Who Makes The Best Tomato Pie In Utica

Level 6

Since: May 13

Location hidden

#36 Mar 4, 2014
My favorite was on James Street St. The name was Italian, they finally closed because the neighborhood got bad. Does anyone know if they opened another store in our area?
Yes

Utica, NY

#38 Mar 4, 2014
Utica Myth Explosion wrote:
Did you know that tomato pie was actually created in New Jersey not utica?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tomato_pie
STFU you're a freakin liar! It was invented in Rome, NY. They have an east Rome section they refer to as "Lil Jersey" due to the sunstantial number of Florentine immigrants who settled there by way of New Jersey. Stop makin shitz up dude!
rick

Herkimer, NY

#40 Mar 4, 2014
Larry Handiman Josheph wrote:
<quoted text>Utica RUNS on vapor, bullshit and hype. This wet halfbreed wannabe pizza is second only to the Annette Funicello lie Uticans claimed for decades until the internet came along.
In fact, the internet was the undoing of Uterus in so many ways. They can't hide their deeds, their failure and moral-poverty anymore. They used to just ask their media friends they bedded down with to keep things quiet but those days are over and now nobody needs either!
Annette Funicello is from utica I saw her on t.v and she herself said she was from utica you moron. Why would she lie
Someone who Knows

Springfield, NJ

#41 Mar 4, 2014
Not roma But Danielle's
why

Utica, NY

#42 Mar 4, 2014
Why so many haters?!? Who cares what you like or dislike? Why do you have to bash what others enjoy? Leave it alone. Tomato pie is good stuff. Especially after it's set for a day. Am I an a hole just because I think that? Do you even know me? Damn...why is everyone getting so upset over this? It's just tomato pie people!!! Relax.......
For The Record

Utica, NY

#43 Mar 4, 2014
Larry Handiman Josheph wrote:
<quoted text>Utica RUNS on vapor, bullshit and hype. This wet halfbreed wannabe pizza is second only to the Annette Funicello lie Uticans claimed for decades until the internet came along.
In fact, the internet was the undoing of Uterus in so many ways. They can't hide their deeds, their failure and moral-poverty anymore. They used to just ask their media friends they bedded down with to keep things quiet but those days are over and now nobody needs either!
This asshoe is still at it all over Topix, so another of HIS lies corrected. From IMDB.com :

Annette Funicello (1942–2013)
Actress | Soundtrack | Writer
Annette Joanne Funicello achieved teenage popularity starting in October, 1955 after she debuted as a Mouseketeer. Born on October 22, 1942 in Utica New York, the family had moved to California when she was still young. Walt Disney himself saw her performing the lead role in "Swan Lake" at her ballet school's year-end recital in Burbank and ... See full bio »
Born: Annette Joanne Funicello
October 22, 1942 in Utica, New York, USA
Died: April 8, 2013 (age 70) in Bakersfield, California, USA
Old Memory

Utica, NY

#44 Mar 4, 2014
I compare today's to the original from back in the 50's, 60's that was in the individual wax paper bags for 10 cents. It was great. Haven't had any yet that compares to that. I believe that was from Diorio's Bakery.
For The Record

Utica, NY

#45 Mar 4, 2014
Utica Myth Explosion wrote:
Did you know that tomato pie was actually created in New Jersey not utica?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tomato_pie
No where in that Wikipedia link does it say tomato pie was created in New Jersey.
Bonomozzeralla

United States

#46 Mar 4, 2014
For The Record wrote:
<quoted text>
This asshoe is still at it all over Topix, so another of HIS lies corrected. From IMDB.com :
Annette Funicello (1942–2013)
Actress | Soundtrack | Writer
Annette Joanne Funicello achieved teenage popularity starting in October, 1955 after she debuted as a Mouseketeer. Born on October 22, 1942 in Utica New York, the family had moved to California when she was still young. Walt Disney himself saw her performing the lead role in "Swan Lake" at her ballet school's year-end recital in Burbank and ... See full bio »
Born: Annette Joanne Funicello
October 22, 1942 in Utica, New York, USA
Died: April 8, 2013 (age 70) in Bakersfield, California, USA
This assho -db- nobody but you and a buncha retards CARE! At least this proves more people know who Annette Funicello, who moved away from Utica at 3 and never went back- is than Joe Crackhead Royal King Bonematzarella is! You people really are some kind of losers!

