What is Tomatoe Pie????

What is Tomatoe Pie????

Posted in the Utica Forum

First Prev
of 2
Next Last

Since: Jul 08

Manlius, NY

#2 Sep 26, 2008
um no here in utica a pizza pie is dough baked with sauce then cooled and served cold with a little parmesan cheese on it. this was originally created here in utica NY. i have heard of what your talking about but never seen or had it but i do know where you can find the recipe for it go to http://www.home-ec101.com/tomato-pie-smack-yo...
kitty

Staten Island, NY

#3 Sep 26, 2008
no, borat...it's pie stuffed with tomatoes

Since: Jul 08

Manlius, NY

#4 Sep 26, 2008
kitty wrote:
no, borat...it's pie stuffed with tomatoes
wow are you illiterate did you bother to read past the fist line if you had a brain you would probably be dangerous......
kitty

Staten Island, NY

#5 Sep 26, 2008
LOL...apparently i am...i MEANT to say tomatoes stuffed with pie...this person is not serious-they are constantly making fun of utica...that is why i was being sarcastic.

Since: Jul 08

Manlius, NY

#6 Sep 26, 2008
ok the recipe i posted is supposed to be one of the bast if you try it let me know
Joey

Utica, NY

#8 Sep 26, 2008
kitty wrote:
LOL...apparently i am...i MEANT to say tomatoes stuffed with pie...this person is not serious-they are constantly making fun of utica...that is why i was being sarcastic.
I thought it was because your an azzhole.
gino

Rome, NY

#10 Dec 16, 2008
i love tomato pie
Frank

New York, NY

#11 Dec 16, 2008
It's a half a cold pizza with no cheese. Another amazing half-idea from Uticans, we're sooooo proud.

Next "Utica Specialty"= Cake with no frosting, they'll call it "Super tasty puffy pie"!

Can you say HALFASS UTICANS??
Italian

Baldwinsville, NY

#12 Dec 16, 2008
Its garbage.
Anttheman

AOL

#13 Dec 16, 2008
goes great with black eye peas and fried chicken.

Utica Lies and Riggies

Since: May 14

Clifton Park, NY

#14 May 23, 2014
n utica wrote:
um no here in utica a pizza pie is dough baked with sauce then cooled and served cold with a little parmesan cheese on it. this was originally created here in utica NY. i have heard of what your talking about but never seen or had it but i do know where you can find the recipe for it go to http://www.home-ec101.com/tomato-pie-smack-yo...
Actually it wasn't created in utica. It was created in New Jersey.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tomato_pie

Since: May 14

Ilion

#15 May 23, 2014
Utica Lies and Riggies wrote:
<quoted text>Actually it wasn't created in utica. It was created in New Jersey.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tomato_pie
Hey, Rig check the spelling of the title of this post. It's Toma Toe pie. That's gotta be a Utica invention

Utica Lies and Riggies

Since: May 14

Clifton Park, NY

#16 May 23, 2014
Gaggy wrote:
<quoted text>
Hey, Rig check the spelling of the title of this post. It's Toma Toe pie. That's gotta be a Utica invention
Ahh good catch. Maybe they can say they created "tomatoe" pie on a technicality. Lol!
tomato pie rocks

Whitesboro, NY

#17 May 23, 2014
Utica Lies and Riggies wrote:
<quoted text>
Ahh good catch. Maybe they can say they created "tomatoe" pie on a technicality. Lol!
What's your favorite meal, shit on a shingle? Jerk off.

Utica Lies and Riggies

Since: May 14

Clifton Park, NY

#18 May 23, 2014
tomato pie rocks wrote:
<quoted text>What's your favorite meal, shit on a shingle? Jerk off.
My favorite meal is a steak from a charcoal grill, mashed potatoes, and corn on the cob. What does this have to do with the fact utica didn't create tomato pie though?
welfare kids

Evanston, IL

#19 May 23, 2014
Oh god here this idiot goes again pretending that wikipeida is the place to look for accurate information.

Utica Lies and Riggies

Since: May 14

Clifton Park, NY

#20 May 23, 2014
welfare kids wrote:
Oh god here this idiot goes again pretending that wikipeida is the place to look for accurate information.
Well ok. Here's another site.

http://whatscookingamerica.net/History/Pizza/...

Just face it. What utica prides itself on "inventing" didn't even actually invent it. It's the great "Tomato Lie"!!!

Since: May 14

Ilion

#21 May 23, 2014
Utica Lies and Riggies wrote:
<quoted text>My favorite meal is a steak from a charcoal grill, mashed potatoes, and corn on the cob. What does this have to do with the fact utica didn't create tomato pie though?
You b'tard, you made me want steak! I gotta fire up the grill now
welfare kids

Evanston, IL

#23 May 23, 2014
some people can be so stupid.

Look at the link for the restaurant that was supposedly sold tomato pie first. www papastomatopies com They use the word tomato pie to describe pizza NOT what people in Utica call tomato pie. Look at the images of what they call tomato pie.

or just ignore me and copy paste your usually false blurb about how Tomato pie was invented in NJ. Even the ridiculously inacurate wiki page you link to says "The Trenton tomato pie MAY even predate the Utica variety". God man take your head out of your butt.

Utica Lies and Riggies

Since: May 14

Clifton Park, NY

#24 May 23, 2014
Gaggy wrote:
<quoted text>
You b'tard, you made me want steak! I gotta fire up the grill now
Don't forget the taters and corn.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 2
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Utica Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
New Hartford Square Apartments 19 min Frank 1
Carbone 23 min ask him 25
Guess who didnt graduate from ND 43 min loser 78
Utica OD---NO coverage at Turning Stone 57 min Nobody cares 4
No1 Chinese Restaurant 1 hr Ooga Booga 5
department stores in utica (Nov '12) 2 hr gordon toffler 19
Tazz KAY HANNA- SLOBFAIL MVCC Dropout, LEZKING ... 2 hr Tazz 24 7 Hanna 1
rob esche getting divorced 3 hr Rob WOMAN YELLO E... 53
Tony's Washington Mills 15 hr Parkway 10
More from around the web

Personal Finance

Utica Mortgages