BELIVE ITALIAN FOOD SUCK.
speaking of sisters how is yours . she was the bukaki queen back in the day she sure could swallow .oh you bring back the memories that mouth could suk golf balls through a garden hose .
The truth

Utica, NY

#46 Dec 12, 2013
The Os on bleecker street is were everything is made for ALL other oscugnizzos shells bread sausage sauce eveything i think people are just scared to come through east Utica to get the best so they go to their Rich section but settle for junk taste!! Stop being scared or stop eating pizza the one on bleecker street as been in business for 100 yrs so obviously they do somthing right!! Il always go to bleecker bc it's original an not fake!!

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Utica Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
New Hartford Police Chief Michael S. Inserra - ... 2 min Tick tick tick tick 54
Work On Aud Improvements 3 min Welfare wendy 398
Samantha Colostomy Testa - SNOOKIE, only fatter. 5 min Bigly Fugly 5
Trump Coluded 21 min Caddy 3
2 New Utica hotels EMPTY EVERY NIGHT! 22 min Indeed 73
Claudia Tenney- swamp rat 34 min LibHater 31
Jill Reale learned a new word. 37 min Pete 1
Kaitlyn Conley (Jun '16) 1 hr Scotts Smirk Slapped 711
Need a good Divorce Lawyer in New Hartford? 2 hr Thanks 97
New Hartford Schools investigated by State of NY 3 hr NO Batman Costume 73

Utica Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Utica Mortgages