NY state to split into upstate and do...

NY state to split into upstate and downstate

Created by Ares Hades on Apr 7, 2009

54 votes

Click on an option to vote

YES

NO

“Historia magistra vitae est”

Level 1

Since: Feb 09

Location hidden

#1 Apr 7, 2009
differentsplit

Syracuse, NY

#2 Apr 7, 2009
I thik a better split would be taxpayer and non taxpayer. Let the people that do not contibute to the State have their own state.
Casual Observer

Westernville, NY

#3 Apr 7, 2009
I think that the law makers need to lay it all out. The cost to do it and then what the budgets would look like. For our state now and seperated, where we would make gains and where we would lose them. Also what would they be called. Upstate NY, Downstate NY? District of NY?
Where will U

Syracuse, NY

#4 Apr 7, 2009
get the $$s to pay for this new Upstate NY?

Upstate doesn't have the resources to support this type of proposal. Have you looked around lately? I only see Seniors, disabled, welfare recipents and others on the dole. No jobs to speak of, industries gone and a decaying city. Rochester, Syracuse and Buffalo are no better.

And, you're bitching about the taxes you pay now? Get Real! Don't waste any money or time on this baloney.
Hogan

United States

#5 Apr 22, 2013
Upstate has been held back by downstate for eons. Its current state is like telling a battered wife she can't do any better because she was abused for so many years and simply lacks the strength to go on her own. It's a negative feedback loop. The only way upstate will ever get any representation is by getting on its own two feet.
It has naturally been a more conservative area of the nation, and I believe the taxes will be more to the liking of its citizens. The capital is there--good universities, educated workforce, etc--let's do it!
Pleasure Kevin

Ithaca, NY

#6 Apr 22, 2013
Without downstate, upstate would basically turn into West Virginia.
downstate

Minoa, NY

#8 Apr 22, 2013
Is to dependent on upstate for water and power, I wish they would separate.
carl

United States

#9 Apr 24, 2013
This needs to happen ASAP. Down state can keep Cuomo and the liberals.
Pleasure Kevin

Ilion, NY

#10 Apr 24, 2013
downstate wrote:
Is to dependent on upstate for water and power, I wish they would separate.
And upstate is dependent for money. Without the tax base of the five boroughs and Westchester, upstate would dry up and blow away. Upstate counties receive more funding than they contribute.
Utica Region Is For Trash

Albany, NY

#12 Apr 27, 2013
Anyone in the utica area that would support being separated from downstate is a true tool.
Pleasure Kevin

United States

#13 Apr 27, 2013
Utica Region Is For Trash wrote:
Anyone in the utica area that would support being separated from downstate is a true tool.
Republicans have convinced the poor to vote against their own best interest for generations. This is no surprise.

Level 5

Since: Jul 09

Location hidden

#14 Apr 27, 2013
If upstate was such a burden then downstate would be screaming to get rid of us. While it is true that downtate pays more in taxes but in truth, how much do they really benefit us? Downstate politics hinders a lot of progress up here.

We should see if it is truly feasible to separate downstate instead of offering opinions based on little to no facts. I believe we can make up any tax shortages by selling downstate goods like water, gas and electricity. Once the super liberals are gone, upstate can vote in more business friendly laws that will prevent companies form leaving and may even create a desirable environment for manufacturing again.
Utica Region Is For Trash

Albany, NY

#15 Apr 27, 2013
NYGunman wrote:
If upstate was such a burden then downstate would be screaming to get rid of us. While it is true that downtate pays more in taxes but in truth, how much do they really benefit us? Downstate politics hinders a lot of progress up here.
We should see if it is truly feasible to separate downstate instead of offering opinions based on little to no facts. I believe we can make up any tax shortages by selling downstate goods like water, gas and electricity. Once the super liberals are gone, upstate can vote in more business friendly laws that will prevent companies form leaving and may even create a desirable environment for manufacturing again.
Downstate doesn't complain about upstate because its not relevant to them. Plus there's a need for a place to park their inmates.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Utica Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Watch out for your daughters 27 min Pygmy Orange 2
Former Oneida County Legislator changes party 36 min RINOs everywhere 1
Sama Nano Announcement Different Year 37 min Dunkin donuts 3
DRUMPF is a FAILURE, suck it up 46 min Trump said its Ri... 1
Obama flees back to Kenya as wire-tapping and t... 1 hr Hans 7
100 million for 300 jobs 1 hr Tums 23
Nano-same announcement 1 hr O no 3
New hartford is the new east utica 2 hr Human Landfill 157
How Much Does H & R Block charge To Do Your Taxes (Jan '09) 2 hr Real Rubics Cube 934
Two Utica cops beat up 15 year kid on Albany st... 2 hr kinetic kat 25
WHY Utica is a rustbelt poverty hole of FAIL. 3 hr Whitetey Nano Fail 56

Utica Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Utica Mortgages