I'm certain the breaking Funicello news will help with the nano-job supercenter!
Trashys Explosion

Dublin, Ireland

#48 Mar 5, 2014
I am still on welfare an will be here all day showing the world by jealously of real men utica, Frank, Money, Olympics, clear skin.
Union Explosion

Dublin, Ireland

#50 Mar 5, 2014
I still never had a real job and I am a low tech failure stalking Franks DK praying I get Larry.
Michael

Ithaca, NY

#52 Mar 5, 2014
Reney wrote:
My favorite was on James Street St. The name was Italian, they finally closed because the neighborhood got bad. Does anyone know if they opened another store in our area?

Italian Saluamaria (prob spelled wrong). They had the best sandwiches and best tomato pie when I was growing up as a kid in that neighborhood.
For The Record

Utica, NY

#53 Mar 5, 2014
Trashys Explosion wrote:
<quoted text>
Well considering the first documented cases of tomato pie were in New Jersey four years before utica...that is in the article.
Before Utica doesn't say the original or first ever.. Golly, JFK was before Obuma but wasn't the first President!!!!
hey larry

Carthage, NY

#58 Mar 6, 2014
Larry Handiman Josheph wrote:
<quoted text>Utica RUNS on vapor, bullshit and hype. This wet halfbreed wannabe pizza is second only to the Annette Funicello lie Uticans claimed for decades until the internet came along.
In fact, the internet was the undoing of Uterus in so many ways. They can't hide their deeds, their failure and moral-poverty anymore. They used to just ask their media friends they bedded down with to keep things quiet but those days are over and now nobody needs either!
and all the crap you post here on topis IS pure vapor, hype and bulls**t. What you need to do is fullfill your self with a real life instead of all that hot air you are blown up with.
marge

Carthage, NY

#59 Mar 6, 2014
Reney wrote:
My favorite was on James Street St. The name was Italian, they finally closed because the neighborhood got bad. Does anyone know if they opened another store in our area?
was it the 'salumaria"
virginia

Carthage, NY

#60 Mar 6, 2014
Utica Myth Explosion wrote:
Did you know that tomato pie was actually created in New Jersey not utica?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tomato_pie
and did you know that you shouldn't believe everything that you read or hear??
For The Record

Utica, NY

#61 Mar 6, 2014
Oh the humanity wrote:
<quoted text> fort Schuyler beer with tomato pie Utica breakfast of champions Get it drink it and remember eat it Every day
Don't say beer, say "Fort Schuyler".
john

Herkimer, NY

#64 Mar 6, 2014
Utica Positivity Brigade wrote:
Larry's comment got removed for some reason, but I agree with what's quoted of him... it's kind of weird that you all worship half-cooked pizza.
Bacause everybody outside of utica ia half baked
john

Herkimer, NY

#66 Mar 6, 2014
Who the "f" CARES
Salami Hung

Utica, NY

#68 Mar 6, 2014
Larry Handiman Josheph wrote:
<quoted text>Especially when it's a ridiculous claim from the mouths of Uterines!
Cold, wet bread with tomato paste! WooOOOooo! Some 'claim to non-fame'!
Ummmmm. Yuuuuummy!

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Utica Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Is Utica used to NO NANO now? 24 min KingAndrewCuomo 22
Old Habits 27 min les 2
paul mc 31 min keep to yourself 1
top basketball players 33 min yeah 34
Why is DA McNamara's office investigated for co... 34 min bar room 19
Hillary Clinton - No good for America Shouldn't... 59 min Ganett Kimmel 1
News Utica businessman charged with arson in car exp... 1 hr WLM 5
Most over and under rated restaurants...a poll 8 hr Disappointed 20
Why was Louis Brindisi charged with harassment ... 9 hr DA Going Down 10
List of OC Pistol Permit holders now online! 10 hr SlobSmith 13

Utica Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Utica Mortgages